This year is the 20th year of the adoption of the UN declaration of human rights defenders (HRDs).
The declaration is an important tool for HRDs as it recognizes their work, focuses on the need for their protection, and also emphasizes the responsibility of the state to ensure the protection of HRDs. 2018 is also the 70th year of the adoption of the universal declaration of human rights (UDHR).
It is important that the third universal periodic review of Bangladesh is going to take place at the UN Human Rights Council at such a significant moment. The upcoming review of Bangladesh is being considered by many HRDs as an important opportunity despite the inherent limitations of the UPR process as a peer review by governments.
Yet, HRDs in Bangladesh hope that the review will be able to highlight the situation they are facing. This review is also a test to watch and observe how seriously the work of the HRDs are really taken into consideration by the government and by international human rights communities.
The situation of human rights defenders did not get much attention during the previous two cycles of the UPR. There were no specific recommendations targeted for HRDs in the first cycle in 2009. During the second cycle in 2013, Bangladesh received 196 recommendations, out of which only one recommendation, made by Norway, was directly related to HRDs: “Step up its efforts to ensure that HRDs are protected and allowed to conduct their work without hindrance, intimidation, or harassment, both at the national and local level.”
Bangladesh did accept this recommendation. However, the five years subsequent to the review demonstrated probably the hardest time for the HRDs in Bangladesh.
Under the UPR process, the state, under review, submits its national report, while civil society organizations from home and abroad and the national human rights commission have the opportunity to submit alternative reports, called the stake-holders’ submission, and UN agencies also make their input.
Several stakeholders’ reports have highlighted the situation of HRDs in Bangladesh.
For example, Front Line Defenders, an international organization working for the protection of human rights defenders, stated, in their UPR submission, that they have documented 15 killings of HRDs between May 2013 and October 2017.
It said: “What began in 2013 as an assault on bloggers sharing secular views and criticizing the influence of fundamental Islam on Bangladeshi politics, transitioned into a lethal environment for HRDs advocating for human rights-related reforms to which those pushing a fundamentalist Islamic agenda were opposed.”
The International Service for Human Rights (ISHR), together with Bangladeshi organizations, recommended to “develop and enact specific laws and policies to recognize and protect HRDs.”
The inclusion of human rights defenders in the report is, of course, a positive sign, as this is the first time the government has talked about HRDs in their national report to the UPR
The government submitted its state party report on February 8. The full report was neither shared on any occasion nor made available to the public even after submission to the UN. We were only able to access it when it was uploaded on the UN website.
Pleasantly surprised, we were happy to see that the state party report has added a paragraph under the title “human rights defenders,” where it has been stated that cases were lodged in regard to the reported incidents of assaults on three human rights defenders, including Ms Sultana Kamal -- one of the most prominent human rights activists of the country.
The inclusion of human rights defenders in the report is, of course, a positive sign, as this is the first time the government has talked about HRDs in their national report to the UPR. However, it is still not certain which three cases of assaults on HRDs the report refers to.
In fact, there were several incidents of killings, assaults, threats, harassment against several HRDs, including the killings of several activist bloggers and free thinkers, the killing of LGBT activist Xulhaz Mannan and Mahbub Tonoy, the killing of CHT activist Mithun Chakma, death threats made against Anu Muhammad, the arrest of Prabir Sikder, Binoy Krishna Mallik, Joly Talukder, and other trade union leaders, the physical assault on Rani Yen Yen, the abduction of Mubashar Hasan, the two Hill Women Federation activists Monti Chakma and Doyasona -- just to mention a few.
As the government has specifically referred to the case of Sultana Kamal, we spoke to her recently, and she said that she herself did not file any cases, nor is she aware of the government filing any such case.
While some leaders of the religious extremist groups were publicly threatening her and there were threats and smear campaigns against her on social media, the law enforcement agencies, to our knowledge, did not make any move to file a case or take any action against the hate campaigners.
Monti Chakma and Doyasona have luckily returned after a month and even named some of the abductors -- yet no action has been taken from law enforcement agencies.
These are but a few examples which show how uncertain the situation is in Bangladesh for HRDs currently.
The role of the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) is equally frustrating. While the state report has, at least, included the issue of human rights defenders, NHRC did not talk about anything specifically relating to HRDs in their UPR submission. While NHRCs the world over are considered as the “defender of defenders,” in Bangladesh it does not seem to be so.
Sayeed Ahmad is a Human Rights Defender.



