Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Turkey and the case for a care-taker government

Update : 26 Aug 2015, 07:19 PM

Some interesting news for our politics has recently come from Turkey. The country had elections in June. However, it left no party with a clear majority. The prime minister, Ahmet Davutoglu, from the Justice and Development Party, tried within the mandatory 45 days to put together a coalition, but failed. Thus, President Tayyip Erdogan, on his advice, called new elections on November 1.

The news of fresh elections in Turkey did not cause any surprise in Bangladesh, but something else did. The prime minister proposed to hold the November elections under the care-taker government, and offered the two main parties to name representatives for it. Turkey has a history of peaceful elections. Questions have been raised about US elections in the past, but never about Turkish elections. The offer by the prime minister to hold the November elections under a CTG was neither a demand from the opposition parties, nor has the PM been encouraged by some serious faults in the existing system of elections to make such a proposal.

In fact, the opposition parties have declined to accept the prime minister’s offer to name representatives for the election-time government or CTG. The offer of the prime minister, therefore, must have come because, with no party with a clear chance to win, he and his party perhaps felt that without a CTG, they might be accused of unfairness in case they emerged from the polls to form the government.

The offer of the Turkish PM is an interesting one in the context of the arguments that are being made in Bangladesh against the CTG. The main argument that those who oppose the care-taker system give is that elections under it cannot be democratic because the care-takers are an unelected body. In other words, they believe that only elected representatives can elect democratic governments.The Turkish PM did not think so, because everywhere, democracies or otherwise, elections are routinely conducted by unelected officials.

They ensure the voter list, give registration to political parties, manage those who want to contest, assure that voters are able to vote without hindrance or fear, and above all, that voters are provided the choice of electing candidates. The unelected officials do all these fundamental functions required to hold a free and fair election, because the laws under which they operate are so mechanical that they cannot do anything to the contrary. More importantly, those who want to influence them, including the party in power, cannot do so because the law simply would not permit it.

The problems with elections and the nature of governments under which elections are held, arise only where governments can set aside the laws, and not just interfere but also influence the outcome of elections. There is no basis in arguing that elections become democratic only when those who lead the election-time government are elected or unelected, per se. The history of elections in Bangladesh is replete with examples where elected governments in election mode have repeatedly set the laws aside and tried to influence elections. Certainly, those were not democratic elections.

In fact, the Awami League’s demand for the CTG in the BNP’s 1991-96 term was based on the argument that party governments, elected or otherwise, cannot be trusted to deliver a free and fair election. The AL forced the BNP to amend the constitution and make the CTG a part of it in June 1996. Thereafter, elections were held under the CTG that were free and fair, and the BNP lost.

The AL credited itself for introducing the CTG as its major contribution to democracy, because it gave the voters the best opportunity to freely and fairly elect the party of their choice to become the government. The BNP also claimed that the CTG was its own contribution to democracy, as it had amended the constitution to make national elections mandatory under a CTG.

Both Sheikh Hasina and Khaleda Zia, in statements made in international forums in their respective terms of office before 2009, have had at least one paragraph crediting their respective parties for the CTG. Those of us who served both the AL and the BNP in those terms have ourselves spoken in very positive terms of the CTG, and those who listened to us in countries of our postings were impressed with what we said -- that in countries where a party in power can set the rule of law aside very easily and interfere, the CTG is the best answer for democracy to survive and function.

It is an irony that the CTG eventually became suspect, not because the people had problems with it, but because the very parties that fought to establish it and then took credit for it, made the CTG suspect. The AL started maligning the very system it had placed in the constitution when it lost in 2001. The BNP, in its 2001-2006 term, tried to manipulate the system by putting a huge number of fake voters in the voters list, and then allowed the system to become suspect when the president, a nominee of the party, became the head of the CTG that paved the way for the army to introduce the emergency that, in effect, pushed the country decades back in development.

The CTG system was introduced when, in politics, the distrust between the AL and the BNP was high. Each believed that the other would interfere with and influence the elections. The law did not protect the officials responsible to hold elections from pressures from the ruling party. That distrust has worsened, so has law and order. In writing the 2012 verdict on the abolition of the CTG system, the judges did take into account these facts, and therefore wanted at least two more elections under the CTG.

The talk of CTG in Bangladesh has not ended. The Turkish PM has reminded many in Bangladesh that the argument used by the ruling party and its supporters -- that the system is against democracy -- is hardly true. In fact, there have been a number of countries that have taken the lead from Bangladesh and held elections under a care-taker system. Greece, Nepal, and Pakistan have had elections under CTGs. 

Democratic elections allow voters choice, and to vote without fear or favour. They do not, in the least, depend on who holds the interim government or whether they are elected or otherwise. In fact, democratic elections depend squarely on whether the law protects unelected officials -- the Election Commission, for instance -- who conduct the elections free from influence or interference.

When the parliamentary system is in interim government mode, the PM and the cabinet become unelected, with the termination of the term of parliament. The law then recognises the speaker as the only elected official for the sake of continuity from one parliament to the next. Thus, the argument that unelected officials cannot elect a democratic government is a fallacy. Bangladesh should take a fresh look at the CTG for its own good. 

Top Brokers