“If I have to have a past, then I prefer it to be multiple choice.”
So said Batman’s infamous nemesis in Alan Moore’s version of the story. His past was always a mystery, always the one thing the world’s greatest detective could not figure out. Not to equate a comic book with a pressing issue, but The Joker at least got this right: When it comes to the past, facts and opinions muddle together to create something out of nothing, and nothing out of something. Villains are notorious for that deceptive hat trick, making mountains out of molehills if the need arises, and squashing down mountains to dust, if that’s what the situation demands.
So, too, seemed to be Saka’s rhetoric as he tried to defend himself against the prosecution. Not only had Saka said that he was innocent of these crimes, but the defence tried to prove to the court that he wasn’t in the country during the period from March 1971 to April 1974 using the testimonial of some professor of Punjab University or other. It was proven to be forged, not worthy of belief.
Where was Salauddin Quader Chowdhury in that time period, when all of the crimes he was accused of were committed? And how complicit was he in these crimes, or, in fact, how active a part did he play in them? Most, if not all, of the populace believe that he was here, and he was taking part in heinous acts which involved murder and rape.
And when he was hanged, finally, people celebrated. A lot of us had waited for this for a very long time. There was jubilation in the air and on the streets, with people crowding near Dhaka Central Jail to witness the life of a truly terrible man being taken away. Let us also not forget the Ali Ahsan Mohammad Mujahid, whose death people also celebrated, whose rap sheet also included much of the same.
While talking to a friend of mine, she mentioned how glad she was that Saka had finally met his deservedly sticky end, and that she felt like celebrating. Being of the rather “liberal” persuasion -- and I use that term loosely -- it surprised me. When I told her that I had assumed she was against the death penalty, she iterated that Salauddin Chowdhury was a special case; this man deserved to die.
“This man deserved to die.” The words echo wistfully of vengeance. Two weeks prior, I had written on the crudeness of the death penalty, how, in any First World nation apart from America (if they can be called thus), the death penalty did not exist. And if one is to take its cues from the 21st century, from progress itself, we cannot hold on to archaic notions of “justice” and still hope for development, one of “digital” Bangladesh, one in which our connections to the outside world (read: Facebook, WhatsApp, Viber) are as fickle as the government’s latest whims.
Saka Chowdhury was, by all major accounts of morality, a horrible man. His personality, though a vision to behold, was crude, ruthless, insolent. He was a bigot, an extremist, a murderer, a rapist, a robber, a fraud. Once, when asked about his current situation, he commented: “If rape is inevitable, why not enjoy it?”
Is Bangladesh and the world a better place with him out of the picture? Yes. Would it have been as good without him merely powerless, in custody, shackled, stripped of all he had, a mental and physical carcass of the terrible man he used to be, a living reminder of how one’s victims cling on to the skin long after they are gone? Yes, if not more so.
The ages-old adage of the sanctity of human life is passé to the say the least. One is reminded of the even more ages-old question of whether one would kill Adolf Hitler if they had the power to go back in time. Most of us, perhaps, would. But would it be right? Does one utilitarian act, no matter how brutal, still persist in being moral, in being justified?
And let us not forget that we too haven’t been saints in the democratic and legal processes. The international crimes tribunal has been more than guilty of being prone to the sways and influences of the government. Did they, too, create something out of nothing? Or something more out of something less? Or, mayhaps, something out of something else?
The creation of evil has to be the most potent political propaganda in the history of the human race. As a result, when we celebrate, it must be kept in mind that a man is not a single drop at the bottom of an empty glass, but he is within an ocean, and when taken away, creates ripples across the ocean’s vastness.
I, personally, do not see cause for celebration at the hangings of criminals. I am merely weary of the fact that such a man exists, and that he has forced a lot of us to revel in the death of another human being. The joke here is that we certainly have killed a man, but he has succeeded in killing our humanity. Though most would remind me that one who has committed crimes of this nature should not be deemed a human being, anyway.
History has been as much created as it has been experienced, whether it be by the victors who portray themselves and their predecessors as the persecuted heroes, or the villains who have been strung up in front of us to stare at while the world washes away in our peripheries. We cannot let it sway us away from truth and objectivity. I am reminded of something Samuel Butler once said: “An apology for the devil: It must be remembered that we have heard one side of the case. God has written all the books.”



