A section of overly-enthused young “Marxists” is up in arms again, this time about the outpour of grief at what was perhaps the most brutal case of mass killing perpetrated by any extremist group in this country.
With their brand of “classical Marxism,” zinged with a ruthless disregard for the barbarity in which the victims were shot, stabbed, and tortured to death, they are raising a virtual storm on Facebook, spouting the most formulaic version that this “grief” is marked by an excess, because the Bangladeshi victims happened to belong to the richest social group, and no shock and grief, they insist, is expressed when someone from the lower classes is executed or killed.
They are not alone in this, however. The storm they cook up with so much bile and bitterness is fanned by some gurus who, through their pungent columns in media, claim that the Gulshan tragedy is just “a higher class affair,” concerning merely those of the rich families that are shielded by money and cars.
They go on to claim, even more arrogantly than their young offshoots, that everything for the middle and lower classes was as usual as before, that no one from these classes has felt even an iota of threat from the attack because life for them is already too difficult with poverty, inflation, etc to be bothered with these “higher class” problems.
For those who are new to the game, this was a bit too shocking, but for those of us who are somewhere halfway along the line, it all sounds familiar.
What they are trying to get at is called “class consciousness,” which, rightly at times, interprets people’s response to an issue in terms of their economic and cultural interest vis-a-vis that given issue.
But to reduce every aspect of the Gulshan attack to economic motives seems geared more towards drifting our attention away from the issue at hand, than towards a solid attempt to untangle the grey areas in it.
To put things in the broader context of a society should not mean seeing everything through the lens of economic determinism, because to do so is to nurture no less extreme a view than the ones held by the militants; because to do so is to overlook the nuances and new dimensions of a threat that is overarching and that, roughly speaking, has been brewing up in this country since the turn of this century. Also, because the concept of identity is a complex one, to understand which, issues of race and gender are as much important as the one called class.
Those poor, illegal Bangladeshi migrants in Italy, who make ends meet selling street food, or for that matter, any Bangladeshi living in Italy or Japan or in any European country -- won’t their existence be affected after what happened at Holey Artisan Bakery? Is this an issue of class or race?
How are these hard-liners to interpret the fact that four of the five attackers of the Gulshan tragedy were from privileged families?
What economic motive did they have when they chose to kill people from, more or less, a similar class background?
What economic motive did those privileged students have when they had killed an allegedly “atheist blogger” who was from a middle class family, as Ahmed Rajib Haider evidently was?
If these set ideas were postulated truths, then why can’t we draw a coherent picture along the economic line? Why, one time, are the privileged being attacked by the privileged? Why, then, at other times, a different set of events are at play?
The most interesting contradictions, which remain unresolved to me, are to be found in the class position of those young hard-liners, who are credited in the first line of this article to be cooking up the virtual storm against the sympathisers of the rich.
Based on debates that some of their Facebook posts initiated in English, anyone could tell where they themselves belong in the economic ladder of society. What is one to make of it? What motive do they have when they critique people of their own class in such shocking terms? Are we to believe, then, that they are the only people entitled to defying the fixed rule of class consciousness?
If history is anything to go by, these hard-liners have a fondness for too much theorisation, and very little action. During the 1971 Liberation War, when genocide had become a norm, their predecessors had thought it better to shun away from it because it was “a fight between two dogs,” by which they figuratively meant the transformation of power from one capitalist group to another.
It must be noted, however, that thousands of Marxists, having a different interpretation of history, had risen to the occasion and laid down their lives for the independence of the country.
In these times, instead of throwing their weight about, what a Marxist should perhaps do is dig at the root of the problem, and see how the Gulshan attack is part of a bigger problem that has been threatening the social fabric in ways that none of us, irrespective of our class positions, should welcome in the first place.
Are we to forget those acts of violence of equal magnitude (or more?) from 2001-2006, most of which were claimed by JMB or Hizb ut-Tahrir, both claiming links to transnational Jihadist groups, and having operatives collected from either madrasas or the mainstream Bangla medium schools? It is only recently that Jihadist ideologies have found their way into English-medium schools.
Between 2001-2006, JMB and Tahrir operatives sought to eliminate our secular social fabric, calling its manifestations “un-Islamic,” like Pahela Baishakh celebrations, the baul fairs, the cultural programs of the left-leaning Udichi, the list goes on. Killing of minorities, especially of the Hindus, was a priority on their list.
Just because we have substantial evidence that IS has some presence in the
country, we should not discount JMB or Tahrir or Shibir, all of which have a long and successful track record of targeting “atheists” and “un-Islamic” programs attended by people from all walks of life.
In fact, it is very likely that JMB or Shibir men will launch more attacks on Hindu priests and temples and baul akhras since a good number of them are claimed, truly or falsely, by IS through its website.
Islamist militancy is a threat that cuts across the classes. If one is a Marxist, they should rather seek to understand how unequal wealth distribution is contributing to the growth of madrasa education on one hand, and that of English medium education on the other; how these schools, both of which have very little government monitoring and virtually no connection to the country’s heritage and history, provide any organised militant group with potential pockets of entry to brainwash the gullible lot; and why, despite economic disparities, a national platform of cultural values is a far stronger tool to begin with, to launch a movement for a better and more egalitarian Bangladesh.



