Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Solidarity for all

Update : 18 Nov 2015, 06:02 PM

The simultaneous gun and bomb attacks in Paris have been the deadliest incident in Europe since the Madrid train bombings. The hostage taking in Bataclan brought back memories of the Moscow theatre siege and the Peshawar school shooting. The co-ordinated nature of hitting multiple targets was akin to Mumbai. If there is one thing that has been made clear by the act itself, it is that the scale and scope of human suffering is tragically familiar.

Yet, even as we come together in our grief for the City of Lights, we run the risk of letting this familiarity get the better of us by becoming desensitised to such horrors.

Hours into the crisis, a series of fires broke out in Calais Jungle refugee camp. This was not a new occurrence; the cramped quarters and the use of open fire to tackle the winter freeze has resulted in fires over the past few weeks. Yet, the regularity of the now ongoing refugee crisis and the situation in France’s capital suddenly meant the coverage of Calais took on two disturbing dimensions.

The first was how the previous incidents all went unremarked outside of local French media and a few specific social media outlets dedicated to monitoring the refugee situation. The suffering of these groups has become such a mundane part of our daily routine that no one could be bothered to remark on the challenges they continue to face.

The second, more worrying aspect of the coverage was how the very first reaction to the blaze was summed up in one sentence: “This is definitely a retaliatory attack and it is inevitable.”

Even as news outlets rushed to verify the speculation, and since proven false of revenge, the story went viral across Facebook and Twitter at the same time as the Bataclan siege came to its tragic end. Most chilling of all was how every account that shared the story took it for granted that the fire was to be expected.

It would seem that humanity’s default reaction to violence is more violence.

With over 130 deaths in Paris at the time of writing this piece, there is no denying the scale of the suffering caused by that one horrific night. Yet, amidst the outrage, another thread has emerged. Even as the world is united in its grief for one part of the world, it appears to be divided in its concern for the rest.

Beirut suffered an IS strike in the same 24 hour period as Paris. The civil war in Syria and the violence in Iraq continued unabated, feeding into the refugee crisis. There were protests and violence in Argentina about civil rights which resulted in multiple fatalities. There were also six deaths in India over the past week related to freedom of religion. Local media outlets covered these incidents, but they barely got any traction on international sites.

To suggest that Paris should not be given its due coverage and respect is wrong. There should be no question of stifling or criticising any expression of grief that centres on France. Individuals calling out the mainstream media for its supposed Francophone bias would do well to remember that they themselves did very little to mourn other incidents until it became fashionable. On that note, targeting anyone for online abuse just because they have changed their profile picture to the French tricolour is categorically wrong.

At the same time, there is no denying that one of the key factors behind such a strong reaction is its unexpectedness and its location as much as it is the actual abhorrent violence.

We are no longer surprised when the Global South faces tragedy and suffering. Of course there are deaths in South Asia and the Middle East. Of course South America is unstable. Of course the refugees will be discriminated against even more now. Of course countries like Poland will now pull back their humanitarian efforts. Of course, of course, of course.

The truth is that empathy has long abandoned us, leaving behind a world where death is the norm. We talk eloquently of equality when our everyday interactions prove no such thing exists.

Pray for Paris. Praise the citizens who opened their doors to terrified strangers through the night. Support the volunteers in Calais, and also pray for the world. Remember Beirut, Syria, Iraq, Argentina, the Bataclan, and the Sinai, just not one at the expense of the other.

Make sure that when we say solidarity for all, we mean all, not some. 

Top Brokers