Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

More to private universities than money

Update : 16 Jun 2015, 06:56 PM

The finance minister has proposed to levy a 10% value added tax on the fees of private university students, but the government’s argument is specious and ill-informed.

Private universities are not-for-profit institutions. This means that the founders (initial investors) cannot recoup their investment. Nor can they earn a return on it by sharing the surplus or paying themselves dividends. Their investments are philanthropic contributions.

Private universities, therefore, have no share-holders or owners. In place of a board of directors, a board of trustees looks after financial matters and guides the university officials in the running of the university. The government seems to be relying on a confusion between surplus and profit. Non-profits, like universities and NGOs, may make a surplus (excess of income over expenditure).

The VAT on private education will burden the students more than anyone. Photo: Bigstock

However, that surplus cannot be distributed, but can only be reinvested. Profit, on the other hand, is surplus that can be distributed. Universities re-invest their surpluses in the form of buildings, labs, scholarships, faculty salaries, etc. By taxing this surplus, the government is taxing the only vehicle of growth the universities have.

In the United States, most private universities -- including Harvard and Yale -- are non-profit. But in return, they enjoy tax exemptions, deductions, and other benefits. Some are also exempt from real-estate or municipal taxes, and benefit from tax-deductible donations, and receive substantial federal grants (much like that annual development and operational funds provided by our University Grants Commission to public universities).

This has helped them build up significant endowments, the returns from which finance scholarships, and development and operational expenditure. Private universities in Bangladesh enjoy absolutely none of these benefits, and yet still must provide quality faculty and facilities.

Perhaps the government thinks it is hitting the richest by imposing VAT. But the vast majority of private university students come from hard-working, middle-class families. At ULAB, around 70% of our students receive scholarships. Most come to class on buses and rickshaws, and not a single one in a Mercedes.

These are the people who will be affected by this ill-conceived tax, not the government’s vision of the ultra-rich, whose children will go abroad anyway.

Ironically, the government requires the private universities to be non-profit, yet, by charging VAT and income tax, the government itself is trying to profit from the fees that students are paying for their education.

This stance is anti-growth, anti-investment, and most of all, anti-education. 

Imran Rahman is Vice Chancellor, and Juditha Ohlmacher is the Advisor for Communications and Student Affairs, at the University of Liberal Arts Bangladesh (ULAB)

Top Brokers