Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Of terrorists and immigrants

Update : 01 Nov 2015, 06:53 PM

Seeing how an American immigration court in New Jersey has declared that Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP) is not a tier III terrorist organisation, as per the Department of Homeland Security’s (DHS) assessment, a valid question of why this designation took place in the first place comes into play.

The case came into immigration review as DHS denied a Bangladeshi citizen seeking political asylum by claiming that he has engaged in terrorist activity due to his membership in BNP. Whereas the court expressed concern at violence attributed to BNP members, it was not convinced that the political party has transformed into a terrorist group.

This court ruling has come into the limelight due to a hunger strike initiated by a group of Bangladeshis seeking asylum in the US. In October, approximately 48 Bangladeshis who entered the US illegally went into a hunger strike at El Paso Processing Centre -- an immigration detention facility in Texas.

Members in this group were seeking political asylum for being BNP members. Upon intervention by the Bangladesh Embassy, the hunger strike was halted and authorities had agreed to release the detainees and allow them to appeal the removal decision.

The court sentencing took place back in July, where the DHS chief counsel’s office was unable to prove that the BNP member seeking admission should be denied entrance based on the terrorism charge. This immigration court is part of the Justice Department, and decides if foreign-born individuals charged by DHS of violating immigration laws should be removed or granted relief.

Looking into DHS operations, its immigration services component can prevent asylum based on terrorism-related inadmissibility grounds. This is in accordance with the Immigration and Nationality Act, which enables immigration ineligibility.

A tier III, or undesignated, terrorist organisation does not have a formal designation process by DHS. It is determined on a case-by-case basis, with names being added/deleted periodically. “Terrorism-related activity” is a broad term, applying even to individuals not commonly associated with terrorism.

In March 2015, DHS submitted evidence of the asylum seeker being engaged in terrorist activity due to his BNP membership. That very same month, US Ambassador Bernicat met up with Begum Zia.

Looking at the situation from Bangladesh, it may seem quite perplexing to have one cabinet-level department in the US declaring a political party as a terrorist organisation, while the chief representative from another cabinet-level department visits the head of this party in Dhaka.

This dichotomy exits as the State Department’s mission is to further US interests in the global hemisphere, while a part of Homeland Security’s objectives is to protect the nation with strong immigration enforcement.

Although DHS holds discretion in determining asylum eligibility, the court ruling pointedly declared that no other US governmental organisation is suggesting that BNP is a terrorist organisation.

Human Rights First, an international human-rights organisation, has noted that, at one point or another, all of Bangladesh’s major political parties have fallen under DHS’s “terrorist organization” category -- an overtly broad term where almost any arms utilisation by a non-state actor can be termed as “terrorism.” This includes the ruling Awami League, which was also designated a tier III terrorist organisation in an adjustment denial immigration case.

This category can even include those engaged in self-defense against a tyrannical regime. An immigration judge commented on the absurdity of the undesignated terrorist category by stating the America itself resulted after an armed struggle from a government that could not be changed with democracy.

The court ruling enabling the asylum seeker to stay in the US illustrates America’s checks and balances system, where one part of the government can validate if the other is rightfully conducting its operations.

This decision invalidates the DHS’s reasoning to deny asylum based on insufficient evidence.

DHS would be wise to adopt sensible interpretations of what exactly makes for a “terrorist organisation.” If one does not pose a threat to the United States, he or she should not be labeled a terrorist out of convenience, just to be deported.

If deportation is the real end goal, then surely there are more straightforward methods to going about the nation’s immigration policies. 

Top Brokers