Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Caught in a trap

Micro-credit doesn’t always pull people out of poverty

Update : 29 May 2019, 09:36 PM

“Micro-finance recognizes that poor people are remarkable reservoirs of energy and knowledge. And while the lack of financial services is a sign of poverty, today it is also understood as an untapped opportunity to create markets, bring people in from the margins and give them the tools with which to help themselves,” said Kofi Annan, former United Nations secretary-general. 

Micro-credit is widely accepted worldwide, as it has first-hand positive impacts on school enrollment, women’s empowerment, better nutrition, and household incomes. 

However, there is a saying that nothing in the world is without critics. Micro-credit scheme has also some limitations. Micro-credit schemes offer small loans to people who do not usually have access to conventional banking credit, for many, micro-credit is a lifeline. 

However, as most of them are not good at financial management, they fail to avail the proper use of it. Eventually, they are unable to repay their loans. Critics of micro-credit argue that borrowers can quickly sink into a cycle of debt.

My mother used to take help of a female neighbour for household chores. Yesterday, she expressed her concern that despite having good wages, her neighbour left the job. It is revealed that she had to flee away from her house to escape from paying the installments of micro-credit of different non-profit organizations. 

It reminded me of a tragic story about a rickshaw-puller from Bogra, who said that he was a farmer but ultimately turned into a rickshaw-puller to pay the installments of micro-credit. We often read on the news that parents, farmers, mothers, etc commit suicide with their kids to escape the agony of paying the installments of micro-credit.

In an interview with BBC, Dr Qazi Kholikuzzaman Ahmad, chairman of Palli Karma Sahayak Foundation (PKSF), a body that monitors micro-finance, describes micro-credit as a “death trap" for the poor.

NGOs and other micro-finance institutions lend money to people under, by and large, 14 business models. Among them Grameen model, group model, individual model, NGO model, peer pressure model are popular in Bangladesh. 

Apparently, in their face, these business models are fantastic. However, if we deeply evaluate these business models, then we would find that these models did not facilitate high-return investments among the poor or lead to transformative results on average for income or long-term consumption. 

As its advocates claimed, there is no proof that micro-credit investments contribute to borrowers’ profits or household incomes. NGOs and micro-finance institutions hardly monitor or supervise what borrowers actually do with the loan money. 

As most of the borrowers have no financial management capacity, they barely invest the money as per the business model. Rather, they use it for consumption and to pay daily expenses. 

So it becomes tough for them to pay the installments of the loan accordingly. In this way, micro-credit loans become a burden for them, and may make their lives worse, not better. 

Critics argue that micro-finance should not be designed to target the ultra poor. In micro-credit loans, poverty due to deprivation is replaced with poverty due to debt. They claimed that the poor are exploited under the garb of helping.

Micro-credit schemes become popular for their benevolent and inclusive business models. The proponent and advocates of micro-credit finance claimed that:

  • Micro-credit elevates people from the vicious poverty cycle by boosting their entrepreneurial potential 
  • Micro-finance institutes provide employment to the masses 
  • It empowers women
  • It has an immediate financial impact on the clients 
  • Improves the socio-political position of the poor, allowing them to be egalitarian 
  • Serves those who are often overlooked in society
  • Creates the possibility of future investments

I would like to state that I am not against the concept of micro-credit -- I think it is a great way to empower the poor; but it is also important to understand the negatives of this initiative, so that moving forward, countries can mend the mistakes that are being conducted to make a better rounded action plan.


Shahnewaj Patwari is an advocate and social worker. You can reach him at [email protected].

Top Brokers