Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Is there such a thing as a neutral journalist?

Update : 07 Feb 2016, 06:50 PM

Of late, there seems to be a lot of brouhaha about ethical values in journalism and how editors manipulate and manipulated their positions to use their media houses to work as spokespersons for those in power.

This got me thinking deeply about the portrayed image of the neutral and unbiased journalist. I am not pointing the finger at anyone here, just using my experience in media to make a few points.

With a direct link to the media world of Bangladesh since 1993, perhaps some of my observations will ring out to be a little cynical but true.

Firstly, the definition of a totally apolitical journalist appears a bit nebulous; in Bangladesh, almost all journalist associations which regularly hold election, and have committees, have a political leaning.

I still recall that back in the late 90s, working for an English daily, I was specifically requested to vote for a certain panel, tilted towards one political side. Of course, no one forced me, but the repeated pleading was there.

There have been papers in this country with huge potential which, eventually, slid into dubious distinction only because they refused to have a clear cut editorial stance.

The blame possibly did not lie with the journalists alone; I have come across media people who were summarily sacked because of being trenchant, dispassionate, and straightforward.

The editors who handed out termination letters often hated the task because very few wanted to see another person on the streets. And given the fact that the profession itself was financially uncertain and without employment, a journalist would simply fall into total despair.

But the dirty deed had to be done because management has taken the decision. Here, the management comes into question because, for any media house, the journalists working in it are perhaps the most vulnerable in their own institutions.

Outside their respective media offices the men and women with the pen may appear invincible, though their fate hangs on the decision of the management, usually led by people who finance the media house.

These people in management represent business conglomerates with clearly marked political allegiance. The moment one of their papers or channels prints or airs something which has the potential to adversely impact their “other” business interests, the fangs are out.

No place for neutrality here! If you work for a certain house then, without question, adopt the unwritten laws. Go against them, the marching orders will come without any formality.

The air in most media houses has a partisan edge for some cause or the other!

So, in such a setting, the discussion about the neutral role of a journalist appears irrational.

In Bangladesh, we have seen all governments that come to power select and send persons from the media to serve as press minister to embassies overseas.

I ask, has there been any instance when an unbiased person without a party label was chosen based simply on skills and capability?

Someone once told me: “One tracked sycophancy is the pre-requisite to be selected for this post.”

Since there has never been an open, transparent selection, I am inclined to accept the above.

In recent times, several blogs have been written about the ethics of journalism though the writers haven’t specified what they are.

Maybe I am not wrong when I say that journalists often engage in mud-slinging against one another in the name of upholding the morals of media.

At the end of the day, a journalist has to follow the desires of the business house funding the paper or the channel.

The unsavoury truth is that it’s the same everywhere: Maybe a bit more pronounced in the developing nations.

A British TV drama called State of Play, which had a huge impact in 2009, clearly showed the influence of the financer of a media house.

A neutral journalist is a person whose real political affiliation will be hard to identify. He or she will report the facts, write the truth, extol the achievements, underline the mistakes, demand necessary reforms, and stand up to all forms of injustice.

Tell me honestly, will such a person ever manage to hold on to a job?

Even if he or she manages to hang on due to an unquestionable set of skills, the prospects of that person going to the top of his or her profession are somewhat limited.

The disturbing thing is almost everywhere: Media houses are funded by business interests and not by institutions specialising in journalism.

Consequently, these business houses, for their interest, will regularly change colours, adopt ambiguous positions, and, in extreme cases, set up examples of complete acquiescence.

When that is the real picture, why do we harp on for the ethical journalists? The demand should be for canny and astute ones who will master the art of survival first and relegate the rather Utopian notion of the role of media.

Tell me, am I wrong or right? 

Top Brokers