Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

A necessary bridge

Update : 06 Jan 2016, 06:29 PM

Recently, there has been a move towards the model of “social business” or “social enterprise,” locally and globally.

The model has drawn the attention of many experts who are interested to see a “business model” in development interventions as a paradigm shift.

The major undercurrent of this trend is to create a convergence between business and development.

This has been echoed in some form in the third International Conference on Financing for Development held in Addis Ababa, where the role of the private sector/business community was tabled in the discussion in achieving SDGs.

Undoubtedly, multi-sectoral initiative is pivotal in tackling developmental challenges.

Here, the spirit of convergence between the development and business sectors is not meant for subsumption -- that is, one sector subsumed by the other.

Rather, the spirit of convergence or integration should be driven by the “comparative advantage” of one sector by the other keeping sectoral niche intact.

However, what is worrying is that there is a tendency of graduating non-profit sector into for-profit sector in the name of integration, legitimising the need for sustainability, more precisely, financial sustainability.

In real terms, the “business sector” represents for-profit character while the “development sector” represents non-profit character.              

Given the contemporary trend in practice, I see the integration between for-profit and non-profit sectors like “putting shoes and books together.”

Here, “shoes” are the metaphor of business/for-profit sector, because it is inherently driven by greed for profit which has no bounds, and more crucially, in the process of making profit, it does not care to cause damage to its competitors.

On the other hand, “book” is the metaphor of enlightenment that drives people towards moral considerations, and broadly inspires them to be pro-active in protecting human beings from violations of rights caused by an individual, group, or collective. 

Given the abovementioned intrinsic value or inherent character of the both, the integration of for-profit and non-profit sectors could be a good wish, but may not be the reality.

It is evidenced from historical experience that the unfettered growth of for-profit sector has caused discrimination, indignity, inequality, and impoverishment across the world.

The rights of people over productive resources are violated through the process of transformation from the concept and practice of common property resources to privatisation of everything.

It is also a proven fact that corporations are ruling the world.

The corporate rule becomes evident when we come to know that annual turnover of any big giant corporation is equivalent to the GDP of a single country, for example New Zealand.

The power of for-profit sector could be sensed well when the club of rich countries backed by the corporations, dominate the discussion in their favour, keeping the agenda of the non-profit sector sidelined in different global meets.

The Addis Ababa conference is a case in point here.

Given the ideological struggle between “dominant” and “dominated,” how can the non-profit sector think of building a bridge with for-profit sector?

As far as development is broadly concerned, it is all about (re)distribution of resources for the well-being of the poor segment of society.

There is no denying that the world has historically gone through the process of “development of underdevelopment” triggered by the greed for profit by the developed country, having unholy alliances with corporations or big industrial houses.

This trend still exists and exacerbates skewed distribution of resources, widening the gaps of inequalities across the world.

Given the above scenario, it raises a question as to whether for-profit and non-profit integration is the inevitable reality or a constructed one.

Indeed, the non-profit sector known as NGO evolved out of the context of “vacuum” where neither the first sector (government) nor the second sector (market) responded effectively to the needs of the people living in poverty, and this is how the concept of “third sector” (civil society/NGO) emerged.

Based on the comparative advantage of the ability to reach out to people, and cost-effectiveness, the non-profit sector known as the “third sector” emerged with two broad mandates, of which one is “poverty eradication” and the other “democratisation.” 

The existence of the non-profit sector was meant to mediate between the “first sector” and “second sector” for the benefit of the unheard voices from the viewpoint of functional legitimacy.

Therefore, the shift of non-profit sector/NGO was a kind of constructed reality, which became prominent during the post-Cold War era.

In order to further justify the penetration of market forces into non-profit/NGO sector, the following proposition is pronounced occasionally by some groups: “Doing good is not the monopoly of the NGO community.” 

Whatever the solution may ultimately be, the issue of identity of the non-profit sector is a matter of concern in the sense that the sector has moved away from homogeneity to heterogeneity in terms of operations due to inter-generational change.

This heterogeneity has made the identity of the non-profit sector obscured, and thus requires redefinition.

Also, we need to come to a consensus as to whether we want to retain the ethos of the non-profit/NGO sector, or remake the development sector as a whole. 

Top Brokers