Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

For democracy to flourish

Update : 10 Apr 2018, 07:42 AM
We have modelled our democracy on the British parliamentary system, but we have still a long way go to reach perfection. A political system is not to be imposed on a people, but the people must be gradually readied first for it. Thrusting anything on a people unprepared is bound to cause malfunction. Islam teaches gradual implementation. The Qur’an had been revealed over a period of 23 years. The Prophet (SM) gradually introduced rituals, familiarizing his followers with new additions over a period of time. British democracy started from Magna Carta in 1215, as we all know, and matured over time. Peoples’ mental makeup also evolved gradually. By democracy, we only understand the regular election of parliament, periodically, nothing more. The campaigning for voting is a divisive process. Candidates are bound to highlight the worst in others -- certainly not a unifier. It creates bitterness between people in such levels that reconciliation is difficult. General elections do create that kind of bitterness among political parties -- even their members become enemies. And while political divisiveness may divide the population, it cannot break a nation. However, in a political party under today’s reality, a nascent democracy can hardly absorb the shock of a fierce fight. That would surely leave wounds behind beyond repair. In a big organization, small cohesive groups compete constantly for ascendancy in hierarchy. In that case, the tension remains simmering beneath. In an open election especially, if all factions are almost equally strong, the winner would find it difficult to run the party and the party may even break in factional lines. Therefore, we think it is still not time to have pure electoral democracy in a political party not yet mature. We need political parties to run a modern democracy. However, we may exercise controlled democracy, where at every stage the party executives are elected without any open canvassing and electioneering, and multiple candidates are selected by a committee (or committees) after evaluating their reports filed by leadership at different stages. This system sounds like a system currently in place in ultra-right parties. We may do the fine-tuning as required.Islam and democracy Democracy is something that comes through practice, not through martial law regulations. In a democracy, a constitution is of supreme importance. All activities of the state needs be referred to the constitution to verify their rightness or wrongness. As there is nothing above the constitution other than God’s law, in a conflict, God’s law prevails when we accept religion at state levels, and our state religion is Islam. As such, all our laws are made subordinate to Islamic law. As soon as Islam is introduced in the constitution, it theoretically takes precedence over everything else, leaving only the followers of other religions free to exercise their religion without any hindrance whatsoever. It is the solemn duty of the majority of Muslims to provide all help to them in their exercise of religious rituals and protection to their lives and property. 
For democracy to flourish we need peace and stability. Revolution or violence is not the way to democratize a populace
This is the secularistic provision in Islam. Definitely, in the matters of Muslims, the Qur’an and Hadith become the controlling canons, and ideally all laws repugnant to Sharia become ineffective. As Islam is secular, there is no contradiction of secularism with Islam -- in fact it becomes redundant in the constitution. Democracy itself is said to be in contradiction with Islam. In fact, if we closely examine the election of the first Caliph of Islam, Hazrat Abu Bakr (RA), we see people taking the oath of allegiance, kissing his hand. That process can be easily expanded to modern day election. Obviously with the increase of population and to ensure participation of as many adult citizens as possible, we need modern day innovations.Developing democracy All our economic activities basically stem out of the necessity to feed our hunger and desires. As such, all our endeavours are directed towards the development of ourselves. When we talk of development, it includes physical, mental, and spiritual developments. Democracy and all other means are only vehicles for development of humans. Therefore, without manifesting development, democracy becomes meaningless. Democracy is only a vehicle to ensure peace and justice in a polity, so that stability persists and unhindered progress is made. However, humans have been making progress constantly, and have endeavoured to establish rule of law throughout history. In all modes of governing, democracy is the most recent and yet untested in most of the world. Even in advanced democracies, it is becoming a two-party rule, like in the UK and the US. We talk of multi-party democracy, but a closely represented parliament is also a hindrance to stability, as in Italy and Nepal. Democratically elected governments can also turn into autocracy -- the best example is Hitler’s Germany. In this sub-continent, we have seen dictators ruling through military might, usurping power. We therefore have to look at the present form of democracy more closely to close its loopholes and tune it to our particular needs. What works and what doesn’tWe have already experimented with a caretaker government, and that proved to be inadequate and almost disastrous to democracy, in the hands of unelected military and civil bureaucrats. We cannot risk more disastrous consequences in the hands of the unelected. Therefore, we must remain within the constitution and devise ways to take our nascent democracy forward without hindering the present pace of development. To take democratic advancement forward and keep the pace of development, we need uninterrupted peaceful stability and we cannot afford to have blockades and violence. However, a robust and viable democracy needs constant monitoring of the government’s activities, causing it to remain within bounds and not turn into a despotic entity. Present day technical advancement gives us excellent tools to keep a watch on the government. Social media is a powerful medium to influence people. It is very efficient in forming ideas and changing our perception about issues. The mighty drawback is its unbound misuse. Lies are used to wrongly influence people’s minds, and unsuspecting uninformed masses that constitute the majority are susceptible to fall prey to such unethical propaganda. We need democracy, and democracy needs development. For democracy to flourish, we need peace and stability. Revolution or violence is not the way to democratize a populace. We are lucky -- we have a democracy, though faulty and exploitable. What we need now is not drastic change or violent upheavals, but peaceful measures to fine-tune the existing system to our needs, remaining within the constitution.  Any extra constitutional measure may bring immediate relief, but not permanent solution. We need to be strictly within the constitution and bring in reforms gradually.Mir Mahboob Ali is an author and fiction writer. He is a former senior executive at The Bangladesh Observer.
Top Brokers