Education is our birth right. The government is entrusted with the responsibility of ensuring this seemingly small, but extremely significant, right of ours. And the government, in its way to fulfill this promise, had allowed private universities to commence operation. The intention was surely noble, providing access to quality and market-focused higher education for many. And then came the VAT.
The known world suddenly had come to an end. Stability had been disrupted. Tranquility had been disturbed. Seemingly, a significant blow had been dealt to the private university sector. Especially the students. All students studying in those universities were on the streets, paralysing Dhaka, though peacefully.
The government was once again at the gallows, facing criticism, especially our honourable finance minister. Once again, everyone had been screaming at the government to withdraw the VAT so that we all could go back to our normal lives. Maybe they were right. We have, too many times, settled for quick fixes and let the bigger problem go unresolved. Too many times. No wonder our children have learned well and are also seemingly going the same way, though in a non-violent way -- it’s just paralysing a city. Non-violent indeed.
Now, let’s take a different perspective and see what the students were really protesting. They were protesting the VAT on tuition fees. Well, actually, no. It was not the VAT that bothered them. It was the affordability of the tuition fees at private universities.
They were disturbed as this VAT would have made the already high tuition fees at their universities even higher and disrupted their academic pursuits. I think there is an obvious point here which we are losing sight of. Actually, someday, we might also thank our honourable finance minister for bringing this real issue in the forefront, albeit unintentionally.
He had imposed a VAT on private university tuition with the assumption that, since the tuition is already so high, why can’t they impose a VAT on an expensive product? He is right from an economic theorist standpoint, but there is a problem: This is education we are talking about. No one is raising the question: “Why is private university so expensive in the first place?” “Is the existing tuition fee rational?” I repeat: Education is our birth-right.
Private universities, by law, are non-profit institutions. No one is asking questions as to why non-profits, which ideally have purely developmental agendas, are charging such high fees for education that our students, and their parents, are suffering. I have seen placards, videos, stories of hardships of students who are struggling terribly to afford these institutions. Why the hardship? Why the struggle?
Why aren’t these universities setting a tuition structure so that we don’t have to sell our land, our mothers’ ornaments, use up our fathers’ retirement funds, and borrow money at high interest to study in these places of education?
Now that the VAT has been withdrawn, as demanded, does it really solve the core problem? Will quality higher education in the private universities suddenly become affordable to our meritorious masses? I think not. No one is talking about this. I see no placards asking to rationalise the existing tuition fees considering our current socio-economic standards. That, I believe, should be the main thing to ask for.
As far as I know, there is not much public knowledge about the surplus of private universities. Though, from time to time, we hear stories of hundreds of crores of taka being accrued in profits. I cannot verify such stories myself. I sincerely hope that is not the case. But if they are true, to some extent, we must now wonder why non-profits need to accumulate such huge amounts of surplus. Is there any accountability? And before we lose sight, let’s just remind ourselves that these surpluses are generated from one single source: The tuition of the students.
These institutions were set up to ensure access to quality higher education and have it be affordable. Mind it. Affordable. Let’s publish the accounts of the private universities publicly, let us review where all the tuition is going. They are educational institutions. They are non-profits. They are entrusted with the “holy” task of spreading the light of education. Let the truth be told.
Show us the private universities are charging a price which is adequate to cover only their operational expenses. Not to make profits (irrational surplus). I am hopeful they will be able to satisfy us, and win our hearts as noble and society-focused non-profit institutions. But let’s have a look first.
As far as the government goes, if they really believe private universities are making good money and are pursuing a business agenda, just go and tax them. Tax the profits. But also, at the same time, remember your promise of making quality higher education affordable for the deserving ones. Deserving based on merit. Go and ensure that first. Education is our birth-right, and you are mandated to ensure that for citizens. Revenue maximisation, at least in this case, should not be first priority.
What about the quality of the education that is being delivered in private universities? Do they reflect the price being charged? If yes, fantastic! If not, who is protesting that? Is there anyone asking this question? We are too busy with superficial and immediate concerns. The government should immediately form a strong committee, with both public and private representation, to review the quality of education of all the private universities. After all, the government gave them the license to operate, and it is their moral obligation to make sure licensed institutions are fulfilling the promise.
Coming back to the popular issue: VAT or no VAT, we must ensure higher education remains affordable to our students who deserve it. I urge the government to take steps to review the existing tuition of all the private universities, and make sure they are affordable to our people. Yes, I strongly agree that education should never be treated as a product; the government should not allow anyone to treat it as such. The goal should be to lessen the burden, and not make it any more expensive.
Since our honourable finance minister went in and opened Pandora’s Box, letting it get closed before some bigger issues got freed, let’s answer all these very important questions: We need to ensure quality and affordable higher education for the students who protested. Let their struggle not go to waste. Let’s honour the recently announced “no VAT” verdict. Let us look for a comprehensive solution. Let the protesters have more than they asked for.
Send them back home with guaranteed quality education which they and their parents can afford. Let everybody win. With the recent decision to axe the VAT, the government has shown that it is indeed in tune with the pulse of the people. I hope they will take this opportunity and capitalise on doing some further good, and serve the people the way they are mandated.
I will conclude with a quote from Rahm Emanuel: “You never let a serious crisis go to waste. And what I mean by that is it’s an opportunity to do things you think you could not do before."



