Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

A global political commitment

The Responsibility to Protect applies to both citizens and stateless people

Update : 01 Oct 2018, 06:42 PM

At the UN this past week, Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina repeated her call to world leaders to ensure the safe return of Rohingya refugees to Myanmar, whilst demanding further international assistance and diplomatic pressure to mitigate what is clearly a man-made crisis. 

Yet, there are those who feel that the UN has no right to interfere in a matter of national sovereignty.

The sovereignty argument by General Min Aung Hlaing is not new to this world -- it is a classic go-to for authoritarian figures, and in the period of internationalization following the post-Cold War era, has been analyzed in subjective, rather than theoretical, terms by global actors. 

Whatever one feels about the idea of nation states and its leaders upholding the sovereignty of its territorial boundaries, there remains little to no doubt that human rights violators have absolutely no right to hide behind the whims of sovereignty as a norm.

And the existence of a global mechanism called “responsibility to protect” (R2P) reminds us of the duties and abilities of the international community to ensure that human security forms the core of any and all development, progress, and cooperation. 

Whilst R2P has its flaws and has been used strategically by hegemonic powers to achieve military and economic wants, this global norm carries weight, and should be looked into as a possible vantage point to ensure mitigation to the Rohingya crisis.

Endorsed by all member states of the UN in 2005, R2P refers to an international political commitment which aims to address concerns to prevent genocide, war crimes, ethnic cleansing, and crimes against humanity. 

The foundation of R2P is observed from the notion that the concept of sovereignty is intertwined with the responsibility to protect human populations from mass atrocity crimes and human rights violations.

R2P provides an institutional architecture to employ measures which already exist to ensure that human security is respected -- including mediation, economic sanctions, and, controversially, military action. However, the selective use of R2P in countries like Libya and Syria have given way to questions as to the viability of this norm -- nevertheless, the problem lies not with the global commitment itself or the stated mechanisms that can be used.

In fact, military force is seen as a last ditch attempt towards humanitarian intervention -- and under the umbrella of the UN endorsed R2P, powerful nations have misused and mischaracterized this norm for their own benefit. 

Nevertheless, according to one of the longest ever produced and meticulously detailed UN report by a human rights inquiry -- the Myanmar military, as a core component of the country’s state hierarchy, is directly responsible for systematically targeting civilians, and for establishing a climate of impunity amongst their soldiers.

Phrases such as a “textbook example of ethnic cleansing” only magnify the gravity of the crisis -- and the call to bring the Myanmar military chiefs, and by association, the Nobel Prize-winning Aung San Suu Kyi, to accountability and justice, has grown. 

Therefore, in such a scenario, hiding behind the aegis of sovereignty is impossible. The UN as a body and its member states have a responsibility to invoke the clauses, such as early mediation, and the possibility of stronger economic sanctions, if not R2P in its full-fledged form, to ensure that individuals like General Min Aung Hlaing do not have the ability to say that the international community has no right to interfere.

The numbers are staggering and are often repeated -- but one needs to remind the global society of its continued failure in ensuring human security. Over one million people have fled to Bangladesh, and a sizeable portion are dependent upon humanitarian and foreign aid, and over 80% of these refugees are women and children.

It is a failure of the Myanmar government and its military to ensure that its territorial resources were protected. What are visible are the attempts made by those in power to escalate this form of violence, and create deep-seated divisions in between religious groups in the country. 

If this is not a prime case for international intervention in whichever form one sees it, the idea of sovereignty needs to be re-visited, because at no cost should the UN -- a body which has been criticized for failing to perform in crucial historical moments -- hide behind diplomatic corridors while millions suffer the wrath of a draconian quasi-military backed regime.

And the less said about the iconic Aung San Suu Kyi the better. We would rather remember her as a promoter of peace, but her inability to address the situation in Rakhine is an indicator of her weakness as a leader, and has provided a catastrophic dent to what was once a celebrated legacy. 

The Rohingya crisis cannot be tackled with international military intervention, this is off the table and should not be considered, given the severe failures of Libya, Syria, and Kenya. But R2P as a norm can be used and invoked by global powers, with targeted economic and political sanctions against the Myanmar regime.

R2P applies to both citizens and stateless people, and as such, the Rohingya cannot be ignored on the basis of both international law and a commitment by all nation states within the UN to sustain human life.

To be the most persecuted ethnic group in the world, and simultaneously continue suffering due to the bureaucracy of global diplomatic agendas is baffling and unbecoming of what a global society should look like. It is time to step up the game against the Myanmar military, and invoking international legal instruments against them should be on the table, front and centre. 

Mir Aftabuddin Ahmed is a graduate of Economics and International Relations from the University of Toronto.

Top Brokers