Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Teesta: A pawn on Mamata’s chess-board

Update : 07 Aug 2015, 07:05 AM

Lest readers have forgotten, New Delhi was prepared to give Dhaka the Teesta deal during Indian Prime Minister Manmohon Singh’s visit to Dhaka on September 6-8, 2011. That is one month short of four years. That deal would have given Bangladesh a 50% share of the Teesta water in the dry season after keeping 20% of the water for the river’s navigability. That deal was generous because, in all prior negotiations, New Delhi had never agreed to more than 28% of the share for Bangladesh.

That deal fell through because, at the 11th hour, Mamata Banerjee refused to agree to New Delhi’s generous offer. Instead, she used the Teesta deal as a bargaining chip to extract more out of New Delhi for West Bengal’s own interests.

She had the power to demand and get anything from New Delhi at that period because the 19 Trinamool Congress seats in Lok Sabha were crucial for the Congress-led UPA government to survive. Dhaka, as a consequence, withdrew the land transit deal that was ready for delivery.

If the deals had come through, Bangladesh-India relations would have achieved the paradigm shift Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina wanted, and for which she had made the first move upon coming to power in January 2009 by promising and ensuring India total security co-operation.

For the next three years, the Congress-led government, till it was voted out of power in May 2014, kept on promising Dhaka that the Teesta deal would be delivered “soon.” Congress was embarrassed because its inability to deliver Teesta was criticised by many Indians as a betrayal to Bangladesh.

The BJP, upon coming to power in May 2014, also did not show any great interest in resolving the Teesta deal. Meanwhile, BJP’s massive electoral victory took away from Mamata Banerjee her handle over New Delhi. The April/May 2014 election changed her position vis-à-vis New Delhi, from a dominant to a subservient one.

Mamata Banerjee was thus forced to make a u-turn on Teesta as well as the land boundary agreement as soon as the BJP humiliated Congress in the April/May 2014 elections. She told Sheikh Hasina, on a visit to Dhaka in February 2015, that she no longer had any objections to New Delhi giving Dhaka the two deals.

She even offered her services to help Dhaka and New Delhi tide over other irritant issues in their bilateral relations. It was a matter of great surprise that Dhaka seemed to have forgotten the fact that she had single-handedly derailed Bangladesh-India relations from being launched to a new level by blatantly pursuing West Bengal’s interests.

Mamata kept half her promise. She supported New Delhi on the LBA, although BJP did not really need Trinamool’s support because it already had the number to ratify the agreement. The first signs that Bangladesh had made a mistake in believing Mamata was apparent when she came with Narendra Modi to Dhaka in June, but only after she was assured that the Indian prime minister would not discuss the Teesta deal on his Dhaka visit.

In recent times, she has gone further in disowning what she had promised in Dhaka in February. She has said that she is not even thinking of the Teesta deal at the moment, let alone delivering it to Bangladesh any time “soon.”

There is no doubt Dhaka repeated the mistake it had made in 2011 when it had believed New Delhi would be able to deliver the Teesta deal. If the Bangladesh mission in New Delhi had co-ordinated with the DHC in Kolkata, Dhaka would have known weeks before the Indian PM’s visit that Mamata was in no mood to let New Delhi deliver the deals, because she was determined to use both to force New Delhi to further West Bengal and Trinamool’s interests, as well as satisfy West Bengal voters who had been jaded over the deals being delivered to Bangladesh.

This time, Mamata Banerjee has again taken Dhaka for a ride. She would be facing Assembly elections in 2016. Teesta water will be a major election issue and, in general, West Bengal does not have the friendliest feelings for Bangladesh for a number of reasons.

Therefore, there is no reason for her to hand to Bangladesh the Teesta deal on a silver platter when her state’s voters would be against it. The Bangladesh High Commission in New Delhi and the Deputy High Commission in Kolkata should know this because it is not a secret. Unfortunately, the Bangladesh High Commission in New Delhi has not pointed this out.

Instead, the High Commission has defended the delay as being normal in any negotiating process, forgetting that the process of negotiations over the Teesta deal had been completed four years ago!

The role of the BJP-led government on the delay in delivering the Teesta deal is surprising though, and raises serious questions. It has both the constitutional right as well as political power to sideline Mamata Banerjee and give Bangladesh the Teesta deal.

In fact, BJP could very well forget the existence of Mamata Banerjee and the West Bengal government and deliver the Teesta deal if it is ready to muster the political will to do so. The impoverished state of West Bengal is now powerless in national politics and is literally at the mercy of the centre for financial support, without which it would simply go bankrupt.

That raises the difficult question: Why is BJP not delivering? One reason could be that New Delhi is well aware of the current nature of politics in Bangladesh and India’s standing with its people.

New Delhi feels that delivering the Teesta deal at this time would not bring India any political advantage, since there are many -- in all probability, the majority of the people of Bangladesh -- who would consider it a gesture to please the AL. Therefore, New Delhi would perhaps like to wait for a change of politics in Bangladesh to deliver the Teesta deal to satisfy the majority of the people of the country.

A more dangerous reason could be embedded in India’s plans for interlinking the rivers that flow into Bangladesh. An accord on the Teesta would create the ground for the sharing of other common rivers that would go against the Indian plan for interlinking cross-boundary rivers.

The strong reaction from our prime minister against the planned interlinking also explains New Delhi’s lukewarm interest in delivering Bangladesh the Teesta deal. It seems that, between Mamata Banerjee and New Delhi, Bangladesh’s hopes of receiving the Teesta deal is fast disappearing into the realms of serious uncertainty, as it becomes a pawn in India’s domestic politics. 

Top Brokers