Education Minister Nurul Islam Nahid, while addressing the May 30 presser at the Secretariat to unveil this year’s SSC test results, made a momentous announcement, saying there would be no lists of the “top 10” or “top 20” schools based on public examination results from 2016.
The minister said the decision was triggered by unethical practices adopted by some schools to secure their place at or near the top of the league table.
He said the ranking system was introduced with a view to creating a healthy environment for competition among schools, but it had since been exploited and manipulated.
The rankings of educational institutions come with the publication of public exam results. We see the media frenzy over the list of the top institutions, with reports on how they have fared compared to the previous years. But in 2016, we could see a wholly different picture in light of the minister’s announcement, and there are compelling reasons why that would be the case.
The key reason has been pointed out by the minister himself -- dishonest manipulation by the institutions. He said the league table was intended to motivate schools to advance scholastically.
What happened in reality, however, should not be very surprising. In the market-place, customers expect competition among companies because the stiffer the competition, the more they are likely to win, both in terms of price and product quality.
But this is not how competition in education usually works.
More often than not, schools competing against each other find ways to adjust parameters, lawfully or wickedly, in order to rig the system, and thus increase their rank without necessarily improving the quality of education.
To draw up the list of the top schools based on public exam results, five criteria are used while comparing institutions:
The percentage of regular candidates among the registered students The percentage of students passing the tests The percentage of students scoring GPA 5 The total number of candidates The average GPA of the institution.Here, the second and fourth factors are not very powerful indicators of how good a school is doing. If a school, for instance, has a large number of candidates who pass the tests without high scores, it will still get ahead in the ranking system by acquiring points for two criteria.
A big school is inherently likely to score more in the fourth criterion and highly likely to do better in the second criterion than a small school without us knowing which one produced better students.
Many schools bar students from attending board exams if they do not perform well in the class tests, which are generally held three to four months prior to the final exams. Now, a school can earn more points in the first criterion only if it allows all its students in a given year to take the board exams irrespective of their scores in the tests.
Sufia Khatun, principal of Viqarunnisa Noon School and College, an institution of repute which saw its rank fall from third to fourth this year, said in an interview that she was not very concerned about the decline in position.
She said the percentage of humanities students was always low. Many schools do not even have this discipline. “What is crucial is the role an institution is playing, not where it is placed on the league table.”
Sufia said many female students who register for the board exams eventually do not take the exams as they are married off early, a problem peculiar to girls’ schools.
One might think the third and fifth criteria cannot be engineered, but the education minister, at the briefing, made shocking revelations as to how far schools actually go to influence these two factors. He said a school can take unethical measures to help its candidates obtain good scores in MCQ tests. He said some teachers open the sealed envelope of the MCQ test questions before the exam and supply correct answers to candidates, enabling them to effortlessly obtain perfect scores in the tests.
Now imagine two schools -- one helps its candidates secure perfect scores in the MCQ test by revealing all the answers to them, while the other doesn’t …
When journalists asked if this year’s best school did anything unlawful to improve its ranking, the education minister said he was convinced that the school had indeed obtained that position, but would look into the matter.
A ranking system that schools can so easily manoeuvre to make their way to the top gives parents and students no useful information.
Whether Viqarunnisa Noon is falling behind or whether Shamsul Hoque Khan is making progress is something that should be properly measured. The ranking system fails at that.



