The Education Ministry was quick to implement the decision of not ranking educational institutions based on public examination results after this year’s HSC test scores came out. Education Minister Nurul Islam Nahid said in May that the ranking system would be scrapped from 2016, but the move was implemented earlier.
Principals of Notre Dame College and Viqarunnisa Noon School and College -- two famed institutions in Dhaka -- have been appreciative of the ranking system’s abolition. Father Hemanta Peus Rozario, principal of Notre Dame College, said the move would reduce the existing unhealthy competition among institutions that had been destroying the quality of education.
But will the quality of education eventually improve just because schools now have no reason to compete against each other due to the absence of a league table? Let’s not forget: The Education Ministry found that some schools resorted to dishonesty to increase their ranking. The ranking system being gone is essentially a major reform, but if quality is not elevated, this won’t change much. Consequently, we will be back to where we were; that is, competition among students to study in institutions that enjoy a history of producing a host of high scorers will continue to dictate our education system.
In fact, the education minister and the education secretary pointed this out while addressing the May 30 presser arranged to announce the SSC results. The secretary said equity in education could not be achieved by drawing up a list of just a handful of the top institutions. “The main motto of education is ensuring inclusiveness and equity, but making a list of some schools is at odds with that motto. There should be efforts to make every school the best school.”
This is where Finland can offer us profound, weighty insights because that is exactly what this Nordic country did more than three decades ago, and is now recognised globally as one of the highest performers in education. Finland is regarded as a poster child for school improvement and has received many delegations from different countries who went there to learn their secrets.
Finland had a not-so-impressive education system back in the 1970s. At the heart of the reforms was the bold vision to build a good public school for every single child.
The country was laser-focused on achieving equity which, in the context of education, means ensuring access to high-quality education for all children irrespective of where they live, what the economic situation of their parents is, or which school they attend.
Dr Pasi Sahlberg, a scholar and prominent Finnish education expert who is now a visiting professor of practice at Harvard University’s Graduate School of Education, writes in his book Finnish Lessons that Finland has been particularly committed to building a good, publicly financed, and locally governed basic school for every child.
“This common educational goal, which placed equity in education as the key priority, became deeply rooted in Finland’s politics and public services.” The Finnish reform to ensure equity in education might fail to sound like that special X factor, because the scale of its implementation and implications can be difficult to conceive for many, especially if they are the product of a competitive and unequal education system, like in Bangladesh. In plain terms, there is no best school in Finland because every single school is the best school. No comparison can be made among schools in terms of the quality of education because the quality is the same in every institution, be it in the rural or urban area.
In Finland, the result of prioritising equity was extraordinary, but it was not readily comprehensible until the first PISA (Program for International Student Assessment) results were published in 2001. Administered by the Paris-based global economic research and discussion organisation OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development), PISA is a triennial assessment of reading, mathematics, and science literacy of 15-year-olds that test how well students can apply their knowledge and skills in a variety of real-life situations instead of what they can just reproduce from what they have learned from books. PISA has emerged as an influential, in-depth survey that extensively compares the performance of students in different countries.
Finland did exceptionally well in the first PISA test held in 2000, outperforming some of the big names in the world of education, such as the US, the UK, and Canada, and thus emerging as the new education superpower. Even though it has always focused on equity instead of high test scores since the reform began, PISA results illustrated that the country has surprisingly achieved both.
PISA measures between-school variation and within-school variation, meaning how the performance of schools differs across a country, and how that of students differs in a given school respectively. Finland has around 6% between-school variance, as assessed by the PISA mathematics scale in 2012, whereas the averages between-school variances in Canada, the US, and the UK stand at 18%, 23% and 30%, respectively.
Moreover, performance variation between different Finnish schools in 2012 was at a level similar to what was found in the previous PISA results. This shows how Finland consistently ensures equality among schools, thereby safe-guarding against school competition. Small between-school variation means Finnish parents are hardly concerned about the quality of their local schools. In essence, all Finnish schools are good and no single school can be exclusively described as better than the others.
Dr Pasi wrote in his book that a high-performing school in Finland is one where all students perform beyond expectations. “In other words, the greater the equity, the better the school is according to the Finnish criterion.”
Bangladesh does not have sufficient data that elaborately explains between-school and within-school performance variations but educationists admit that the performance of rural Bangladeshi schools, where disadvantaged students mostly study, is significantly lower than schools in the urban areas.
Sadly, the inequality is also stark in schools located even within a neighbourhood in the urban areas. The inevitable result? Our parents are consistently worrying about securing enrolment of their kids in those few “best schools,” eventually causing educational inequality to soar. This is why the list of the top 10 or top 20 schools based on public exam results matters so much to parents and students.
This also explains why only cancelling the ranking system is equal to scratching the surface of the mammoth inequality problem that Bangladesh has been facing for years. In practice, the removal of rankings will change nothing because students and parents across the country know it very well that not all schools can deliver quality education, no matter if a league table exists or not. And who will not wish to send their children to a good school?
It is, therefore, crucial that our policy-makers seriously think about how wonderful it will be if parents could entirely stop worrying about which schools will be best for their kids and pick just any school instead, preferably in their locality, to send their children to.
Also, if every school is a good school, all students will get the chance to receive education of the same quality, which will surely be a big boost for our national learning outcomes. Not surprisingly, PISA results have consistently shown that the countries boasting high student achievement are also those that have built highly equitable education systems.
There are, of course, mountains of differences between Bangladesh and Finland, and it is absolutely true that an education system cannot just be copied and pasted in another country, but that should not deter our policy-makers as well as school authorities from paying heed to this simple yet remarkable Finnish lesson: Build good schools for every child across the country instead of building several good schools where a disproportionate number of children will ruthlessly compete to get into.
Our politicians talk about ensuring good education for every child, but it is a pity that the right actions are not taken to translate that idea into reality, causing such discussions to turn into empty rhetoric.
Bangladesh is in dire need of educational equity and that is what policy-makers should address first and foremost. How committed we are to ensuring equity will directly play a pivotal role in how much we can improve in the coming days. This is a grand task and serious challenges are bound to emerge along the way but those are not insurmountable, as Finland has proved to the world.



