This is an imaginary story of a father and son on a September day of 2015: The father teaches at a public university, has never been able to bag any consultancies, barely makes enough income to stay alive in Dhaka, and lives with the shame that he cannot afford to give his son anything more than his daily bus fares.
The son studies at a private university, tries his utmost to win a scholarship, and lives with the shame that he got rejected by public universities, and is now having to be a huge financial burden to his father by attending a private university.
Both their shames are generally silent, hidden away safely … but not that day.
On the morning of the September day, they both have their breakfast and go out, oblivious that the next few hours will change their lives forever. Within an hour, the father finds himself in a teachers’ protest demanding that their pay scale and rank be kept separate from those of the civil servants. Not too far away, the son finds himself in a students’ protest demanding that education be kept out of the clutches of VAT.
After an arduous day of protests, speeches, and police-charges, they meet at the dinner table, each congratulating the other for making some progress. The son starts out by saying: “So, the finance minister has apologised for his derogatory remarks regarding teachers -- you must be happy?”
The father responds that he is, and that he appreciates the culture of a minister apologising, but also adds that this apology effectively does not make much of a difference in their core demands of a separate pay structure. While civil servants perform the important function of keeping the government machinery running and making important resource-allocation decisions, the teachers, particularly university teachers, perform the important function of creating the foundation for skills and talents needed for keeping the nation running.
They are parallel but inter-dependent functions, and the governance ought to reflect that. He laments that the recent significantly improved pay structure could have been an opportunity to re-build the public universities with renewed enthusiasm from the teachers, who could now afford to focus less on secondary sources of income and more on their core responsibilities.
The father changes the topic and says: “So, it has been declared that the VAT will not be levied on students but on universities -- you must be happy?”
The son responds by saying that he is, and that he appreciates that the government took their protests seriously enough to issue a statement promptly, but also adds that this statement has to be taken with a big grain of salt. Showing off his knowledge of economics, he explains that VAT is a consumption tax generally paid by the consumer, not by the service provider. He knows that the financial authorities of the country have to know what he learned in his Economics 101 class -- so he is still not sure what to make of this statement and feels that a VAT will ultimately fall on the shoulders of students, and may pass on in disguise through reduced facilities, increased auxiliary fees, reduced scholarships, etc, even if the tuition fee itself is not increased abnormally.
He points to the fact that many of his friends at his university come from far less privileged backgrounds than him and he cannot imagine how adversely this increased VAT will affect them. The dominant thinking behind imposition of this VAT seems to be that, since private universities make a lot of money, they should share more of that with the government, or that relatively well-off families send their children to private universities, so they should be able to afford a little extra.
While the private universities started out attracting the more wealthy sections of society, the situation has changed drastically over the years and he feels that the government does not seem to be aware of that from their statements.
He says that the thinking he would have welcomed from the government is that, since such a large number of students from all backgrounds are having to go to these non-profit private universities, how can the quality of their education be improved and financial flow better monitored to ensure that the students are reaping the ultimate benefit.
A few more minutes of their conversation make it clear to them that it is too soon to celebrate anything, and the statements from the authorities are either misguided or misleading. The father vents out frustrations about how the tertiary education sector has been historically de-prioritised, with little funding going into research or improvements in overall quality of education.
While people coming out of the education system in neighbouring India are now dominating the global corporate sector, it is indeed sad to see that we are still dealing with the fundamentals, and still taking a few steps in the right direction and then a few more in the opposite direction.
The mother, who has been patiently listening, suddenly interrupts: “What are you really fighting for?”
The father says: “Our professional pride.”
The son says: “Our economic rights.”
The mother responds: “None of you are correct -- you all are fighting to keep the nation alive by trying to keep its heart, the education sector, pumping. You are all fighting for a common thing really.”
The mother’s prudent words make the father and son realise that their fight is hardly about their own respective groups, and own respective demands. It is ultimately about saving this nation -- it is about putting education, teachers, and students at the heart of the national growth policy, giving students the right opportunities for higher education, giving teachers the environment where they feel that they are respected in society and can operate autonomously.
The mother continues: “But why do you have to shut down the entire city to make your point?”
“Simply because that is the only way that the government will listen,” both the father and son echo.
The mother refutes, saying that the fight is about saving our nation through saving the tertiary education sector, which requires all walks of life to join the fight. A strategy that brings countless sufferings to the entire population of a city of more than 11 million people does not win hearts and minds. She reinforces her point by saying that one should not be looking for a short-cut to winning this fight. This has to be an inclusive, long-term one if a sustainable outcome on these issues are sought. She gets up from the table and leaves behind a pensive father and son looking at each other.
The father retires for the night, listening to his favorite uplifting song -- “Ekti phulke bachabo bole juddho kori.”
The son retires for the night, listening to his favorite morbid song -- “Killing me softly.”
The father and son both realise that they just have to join forces and so do the rest of society, and tell the powers-that-be in non-violent and non-disruptive ways that it is our collective responsibility to allow “killing me softly” no more, if we have to save the ekti phul that we have, before it’s too late. There is a lot of convincing to be done when they wake up the next day to new possibilities.



