Powers seem to have decided that it is time to cut down to size the two largest newspapers that are still a critical voice.
With smooth timing and synchronicity, a campaign has apparently begun against Mahfuz Anam, the editor of the largest English newspaper. On the exact week of the English newspaper’s 25th anniversary, the editor was ambushed in a public forum.
The show was hosted by regular host Munni Saha, but the attacking questions came from the news editor of Bdnews24. He accused Anam of publishing news item during 1/11 which could not be substantiated. Bdnews24 then immediately put the clip online.
Watch the news clip (https://youtu.be/Q7X6c0e1nsU) carefully, for the devil is in the details. The Bdnews24 news editor refers to two news reports in May 2007 -- one about Tareque Zia and Falu, and the other about Sheikh Selim.
Mahfuz Anam responds that each newspaper published this news item, not only The Daily Star. Then he amends the statement and says that Nurul Kabir’s New Age did not print the news item, and he deserves kudos for that.
Now comes the crucial moment in the clip. Mahfuz Anam says (3:11 in the clip) that he was not able to independently substantiate this news, and the newspaper mentioned this as well.
Without independently substantiating the news, the newspaper published a news report that had come from DGFI, and this was “the biggest mistake” of his journalistic career.
I have many questions for Mahfuz Anam. Did he know at that time that the source for the news was DGFI? It isn’t clear at all from the clip, because he’s not allowed to finish his sentences (par for talk shows). Did he try to verify and fail? Did he publish a note in the article saying they were not able to verify?
There are many ways to parse this event. Certainly The Daily Star’s fact checking process failed in this instance, as did the process for every newspaper in the country (except New Age). This could be a watershed moment in journalistic ethics discussion.
But that is not how the news item played out, because it seems the smear campaign was ready to be launched.
Instead of a news item that talked about the complexities of the case, Bdnews24’s banner headlines uploaded at 3:49am Dhaka time said “Mahfuz Anam admits to running DGFI reports” (http://bdnews24.com/media-en/2016/02/04/daily-star-editor-mahfuz-anam-admits-to-publishing-dgfi-fed-baseless-stories).
The YouTube clip was also uploaded on bdnews24’s YouTube channel with the same headline.
As Mahfuz Anam said twice in the news show, the news item was published four months after the military coup had already happened. Therefore it could not be “preparing the ground” for the coup as was being argued in the talk show.
But that is exactly the argument made in a news item published a day later in bdnews24. This time the portal cited the prime minister’s son’s Facebook profile to say that Mahfuz Anam was “trying to facilitate a military coup” and that he be “tried for treason.”
At the same time as this Facebook post as news report, Bdnews24 also printed an op-ed from Afsan Chowdhury. He says all the right things about “journalist standards” in this op-ed, but it comes from someone who does not run a newspaper and instead has the freedom to write polemics that do not require fact checking (eg “We don’t care about Felani”).
One news portal ran three items on this, and their new editor carried out the ambush interview. Publishing a news item without doing proper fact-checking is definitely a major error, and Mahfuz Anam has said it was an error.
But do other news outlets practice what is being preached? For some time now, this portal has been running “news items” against various members of civil society, and others. How much fact-checking is done before the publication of these items?
When the campaign to oust Muhammad Yunus from Grameen Bank was in full swing, this portal ran many news items alleging financial irregularities by Yunus, by his family members, by other GB executives.
None of these allegations have ever been proven, but I don’t recall the portal ever publishing any corrections. Nor do I remember anyone taking the portal to task for this or any other unsubstantiated news items.
The list of those who have been targeted one way or another in recent years is a long one: Muhammad Yunus. Mahmudur Rahman. Nurul Kabir. David Bergman. Farhad Mazhar. Subrata Suvo. Piash Karim. Wahiduzzaman. Debapriya Bhattacharya. Moja Loss. And now Mahfuz Anam.
Pastor Martin Niemoller has been invoked in the past, and he illuminates Bangladesh today as well.
Will we, too, one day be contemplating our silence at such times, ending with the rueful observation: Then they came for Mahfuz Anam and I did not protest because I was not civil society. By the time they came for me, there was nothing left anyway.



