Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Mosque and state

Update : 21 Mar 2016, 06:03 PM

The best thing about Dhaka on a Friday -- at least, until the evening -- is how vacant the streets are. Too tired by a five-day, nine-plus-hour work week, the denizens sleep in and rest. Even as I go out, the lack of vehicles, despite a hot almost-summer day, keeps the heat bearable.

And because there aren’t as many obstructions -- and I don’t know if I actually feel this or imagine it -- there seems to be a slight breeze blowing through the winding streets of this fast imploding behemoth of a city.

Last week, on a Friday as free as an imaginary Dhaka, I was going from Bangla Motor towards Dhanmondi. And, also because it was a Friday, my rickshaw took the main road in front of Bashundhara City, with there being no khaki-clad police chamcha to exhort Tk5 from us.

We moved through smoothly and fluidly until we hit Panthapath masjid. Even as we went past the mosque situated on Bashundhara road, we could pass the quickly encroaching mats of the Jumma prayers.

As we got to the mosque right opposite Bashundhara City, however, the prayer mats had taken over all across the street.

There was one single lane, bottlenecking the flow of traffic, of slow-moving cars, motorcycles, and rickshaws but, almost as we were about to go past the columns of Jumma-goers, the more inconsiderate of the bunch blocked it from the front. And, for the next 30 minutes, we waited as the namaaz went on, sitting in one singular column of traffic.

Don’t get me wrong: I have nothing against Jumma prayers. And I’ll take the criticism of those who consider me in the wrong for skipping them.

But should the people, merely because there aren’t enough mosques or enough space in mosques, be allowed to infiltrate the streets so that people who aren’t part of the religion are made to suffer?

What if I had to be somewhere at a particular time, what if I had an appointment to keep, what if I was in an ambulance taking my loved one to the hospital because they were in dire condition and that was the fastest way to get to Square Hospital? What if I was a member of another religion?

That is not to say members of other religious sects cannot enjoy the celebrations of Islam and vice versa, cannot learn to appreciate the beauty that can be found within the religion. Or to say that one should have any expectations of reaching anywhere on time when one is an experienced member of Dhaka city.

But why should citizens take it upon themselves to encroach upon public property? Would the rest of the city, or even country, take it so lightly if it was another religion that was taking over the streets, another culture’s celebrations preventing them from reaching their destination?

That is to say nothing of what happens in front of Sobhanbag Masjid, where police themselves block the street and make the other side a highly congested two-way street.

In a secular nation (which, it is becoming clear, this is not), shouldn’t there be -- if I may borrow this Western term -- a separation of mosque and state? Or is that too much to ask from a country that is so vehemently lying about itself to the rest of the world about its state as being pro-co-existence?

This indubitably brings up the question of freedom and how far we should go to cater to secular rights. Should we then not have any religious holidays?

And if we do, if we are meant to treat each citizen equally, shouldn’t each religion get equal treatment in the calendar?

That would be unrealistic, perhaps.

We have gone too far beyond the point, or live too enmeshed in a culture that celebrates segregation, or sees people who are different from us as just that: Different.

This speaks for a culture that is very sure of its dominance within the national playing field, and doesn’t care for other minorities who may wish to live as freely and as openly as they do.

That is why, every time a blogger gets killed or a temple gets bombed, there is an awkward silence. Half the people are outraged while the rest are thinking, maybe silently, that it doesn’t really matter as much as “our” mosque, “our” religion, and “our” people.

Or maybe most people, when given the chance, will strive only to serve their own agenda, will be inconsiderate to the woes of the weak and I was just caught in the crossfire, stuck in traffic when I didn’t need to be, because I, like so many other people, am tired and exhausted of being rooted to the same spot for too long.

Is that too much of a stretch, or are the streets of Dhaka on a Friday afternoon a microcosm of things to come? 

Top Brokers