Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

When there’s nothing left to burn

Update : 01 Feb 2016, 06:41 PM

Cradling a cigarette between one’s fingers and blowing smoke into the cold, dark night is perhaps an undeniable pleasure to those who take up the unhealthy habit. When your heart’s been broken, there’s no money, in-laws are breathing down your neck, spouse is being a pain, parents say you don’t visit them enough, the only friend you have is a death stick. Conversely, when you’re having the time of your life, your parents are out of the picture, and so are your in-laws, that woman you wanted to marry said yes, you’re making the big bucks, you light one up to celebrate.

Is there no way out of the rings of smoke?

When it comes to smoking, there is hardly anyone in the world who would deny the damage it causes, except perhaps people in the same group as BoB, who still think the Earth is flat and deny that the moon landings happened or that, with nary a tone of irony, “jet fuel can’t melt steel beams.”

That is not to say one shouldn’t be doubtful of every piece of information that is thrown at us, but some things are less ubiquitously deniable than others.

Since there is no debate as to whether smoking is de facto “bad” for you -- in fact, there is a hefty consensus -- the main argument seems to be one between giving people the the choice to kill themselves through the combination of nicotine and tar, or lack thereof.

Should the government really have any say as to what we do choose to do with our own bodies?

Not to take a page out of the feminist cookbook, but every now and then, they do get it right. Our rights over our own bodies have always been a crucial aspect of defining civil liberties, whether it be for women to dress as they wish to, to “be” with whoever they choose to. Or plainly for giving people the benefit of the doubt, by not insulting their intelligence and leaving it up to them to decide whether something is harmful for them or not, and responsible enough to live with those choices.

But I’m getting ahead of myself. Let’s, for a second, stick to the side that wants to ban smoking, make it illegal. One bit of news claims that big tobacco companies like BAT have been using other “hybrids” of tobacco when farming, without the explicit permission of the government. Apparently, there are four kinds which are meant to be used, and a jilted ex-manager of Rangpur has claimed that they’ve been using more than that, at least eight.

And in an interview with the president, a certain Matthew L Myers, of some institution (an institution that I’ve never heard of -- this is not to insult them; I do not know the names of many an institution), going by the elongated name of Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids, claims were made about how, in Bangladesh, progress is being made with regards to preventing smokers from catching the habit.

Gruesome photos showing the aftermath of smoking (via images of reddened mouth ulcers and blackened lungs and slightly bent cigarettes to insinuate erectile dysfunction) will be one of the key features of cigarette packets in Bangladesh in the future. Other things like taxes are meant to keep increasing the prices of cigarettes so that it becomes more and more unaffordable for the customers.

But the thing is: Does it even matter?

Some statistics would claim that pictorial warnings, increased prices, and the implementation of a minimum age do, in fact, reduce the number of smokers. But who cares? In Bangladesh, really, pictures and prices would make a difference? The most expensive of cigarettes can easily be afforded by some of the poorest, and that is not even saying anything about the Tk1 to Tk2 Sheikhs.

Doesn’t all this seem superfluous if one is already aware of the fact that “smoking kills”? If this is the case, why isn’t it being banned outright? Trying to put warnings on a literal death stick, which is there for the very act of consumption, which is in itself composed of addictive materials, is a lot like telling suicidal people about how the ground is hard and jumping towards it from a good height will kill them.

Either way, both the parties know what they’re doing.

But also: Maybe baby steps? The tobacco lobby isn’t the easiest to mess with.

No smoker really wants to keep smoking (though I’m sure there are exceptions. Read: Teenagers) because everyone knows that it’s bad for you. The real issue here is whether it should still remain legal in an age when we are very aware of the facts, of not only how it negatively affects the smoker, but also those around them, and the environment.

This is, in effect, a fight between a libertarian and a liberal. How much should the government interfere with the choices we make? Small government or big? And the argument isn’t confined to smoking, but every material deemed harmful and/or addictive, which are both relative terms, and can be applied to many other things that are legal.

Only recently, much of the US legalised cannabis. Why not here? And if that, why not all the other life-killers, the heroin, the yaba, the cocaine? Some might say this is a non-argument, and the lines aren’t as blurry as I might be, at this point, making it seem. But they are blurry. The choices and the decisions we make -- one between giving the people the right to mess up their lives as much as they want and taking that very right away from them -- is as close to each other as it can get.

Give the people the right to be fat and addicted to drugs? Maybe. But, wouldn’t that lead to some sort of anarchy?

Probably not. What needs to be made is a calculated decision. Perhaps the best thing to assume would be to take for granted that most people are stupid and don’t know any better. Or that they have the freedom to be as stupid as they wish.

Either way, we must stand on one side of the line. Or must we? Can’t we stand on both? 

Top Brokers