Among the issues discussed in debates by the current pack of US presidential hopefuls, of both parties, foreign policy is one of the hotter topics.
Each candidate has expressed his or her iron will in formulating a strategy for the eradication of terrorism and, of course, sternly dealing with the rising menace of Islamic militancy in the Middle East.
Some candidates, notably Donald Trump on the Republican side and Bernie Sanders from the Democratic, have been very vocal in putting the blame for the current crisis in the Middle East and the rise of the militant state on the Iraq war.
And that discussion has led one of the Presidential hopefuls, Ted Cruz, to suggest that maybe the Middle East was better off in the past, governed by dictators. Did Ted Cruz make a Freudian slip, saying something that many might have been thinking subconsciously?
It’s hard to imagine that the vast swath of territory, commonly known as the Middle East, that straddles two continents and comprises 10 different countries, was a generally docile place a decade ago, where hardly any political commotion took place.
The occasional murmurs of protest here and there were quickly put down or were never heard even inside the countries themselves.
The heads of government in Egypt, Iraq, Libya, Syria, Tunisia, and other neighbouring countries ruled with an iron grip for decades, with nary a threat to their regimes, and the rest of the world was none the worse for what happened in those countries with the dictators.
There would be some reports of human rights abuse and suppression of freedom of speech, carried by the liberal media in the West, but generally, the Western governments looked the other way as their national interests were not at stake.
But that was until Saddam Hussain was toppled after the US invasion of Iraq in 2003, ending his long rule of nearly a quarter of a century.
Although an end to Saddam’s rule was brought upon by a war launched on Iraq to punish him for his support to terrorists, and harbouring so-called “weapons of mass destruction,” the end to his long rule opened a Pandora’s Box of decades of trouble, not only in Iraq but also adjoining areas.
The demise of Saddam brought an end to his iron rule but it also released internal forces of sectarian opposition and ethnic hostilities that Saddam and his Baathist party had ruthlessly suppressed.
The end to the Saddam regime did not usher in a new dawn of democracy and freedom for the Iraqi citizens, it pushed them to a new era of mayhem and complete breakdown of law and order that ended in civil war between Shias and Sunnis, Iraqis and Kurds, and gave birth to militant Islamists seeking to establish a new order.
While Iraq battled one crisis after another with a weak government and a ragtag army that was completely depleted of its former ferocity, a new wave of popular movement against dictatorial regimes pounded the shores of other Middle Eastern countries.
A revolutionary wave of demonstrations and protests (both non-violent and violent), riots, and civil wars in the Arab world -- the Arab Spring -- would spread from one end of that region to another beginning with Tunisia and running through Egypt, Libya, Syria, and Yemen.
By the end of February 2012, four rulers had been forced from power (Tunisia, Egypt, Libya, and Yemen) and one ruler (Syria) was fiercely fighting his existence while losing territories to rebel forces.
There were other civil uprisings that had erupted in the region, but these subsided because of lack of support from the general population and, more importantly, the armed forces.
Today, the Arab Spring has turned into the Arab Winter for its spectacular failure in bringing about the changes the protestors wanted.
Except Tunisia, almost all of the countries that cheerfully toppled their regimes in the hope of democracy, freedom, and individual liberty are still fighting internecine civil wars, breakdown of law and order, and are living a nightmarish existence.
After four decades of economic progress, earned primarily through oil revenue and a stable albeit ruthless government, Libya is in shambles now.
It is practically a country without a formal government as it is divided in two parts -- one under a legally-elected government and the other seized by militants who call themselves Islamic state.
Yemen, where a popular upsurge led its autocratic president agree to surrender power in 2011, has now become a failed state after the hostilities between Shia Houthis and the government forces broke out in 2013.
The country has practically no government, as war between the Shia rebels and the Sunni controlled government forces aided by Saudi Arabia ravages the country.
After a short period of democracy in Egypt, where a new government was installed after the country’s first free and fair elections after Hosni Mubarak, the army stepped in to put down another set of civil riots against the new government.
The country is back under a former army chief who formed a new government after fresh elections that many think were engineered.
The survival of this last bastion of dictatorial regime has been possible mainly due to lack of a united action plan among Western powers on the disposal of the Assad regime, and support to the regime given by Iran and Russia.
This ambiguity among Western powers, as well as the breakdown of Iraq as a unified country, helped grow a third front in Syria -- the Islamic State -- which was able to solidify its strength by occupying territories of a fractured Iraqi state and parts of strife-torn Syria.
This new entity has cast itself as a force more dreadful and threatening than President Assad and his government.
The dilemma for the West now is who to get rid of first, a dictator who is suppressing only his own people, or a militant group that threatens the whole region, as well as the West itself?
No one knows when and if peace will return to the Middle East and the lives of people there will go back to as it was decades ago.
It is cynical to suggest that these countries were better off with dictators. It is decades of iron rule and suppression that has brought the countries to where they find themselves today.
But it is tempting to long for those days for its citizens because they had roofs over their heads, and they did not have to leave their homes for work with fear of death looming over their heads.
That day will probably return, but only after the citizens in those countries get unified to fight the enemies of sectarian and ethnic strife that afflict them now.



