Recently, UK Prime Minister David Cameron stirred up quite the controversy by remarking on the “traditional submissiveness of Muslim women,” sparking a wave of outrage in the midst of a farcical attempt to sell English language classes to Muslim women in order to integrate them into British society and reduce radicalisation.
In keeping with the age-old tradition of British wit, Muslim women in the UK hit out at Cameron by Instagramming pictures of themselves and their qualifications, with the hashtag #traditionallysubmissive.
Starting from aspiring to be a scientist to knowing five languages and being the grandmother of 10, this social media storm did really well in dishing up a proper amount of humble pie to the condescending PM.
However, while this was a great effort at dispelling the myths surrounding Muslim women, this is only one incident that reflects a worrying trend in Western thought … and I don’t mean Islamophobia.
Liberating oppressed Muslim women (and using the blanket term “Muslim women” to just put us all in one giant box) is a long-term preoccupation of the Western consciousness, and was an important part of US war-time rhetoric.
Then First Lady Laura Bush’s speech comes to mind, when she stated, in 2001, that the invasion of Afghanistan and US military gains had freed imprisoned women from their homes so they can “listen to music and teach their daughters without fear of punishment.”
These justifications have been repeated by numerous politicians, such as Hillary Clinton and her vows to defend the rights of Afghan women, coupled with her continuous support of the invasion of Afghanistan.
What better reason to invade a country than rescuing the damsel in distress? The idea of white men saving brown women from brown men is an age-old narrative that has played a crucial role in political and development discourse.
Especially during colonial times, women’s lives (and bodies) have been the battleground of the clash of the “civilising” empires against the native barbarians, with the desire to rule being cleverly masked as the virtuous need to rescue the oppressed females. This has led to the image of the average “Third-World Woman” -- a victim of poverty and tradition in dire need of liberation.
While there is no denying that women across the world do suffer from oppression, prejudice, and the patriarchal society, it is imperative to remember that gender is a social construct, and race and social class are crucial issues that cross-cut with women’s rights as well as the game of international politics. Creating this idea of the non-Western woman as traditionally oppressed is not only demeaning, it is dangerous when used as justification for raising approval ratings of unjustified wars.
A classified document leaked by Wikileaks revealed that this is exactly what was done in 2010 when interest in Afghanistan was dropping -- using the image of oppressed women to garner sympathy, whereas during the Cold War, women’s rights, in the exact same areas, was not an issue.
Obama’s State of the Union speech, while not directly related to Muslim women, referred to the conflicts in the Middle East as dating back millennia, reflecting a similar trend of white-washing facts and viewing them through highly polarised lenses.
Views like this completely ignore the role colonial powers played in drawing arbitrary lines and creating conflicts that continue to this day, and simply project the image of a distant land with a barbaric “other” and a civilisation that is incompatible with that of the West.
Even more worrying, this narrative imposes upon us the idea that feminism is a liberal Western concept, and that freedom has only one set definition. Post-colonial feminists have widely criticised this view of the Third-World Woman and the white man’s burden to save us, as well as the idea of the progressive, liberal white feminist (think Hillary Clinton) who travel to the Third World and teach women what it is like to be empowered.
While it is amazing that women’s rights are now a mainstream issue, it is time for us to reclaim feminism and remember that it is not a Western export, and that we must protest against cultural stereotyping that glosses over a complex stream of historical and political dynamics.
If we are to live in truly multi-cultural societies, we must recognise the diversity of experiences in all women’s lives, rather than creating a polarised view that places feminism firmly on the side of the West.



