Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Far from the Gulshan crowd

Update : 09 May 2017, 03:51 PM

When you want to refer to the elite of Dhaka city - the rich, the powerful, the poets and artists, the abroad-studying patriots, the nationalistic nihilists, the principled daughters of corrupt politicians, the activist sons of capitalistic businessmen - you say the “Gulshan crowd”.

Apologies to those who live in Banani and Baridhara. Gulshan, standing in between the elite apogee, has become the synecdoche. Gulshan-Baridhara-Banani, the heavyweights of Dhaka North, stands in unison, with its availability of multi-ethnic cuisine, its alcohol-flowing western-themed parties, its hardy-har-har conversations about world politics and modernist (if you’re above 30) and post-modernist (if you’re under) philosophy. That’s the way it goes.

On the other side of the spectrum, if you wish to refer to the tackier side of Dhaka life, the Bangla medium-goers, the restaurants named after TV shows and mythical characters, the literal middle-class, the virgins making out in shoddy lounges, you say the “Dhanmondi crowd.”

Under the banner of Dhanmondi also lie Lalmatia and Mohammadpur. One could even stretch that to include Mirpur, the black sheep of Dhaka North, cradling in it the mastaans of the city, and a danger of being mugged.

There are nooks and crannies, of course, other “types” situated across a span from Jatrabari to Uttara.

This is the way the city is separated, into cliques and groups and peoples, each comprised of qualities the other does not quite understand: A divide.

You can’t sit with us

For those who live in Dhaka, the differences are nothing new. Now, I understand that this involves generalisations depending on where people are physically located. It removes the exceptions, the individuals.

No one is saying there aren’t English medium students in Dhanmondi (in fact, some of the best schools are there), and that there aren’t tacky people in Gulshan (money can’t buy taste). But this divide speaks of a certain way the city flows.

On the surface, one group judges the other for lacking fluency in English, for example, or for being a “farm chicken”. One hosts chandelier weddings while the other has daytime “holuds” in Puran Dhaka. Both watch Bollywood, but one does so ironically, while the other does not.

But, since they remain as untouched circles in the Venn diagram of life, nothing ever changes, and everything continues to chug along

These are common tropes amongst fragments in any society. But specific to Dhaka, this divide creates pockets which prevent constructive dialogue, or room for improvement.

Each group has much to teach the other, and at the end of the day, even if not consciously, one finds oneself stuck within the same circle, patting each other on the back for believing in things everyone else already believes.

These bubbles, in which there is no disagreement, are problematic. Those who disagree are social outcasts, or are pre-emptively excluded before given a chance to explain themselves.

The bubble never bursts

And so, these bubbles continue to exist with little or no self-reflective criticism. One continues to discuss the roles of NGOs at chic North End cafes while the other “does prem” on Dhanmondi Lake. One looks down from her high horse, while the other peeks up from the gutters.

Neither listens to the other.

And, as such, the bubbles never burst. They remain intact, widening an already broadening gulch. This is ironic, considering that one, with all its penchant for activism or talk of the value of immaterial rewards, almost wishes to help the other. But, since they remain as untouched circles in the Venn diagram of life, nothing ever changes, and everything continues to chug along. They almost never meet.

How can they? The languages spoken are different. The dialect is somewhat different, so is the accent, and even if they do remain the same, most importantly, the subject matter varies. Priorities are mismatched, judgments are passed based on sex and sexual intercourse, entire communities created out of the shut-in mindsets of a select few.

Party-goers and party-poopers

Though some might see this dichotomy as nothing more than just another phenomenon, it is indicative of more than that. What is problematic in the situation is the inevitable ideological divide that festers.

Within the same space, groups of people become more and more disparate. One side’s voice gets quashed by the more “mainstream” voices of the other. The Gulshan elite, with their liberal ideals, cannot help but see the obvious lack of logic in their neighbours.

And the Dhanmondi everyman cannot help but see these ideals as Western encroachments on home turf. These are the views and opinions imported via devilish TV channels and internet celebrities, evidenced by the hedonistic flow of alcohol at Gulshan parties with their expats and their eminence grise(s).

There’s nothing wrong with any of these - as long as it or the people are not exclusionary, which they inevitably become in the very form they take.

These generalisations aren’t meant to offend per se, but to shed light on common character traits which need to be held on to a little less tightly. The presence of social wealth, which comes in the form of mainstream media acceptability, is as segregationist as other, more brutal movements in the past.

This happens without most of us knowing about it. All you have to do is look west to France or the UK, or across the Atlantic at the US.

Scarier still: Neither side has learned across all those borders, despite their so-called education, higher standards of living, and increasing numbers of resources. What will happen to us?

Or are we just so comfortable in the way this city, if not this country, has separated us, that we don’t mind letting it stay, just the way it is?

SN Rasul is an Editorial Assistant at the Dhaka Tribune.

Top Brokers