I re-read my article “American democracy, bigotry, and Islamophobia” printed in Dhaka Tribune on November 27, after the San Bernardino massacre in which a Muslim-American couple killed 14 people, of whom 12 were the male suspect’s fellow workers. I also read the comments. One reader wrote that I was wrong to suggest Islamophobia was on the rise in the US in the aftermath of the Paris carnage. Another reader thought the use of words “carnage” and “massacre” were taken “from recycled TV news” that did not make a “good column.” Finally, one wrote there were “relatively few bias crimes against Muslims in America to speak of.”
I wonder what the commenters now feel following Donald Trump’s bombshell delivered on December 7 -- that Muslims, both as immigrants and tourists, should be banned from entering the US. He later extended the ban to include Muslim-Americans returning home from overseas visits. His campaign people added, when questioned by the media, that the 8 million American Muslims would also be packed and sent to their countries of origin. That does not address the fact that many American Muslims are natural-born and many are born to natural-born American citizens.
Donald Trump did not throw his bombshell into the centre stage of US politics suddenly. He started his campaign as an outsider. He quickly attracted everybody’s attention with his anti-Washington, anti-immigration, anti-women, anti-poor, anti-Hispanic rhetoric to throw everyone in the Republican establishment off-guard. He believed that his anti-everything hate rhetoric had, at the grassroots, enough supporters to easily give him the lead in the pack of 15 candidates running for the party’s ticket.
Thus, in national polls, one after the other, he dominated the pack. And as his position became secure, he introduced the fear in the country over ISIS and blamed Muslims for it. He did it because he knew that the support base that landed and kept him in a dominant position among the candidates was also latently Islamophobic. The Paris carnage encouraged him to move towards Islamophobia as the central theme of his campaign and towards lies to fan fear based on Islamophobia. Thus, after the Paris carnage, he said he had seen “thousands and thousands” of American Muslims celebrating 9/11 in the streets of Jersey City and that as president he would close down mosques.
After the San Bernardino massacre, he claimed that his “hate Muslim” stance was not only correct, but also favoured him in the polls. Thus emboldened, he recommended identity cards for Muslims like Nazi Germany had issued for the Jews. He called to kill the families of ISIS that led sources close to the Israeli government to describe it as a war crime. Undaunted, Donald Trump said that the “wives” of the 9/11 terrorists knew what their husbands were up to, only for the media to nail that as a blatant lie based on the official report on 9/11 that revealed that all the terrorists were unmarried.
Following the claim about the “wives,” the NYT was forced to call him a liar -- first time for the paper. Most US major papers have never called a national-level politician a liar as openly, having limited it to their comments.
Donald Trump has made “Islamophobia” the official trademark of his campaign now. His “ban the Muslims” demand has been condemned by his own party in unequivocal terms as unconstitutional and fundamentally contrary to American values. And with the condemnation all around, except among the extreme Islamophobes and radical extreme in the Republican Party, the comparison is now being made between Donald Trump and Adolf Hitler. The New Yorker called him the “New Fuhrer.”
In fact, a consensus on the Hitler comparison has now emerged about the candidate leading Daily News to write: “Major media outlets have taken to comparing the billionaire blowhard to Adolf Hitler, another narcissist who managed to make millions of people feel increasingly unsafe.”
The bipartisan condemnation of Donald Trump notwithstanding, the fear among American Muslims since the Paris and San Bernardino massacres has increased, because of the anti-Muslim hatred he has incited that is as real, if not more than, mainstream America’s fear of attacks from Muslims. The stand against Donald Trump by Hillary Clinton is encouraging to American Muslims. She described Trump’s demand to ban Muslims as “shameful and dangerous,” that it came out of his “trafficking in prejudice and paranoia.” But Muslims are worried by what she pointed out about Senators Ted Cruz and Marco Rubio. She said their mindset is similar to Donald Trump, but subtler.
A day before Donald Trump’s bombshell, the president himself underlined the fear of Muslims from Islamophobia as real in his national address on December 6. He called upon Americans not to be misled by the Islamophobes because, first, ISIS did not represent Islam, and second, America cannot win the war on terror without Muslims in the US and abroad. He called upon American Muslims and moderate Muslims abroad to join the war on terror more proactively.
The secretary of homeland security and the attorney general have met the media to reassure the Muslims following the president’s address.
The fear among American Muslims has enhanced since the “ban Muslims” call. There is no doubt that the president would have articulated what the majority of the Americans are now feeling: That they cannot be expected to allow their country to become fascist, to speak against Islamophobia. The Germans had accepted Hitler and fascism partly unwittingly and partly because of the huge national frustration in the country as a result of the developments following the First World War. There is, in contrast, little occurring in the US comparable to the reasons that had allowed Adolf Hitler and fascism to take over Germany.
Therefore, it is inevitable that Donald Trump will utterly fail to turn the US into a nation of bigots through his Islamophobia. In fact, he may have shot his candidature in the head, perhaps deliberately, to force the party to kick him out so that he can blame it and contest the election as an independent candidate. He talked about it following the nation-wide condemnation for his ban the Muslim demand.
However, the fact that almost 30% of Republicans, or roughly 15% of Americans, support Donald Trump’s Islamophobia, must concern the White House and the congress alike in a bipartisan manner and with the same intensity. The fear among Muslims will thus remain with or without Donald Trump in the campaign. Ironically, by taking Islamophobia to a criminally insane level, Donald Trump may have done the Muslims a favour in the long term as Americans realise where Donald Trump is trying to take the nation. In the short term, though, Muslims will live in fear because of the hatred that Donald Trump has put into the hearts and minds of many Americans against them.
Trevor Noah, host of the popular Daily Show, said Donald Trump has done ISIS a huge favour, because it believes that his insane Islamophobia will drive many moderate Muslims towards it. He thus called Donald Trump the “white ISIS” and his campaign “WISIS!”



