MM Kalburgi, a rationalist and former vice-chancellor of Karnataka Hampi University was killed by assailants on August 30 at the doorstep of his house in Dharwad city of the South Indian state of Karnataka.
Professor Kalburgi, a septuagenarian, is the third victim of religious extremists in India since the murder of rationalist Dr Narendra Dabholkar, 65, in 2013. Govind Pansare, political activist and author, met a similar fate in February 2015. All three have been targets of religious extremist forces for their uncompromising views on organised religion and its political manifestation.
The Indian sub-continent has seen a rise in crimes by extremist groups. The month of August in which Professor Kalburgi was killed also saw the murder of a young blogger from neighbouring Bangladesh, Niloy Neel, making it the fourth case of a blogger to be hacked to death.
In Sri Lanka of Bodhu Bala Sena, an extremist Buddhist group said to have incited clashes between Buddhists and Muslims near Colombo this year have put the island-country on the map of religious extremism.
Criticising fundamentalism sealed their fates
In the case of the Indian trio, it is clear that their relentless criticism of religious fundamentalism and social oppression that earned them many enemies, especially among religious fundamentalist groups. Narendra Dabholkar was the founder-president of Maharashtra-based Maharashtra Andhashraddha Nirmulan Samiti (Superstition Eradication Forum) and he was instrumental in drafting the Anti-black Magic and Superstition Ordinance.
Communist Party of India leader Govind Pansare, author of the book Shivaji Kon Hota, that had sold over a million copies had interpreted the medieval king Shivaji Bhosale as a secular King and the protector of the interests of the peasants, unlike the communal and casteist interpretations of a Hindu king, commonplace.
Kalburgi, an academic and administrator, had earned repute not just as a scholar but a vivid rationalist writing in the Kannada language who had voiced opposition to idol worship.
The hallmark of Dabholkar, Pansare, and Kalburgi was that they were rationalists. The latter had lent out his full support to eminent litterateur UR Ananthamurty for the anti-superstition bill in a seminar in Bengaluru last year.
Their opponents, after having issued threats, burned books, humiliated them publicly and resorted to murdering them. It is due to support from some majoritarian fundamentalist groups with political clout that their assailants dared to commit such acts.
Hindu extremist groups like the Bajrang Dal, Sanatan Sanstha, and Hindu Janjagriti Mancha had publicly issued threats against Dabholkar. Though complicity in crimes of such groups is being investigated, such groups have emboldened the assailants to commit murders in broad daylight.
Justice denied
Kalburgi, the last one to go, had received life threats and only lately he had given-up the police security cauldron provided to him by Karnataka police. Dabholkar had received death threats for several years, before he was picked up by his murderers on a 2013 morning walk in the Western Indian city of Pune. Though, there was no immediate pretext for murdering Pansare, his book’s reputation of exposing communal and casteist interpretations of Shivaji was certainly a factor behind his murder in the town of Kolhapur in Maharashtra this year.
There has been little progress in the Dabholkar and Pansare murder cases, and not a single person has been arrested till date, the police have interrogated many Hindu extremist groups for their alleged involvement of the murders. However, though no incriminating evidence has been found, quasi-political outfits like Sanatan Sanstha and Hindu Janjagriti Mancha had been vehemently opposed to Dr Dabholkar’s work and passing of the ordinance.
The Dabholkar case that has been taken up by the investigating agency CBI is also looking into the planned nature of the murder as Dabholkar. Within hours of Kalburgi’s murder, a Bajrang Dal leader, Bhuvith Shetty tweeted: “Then it was UR Ananthamurthy and now MM Kalburgi. Mock Hinduism and die dogs death. And dear KS Bhagwan you are next.” This Bajarang Dal leader was later charged for promoting enmity between communities and criminal intimidation.
Investigation agencies and governments in the Western Indian state of Maharashtra have failed to bring the murderers of Dabholkar and Pansare to book. A court in Maharashtra also rapped the investigating officer of the Dabholkar murder case for failing to file a charge-sheet against two persons suspected to have provided arms to Dr Dabholkar’s assailants.
The court granted bail to the two individuals arrested on the day of murder and had recovered fire-arms from them and after ballistics analysis, one of which had matched with the bullets recovered from Dabholkar’s body. Even after the Maharashtra police had put in place a Special Investigation Team for probing Govind Pansare murder, his assailants are till date to be brought to book.
Communal agenda
The rise of extremism by majoritarian religious groups in India and its neighbouring countries is a worrisome feature. Not a single day goes by without incidents of inciting communal tension. Instances of inciting millions of the their rank-and-file by coining terms like “Love Jihad” or advocating death sentences for cow-slaughter and conversion have been the order of the day.
There are also members of parliament of the ruling NDA government in New Delhi who believe that the assassins of Mahatma Gandhi were “martyrs.” On one hand the state and central governments in India are conduit in bringing false charges against social activist Teesta Seetalvad providing legal help to the widow of Congress MP Ehsan Jafri fight the case of complicity of the Gujarat state administration in murdering Jafri and Kancha Illiah famous for his book Why I am not a Hindu.
On the other hand, perpetrators of the ghastly 2002 Gujarat genocide are shielded by government intervention, from being awarded death sentences.
The Modi government has also removed any vestiges of secularism that the state adhered to in the past. The ancient Hindu practice of yoga has been forced on the people of this country and the schools were declared open on Christmas for the observance of “good governance” day, only to have earned an ire of the minorities. Incidents of violence targeting minorities have received a blind eye by the prime minister and his entourage.
There is an attempt to modify the social, cultural, and political fabric of the sub-continent that has a shared culture and boasts of diversity of religious and ethnic groups. The steep climb in the prosecution of secularists and social activists are a reminder of the looming danger that religious extremism has come to pose. Murderers of MM Kalburgi, Govind Pansare, Narendra Dabholkar and murderers of all four bloggers of Bangladesh are the assassins of conscience.



