Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Why doesn’t India take a stand on ISIL?

Update : 31 Oct 2015, 06:48 PM

USA wants India to participate in the fight against ISIL, instead meets India’s resistance. Meanwhile, Russia’s Vladimir Putin opposes the US and advocates the importance of supporting Syria’s Bashar al-Assad in the fight against ISIL.

There is little evidence that India is trying to ride two horses, but reluctance to choose a side may be negative for the country’s desire to be taken seriously as a responsible global power.

Still, many are asking themselves why India, which regularly experiences terrorist attacks, will not show global responsibility and leadership in the fight against a terror such as ISIL?

India and the US are creating ever more arenas for co-operation. After Barack Obama and Narendra Modi revived what they call Strategic and Commercial Dialogue earlier this year, the first meeting under this umbrella recently took place. The US fielded its Secretary John Kerry, while Foreign Minister Sushma Swaraj represented India. One result of this conversation was to maintain a public condemnation of ISIL as a global security threat. Beyond this, India did not want to contribute to US coalition to combat ISIL.

Herein lies a source of concern in terms of India’s willingness and ability to take a stand and choose a side. It may not be enough that India will increase its commitment to train UN peace-keeping forces. However, India and the US co-operate and support each other, increasingly, in various areas.

India and the US share the same view on Afghanistan’s future, the need to combat terrorism globally, the necessity to achieve a common climate agreement in Paris later this year, and much more. These important signals clarify a common understanding of key challenges facing the world.

At the same time, they also point towards solutions based on what they call democratic values and a belief in taking down trade barriers. It is currently difficult to imagine an India that could come to similar joint statements with either Russia or China.

Nevertheless, an overriding concern is increasingly expressed: Can and will India truly contribute, when global leadership really is required? And who defines what is considered global leadership? Or, to take a topical challenge, why would India not help fight ISIL? Especially because India is also a victim of terror committed under black and other flags.

Two answers stand out. Firstly, India does not risk distancing themselves more from Russia (and China) than what they have already done. Especially economic, but also historical, relations make it important for India to keep the two countries close.

Second, the US and India have two very different approaches to how terrorism should be fought at home. US works against radicalisation and has a special focus on minority groups who are considered at risk. India does not focus on minority groups in the same way.

Instead, they focus on specific terrorist threats and the presence of police and counter-terrorism units in exposed areas. The US tries to fight the causes of extremism, while India accepts the existence of extremism and would rather limit the possible consequences and injuries. The starting point for talking about the global fight against terror is thus very different.

Still, the US and India agree on an increasing number of fields. This, in itself, is not a given and that they do not share the worldview on a wide range of areas should come as a surprise. Disagreements concerning how to deal with ISIL does not reveal the role India seeks in shaping the world of tomorrow. 

Top Brokers