Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Do what you are least bad at

How people with disability can be productive

Update : 07 Sep 2019, 10:34 PM

Sultan Mahmud of the Bangladesh Institute of Social Research has told us in this newspaper that disabled people can be income-earning and productive members of our society. This is entirely true. 

The trick we need to use is the same one we use to have a richer society in the first place -- the division of labour. 

That is, yet again, Adam Smith had the answer to our modern-day problem. Not all that bad for a European who has been dead these two centuries and counting now.

It’s entirely true that we’ll not send one-legged pole vaulters to the Olympics, the blind policewoman might not be put on traffic duty, and a deaf piano tuner sounds less than helpful. 

And yet a blind piano tuner was a commonplace for a century and more in my native Britain. Of course, a modicum of musical ability was required, but once established, it was standard practice to train the truly blind in how to adjust these musical instruments. 

In those days before widespread TV especially, any house with even the mildest pretensions to entertainment would contain a piano. They need tuning regularly, and thus there was a good living to be made from being the local tuner.

That being the secret of how to deal with any and every disability. To find out where it matters and where it doesn’t. As Smith would have pointed out -- he died before the invention of the piano by the way -- we can use the division and specialization of labour. 

We each work on being particularly good at the one or two things, produce those, then swap across society with those who have also specialized. 

This doesn’t have to be limited to pin factories, any specialization works. As does dividing any and every form of labour.

Exactly when we do this, we can assign tasks to those with the skills suited to them.

In the Smithian world, this is what creates economic wealth for all of us. It was David Ricardo who took the idea further. He called it a comparative advantage, which has been called the one non-trivial and non-obvious finding in all of the social sciences. 

This usually gets applied to international trade, but that’s just a special case of the idea. It’s usually stated as we should all do what we’re best at and then trade the results.

This has a problem, because people start to think, well, but I’m not “the best” at anything. So what can I do? That’s something else, that’s an absolute advantage. 

Comparative advantage can be taken to mean better than other people. But that’s not actually the strength of the insight. What we really mean is what, among the things that I could do, am I best at doing it?

To make this even clearer we should invert the idea: What is it that I am least bad at? Then that’s the thing that I should be doing. It would, for example, be possible to employ me as a piano tuner. 

As I’m tone-deaf, that wouldn’t work very well but there we are. Perhaps I could be, as I have been, a broker of strange and weird metals. I wasn’t all that bad at that. So, what is it that I’m least bad at? Metals, not piano tuning. So, I should work with metals then.

When we apply this to everyone, we, therefore, get everyone applying their talents to what they are best at. That is, among the various things they could be doing, what is it that they’re least bad at? 

We thus get the maximum possible production of everything, because everyone is using their talents, whatever they are, to the maximum possible.

Note three interesting results of this. Everything that is produced will be consumed. Therefore, if we’ve maximized the use of the talents of everyone then we can consume more than in any other arrangement – we’re richer. 

Secondly, we already have a method for determining all of this -- market economy. But the most important, and third, observation is that this makes the disabled no different from all the rest of us. Sure, so, there are certain things someone disabled cannot do. 

That’s the very meaning of “disability,” the lack of ability. But we’ve all got things we’re terrible at doing. Our aim and goal are to find out what is it that we’re not so terrible at doing and then to go and do that. The difference between this and someone else and their abilities is what?

Sultan Mahmud is entirely correct that the disabled can -- should even -- become entirely productive and income-earning members of society. The method by which we achieve this is exactly the same as we achieve that same goal for everyone else. 

We each do what we’re least bad at, swap the resultant production, and we’re all collectively as rich as we can possibly be.

Top Brokers