Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Politics thrives on simplicity

Update : 08 Jun 2015, 06:22 PM

Take a look at any election campaign -- whether Bangladesh’s turbulent attempt in 2014, the UK’s surprise result this year, or the USA’s impending battle royale next year -- and the one thing that keeps coming back is the fight to win grand debates in a nutshell.

Justice versus legitimacy. Patriotism versus diversity. Security versus freedom. With news cycles becoming increasingly shorter and ways of disseminating information more varied, it is easy to understand the temptation to take away nuance in favour of a sharp message that is easily taken in. However, it makes the practice no less forgivable.

Political dissent is a powerful tool, and one of the greatest features of any successful system of governance. After all, if everyone agreed on everything, there is no point in having such a system in place to begin with. Encouraging debate -- itself a rare occurrence in contemporary politics -- allows for more opinions to be heard and fairer compromises to be reached in the absence of unanimous consent.

While it is difficult -- indeed, undesirable -- to accommodate difference when it comes to issues of basic rights, many political debates deserve a greater understanding of their depth than is actually afforded to them. Fostering and engaging with difference, then, should be the hallmark of an ideal system. The reality is far less utopian.

Consider the conundrum facing Rudy Giuliani, New York’s 9/11 hero, and once a front-runner for a Republican presidential nomination back in 2008.

Were he to run for the 2016 race, his credentials would set him apart from most, if not all, of his rivals. Yet, the former mayor has no intention of returning to the political arena because he does not fit neatly into the desired mould.

Giuliani is practically a Democrat, with his opinions being for less stringent immigration laws and against large-scale foreign interventions. He is reportedly against mass surveillance as well. Yet, he fits the traditional Republican bill by being anti-taxation and being in favour of greater power for states. He is, in short, a complex individual when it comes to political opinions and, therefore, an unwanted anomaly.

For a different type of example, take a look at the gun control issue that is bound to be a hot topic during the presidential debates next year. At the moment, there are only two stances to take. A candidate can either be in favour of blanket gun control, which is likely to get them branded as unpatriotic as it goes against the hallowed Second Amendment, or they can be in favour of protecting current gun legislation as set out by the constitutional framework, in which case they have no regard for human life.

The fact that the actual discussions around regulating weapons ownership and usage are far more complicated than a simple for/against dichotomy is brushed aside on a regular basis. One side would advocate banning all sales without considering the ammunition already out there on the streets and what is needed to balance that. The other would pump more firepower into the system without acknowledging the thousands of gun deaths every year.

An added frustration is that political discourse and political issues do not take place in a vacuum. Banning the use of firearms is all well and good in the wake of a shooting, but it does not address other factors that often play into such tragedies, such as mental health and institutional prejudices. These issues also play into each other, and affect further debates like education, policing, and even immigration.

Despite this interconnectivity, however, our leaders in their glorious omnipotence usually decide to summarise such topics into ten-word catchphrases. No time for more talking, they say. It is imperative to come up with quick solutions for society’s many ills and the best way to handle that, according to current practice, is to tackle them without a second thought.

Except that tried and tested method is clearly not working. The world’s problems, like the people who create them, are multifaceted. Every once in a while there might come a discussion with an absolute right and an absolute wrong, but those are far and few in between.

For every other political debate, whether it is something as high profile as gun control in the USA or something as under-represented as tribal cultural assimilation in Bangladesh, the intricacies are innumerable. It might not be possible to address all of them in one go, but it would be a good start to recognise they exist instead of sacrificing our capacity to think. 

Top Brokers