After carefully analysing the environment impact assessment, Kallol Mustafa correctly concluded that “although the EIA report has tried to justify the Rampal coal power plant near the Sundarbans by using wrong emission standards, underestimating various adverse impacts, not specifying impact in many cases, using words such as ‘unlikely,’ ‘hardly,’ ‘very little,’ ‘may,’ ‘may not,’ etc, the impacts of construction and operation of the coal-based power plants on the Sundarbans’ eco-system documented in the EIA are enough to call off the project immediately.”
Process of deception
Thirdly, from their work map, the very intention of the governments of both countries can be questioned.
Years before the EIA was done, 1,834 acres of land, which were mostly agricultural and shrimp aquaculture pond, had been acquired for the proposed 1,320MW power plant project. That was done by the government without the consent of the people, and with force by the police and local thugs.
Moreover, if we look at the chronology of events, it would be clear that the EIA process was merely an eyewash, used as an instrument to rationalise a pre-determined project. The events took place as follows.
Land acquisition order for this power plant was issued on December 27, 2010 -- more than two years before the EIA was completed.
Before the EIA was approved, the joint venture agreement to set up the power plant was signed between Indian company NTPC and Bangladeshi company PDB on January 29, 2012.
The EIA was published on January 2013 in the PDB website for public opinion. Experts and some concerned organisations submitted their opinion in due time. They rejected the EIA. A public consultation was arranged by PDB on April 12, 2013.
The experts present there identified serious problems with the EIA; they categorically rejected the EIA, and asked the government to stop all activities before another independent EIA was completed.
A week later, two government representatives signed the final agreement (on April 20, 2013) -- the Implementation Agreement (IA) and Power Purchase Agreement (PPA).
Moreover, Bangladesh government made the special decision to allow the Indian side to get a tax waiver on its share of profit from the proposed plant. Bangladesh will purchase “NTPC’s stakes at a price evaluated by an independent Indian firm.
“Earlier, the PDB had relaxed the Liquidated Damage (LD) and Performance Guarantee (PG) clauses, along with Corporate Guarantee, for implementing the Rampal power project.”
Therefore, whatever happens to the Sundarbans, the Indian company’s huge profit is ensured.
India is violating its own law
The spokespersons of the governments of Bangladesh and India have been asserting on the point that no damage will be done to the Sundarbans since super critical technology will be used in this project.
The question remains, why couldn’t the use of technology justify the coal-based power plants in India, eg in Tamil Nadu, Madhya Pradesh, and Orissa, which were cancelled due to environmental concern?
According to the EIA, the distance of the proposed Rampal coal-based power plant from the Sundarbans mangrove forest is 14km, which they claim as a safe distance.
But the EIA guideline manual for coal-based thermal power plants prepared by the Indian Ministry of Environment and Forest in August 2010 clearly states that the “locations of thermal power stations are avoided within 25km of the outer periphery of the following: Metropolitan cities, national parks and wildlife sanctuaries, ecologically sensitive areas like tropical forests, biosphere reserves, important lakes, and coastal areas rich in coral formation.”
That means the Indian state-owned NTPC is pursuing the Rampal project by violating its own principle and legal restrictions.
Nevertheless, the Indian government is pushing for that. No company, including the NTPC, will be allowed to implement similar or much less disastrous projects in India.
The government’s claim about the distance of the proposed plant, 14km from the forest, has also been contested by the experts.
For instance, geographer AKM Wahiduzzaman and Mohammad Tawsif Salam gathered their findings through geographical information system (GIS) software and exhibited that this distance is between 9km and 13km, which they elaborately explained in “Rampal Electricity Plant and our Environmental Consciousness.”
The more worrying fact is that if we consider a buffer zone, crucial for preservation of forest life, this distance goes down further to 4km.
People against grabbing and mass destruction
In the larger Sundarbans area, several corporate houses already built billboards declaring their new profit-making ventures. New projects on shipyard, ship-breaking, five-star hotels, and aggressive tourism are in the air.
It is also heard that gas exploration and security installations are also in the planning process by relevant authorities. So, an all-out attack on the Sundarbans and the country has been in the making for a while now.
While visiting Bangladesh a few months back, the president of India urged that both India and Bangladesh should work unitedly to protect the Sundarbans.
In reality, the governments of both the countries are working for the very opposite.
The huge and vital forest is spread over into both India and Bangladesh. Therefore, people of the two countries should be united to resist the Rampal coal-fired power plant to save the Sundarbans.
In order to protect the lives and livelihood of millions of people, and the world’s largest mangrove forest -- a natural defence system against natural disasters, extremely important bio-diversity -- we have no other way but to resist any project that is disastrous to the Sundarbans.
Concerned people express their main argument regarding the Rampal power plant in one sentence: “There are many alternatives for power generation, but there is no alternative for the Sundarbans.”
People of Bangladesh are gathering to save the Sundarbans. Indians and the world should join them to save this World Heritage Site.



