Recently the Supreme Court, the highest judiciary body of Bangladesh, decided to uphold the death sentence to former Al-Badr commander Mir Quasem Ali. While the attorney general reiterated that justice was served, I decided to ask few of my friends about their opinions on this matter.
Some of them, being educated in the West -- self-proclaimed liberals -- criticised me for expecting the highest punishment permitted by our legal system even for war criminals.
I failed to understand this liberal philosophy. Since when did we stop sympathising for the victims and start caring about the criminals?
When has this question “do you support capital punishment” become our ultimate test of morality? It would be cowardly of me if I keep my stance a secret so that I am not despised among liberal friends of mine.
Most of the people who object to capital punishment do so because they believe the punishment itself is morally reprehensible.
The common moral objection I hear is that, wouldn’t we as a state, descend to the criminal’s level if we allow death penalty for murderers? Absolutely not.
The state is not punishing an innocent person, but rather, providing fair justice to the families who have lost their loved ones by punishing the criminal.
Some of them would want to see the state’s right to sentence the death penalty repealed, even for the gravest crime.
In fact, Article-6 of the ICCPR (International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights) preserves the state’s right to use the death penalty in the cases of the most serious crimes.
Although more countries are moving towards abolishing capital punishment, the world’s two largest democracies (the US and India) still retain the capital punishment, and almost two-thirds of the world’s population still lives in places (top four populous countries: China, India, the US, and Indonesia) where capital punishment is permitted.
But is it immoral to ask for the death penalty even for the worst crimes? What I would try to do is to examine the morality of the punishment through Bentham’s utilitarian principle and Immanuel Kant’s categorical moral reasoning, and let readers make an informed argument about the issue.
According to Jeremy Bentham, the father of modern utilitarianism, the action that maximises utility is the best moral action: “It is the greatest happiness of the greatest number that is the measure of right and wrong.”
A Benthamite would support capital punishment, only when the benefits to the society outweigh the suffering of the person who committed the crime. One obvious benefit would be that the death penalty will prevent future murders due to its deterrent effects.
There are several studies which show that the death penalty actually reduces homicides. Why would we not want to execute murderers if it protects fellow innocent citizens from being killed in the future?
As Ernest Van Den Haag, professor of jurisprudence at Fordham University, puts it: “Common sense, lately bolstered by statistics, tells us that the death penalty will deter murder. People fear nothing more than death.
Therefore, nothing will deter a criminal more than the fear of death and life in prison is less feared. Murderers clearly prefer it to execution -- otherwise, they would not try to be sentenced to life in prison instead of a death sentence.
Therefore, a life sentence must be less deterrent than a death sentence.
And we must execute murderers as long as it is merely possible that their execution protects citizens from future murder.”
Immanuel Kant, often regarded as the most influential scholar of modern philosophy, rejects the utilitarian logic of punishing criminals for two reasons: First, he believes it treats criminals as a tool to achieve others’ good; Kant’s categorical reasoning prohibits this. Second, the utilitarian theory could justify punishing an innocent person to promote general welfare.
In The Metaphysics of Morals, Kant absolutely insists on capital punishment for murderers.
According to Kant: “Whoever has committed murder, must die, because no matter how difficult life might be, it is still better than death.”
Kant goes even further by arguing that if a state does not sentence a murderer to death, eventually it becomes an accomplice to the crime.



