One of my relatives, who had gone there to be treated for his heart ailments, recently returned from India. I went to see him the other day, and when I asked him how he was doing, he replied: “Excellent! They (the Indian doctors) are very skilled. I felt half of my ailments going away just to be speaking to one of the doctors in India.”
“But things are just the opposite in Bangladesh. When I go to see a Bangladeshi doctor, I feel even more ill. I don’t know why.” In the 10 minutes of my meeting with him, he mostly explained why Indian doctors were so good. When I was about leave his place, he asked me not to go to see any Bangladeshi doctors. “Even if it is a little bit of a hassle to go to India to see a doctor, it is worth accepting for the long-term benefits,” he advised.
On my way back home, I thought a lot about his words on Bangladeshi doctors. He is not the only person who holds such opinions. In fact, I have witnessed similar sentiments being shared by many others. A good number of them don’t have any faith in our doctors. While many lower-middle class and middle-income groups can go to India for treatment, most from our higher income groups prefer going to Singapore, Thailand, and other countries over Bangladesh for their treatment.
It is true that these countries have better medical facilities than ours, but, sometimes, Bangladeshi people go to see doctors in other countries for relatively insignificant medical conditions, which can easily be treated here in Bangladesh. According to my personal survey, better medical facilities are not always the sole reason for most people’s preference of travelling to other countries for their treatment. I have spoken to a number of people who simply prefer Indian doctors to Bangladeshi doctors.
The main reason, according to my surveyed patients, is their bitter experience of being on the receiving end of bad behaviour from doctors here in Bangladesh. The patients cited that doctors never listened to them, and tried to end their sessions as quickly as possible. Some of them even told me that doctors often behaved in such a bad manner that it might have appeared, to an outside observer, that patients were their personal service staff, and as though they had committed a crime by my being ill in the first place.
According to the patients, it is not only the government hospital’s doctors who behave like this, but often doctors in private hospitals as well.
From my own experiences, I am inclined to agree. I have found some of them to be extremely rude. Here is a recent experience of mine with an eye doctor: He charges Tk800 for his two-to-three minute appointment; I took my father to see him. The doctor was at least an hour late for the appointment, as he normally sees three patients at a time.
He has his team of assistants jot down details from his patients. He only takes one look at the papers and starts to write down a prescription. When any patient asks the doctor about his or her problems, the doctor answers, bad manners and all (bear in mind that one of the patients was in his 80s): “You either understand nothing or understand too much. You don’t have to understand everything -- just listen to me,” his face giving off an expression of severe annoyance and anger.
Another patient, a woman, asked him something about her son, who was blind. The doctor replied: “Did you never receive any form of education? You seem to understand nothing.” I was astonished to hear him say things like that. The woman seemed educated enough, but said nothing to the doctor in return. This is a doctor who charges Tk800 for a few minutes, but he behaves as if he was doing the patients a favour by charging so much.
I experienced the sad rudeness of Bangladeshi doctors in another incident, when my younger sister was hospitalised after she survived a major accident. She was rushed to an orthopaedic hospital here in Dhaka. After her operation, when she was crying out in pain, one of the doctors scolded her.
She was still under anaesthesia. I was angry at this behaviour, and, upon protesting, the doctor refused to treat her. On that day, I understood how cruel and inhumane our doctors can be -- we had to get someone else to treat my sister.
I know that many people in Bangladesh can share tales of similar experiences -- I have heard many such stories from my own friends and colleagues. Why doctors in Bangladesh are so rude is a matter that should be probed into. One of the reasons could be our very low number of doctors in general.
Due to this shortage, doctors often feel like they can do no wrong, blatantly taking advantage of their position. Another reason might be that our doctors are simply stressed out -- stress can certainly affect one’s behaviour.
Whatever the reason, such behaviour is certainly affecting our economy in an indirect way. A good number of patients who are going to neighbouring countries for their treatment might stop doing so if our doctors just learned to behave.
I think a three-credit course in manners for our medical students could help us save a lot of money in that regard. The Health Ministry should seriously consider something like that.



