Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Whose parliament is it anyway?

Update : 22 Feb 2015, 06:18 PM

The British parliamentary system owes its beginnings to a small gathering in a meadow of Runnymede off the banks of the Thames 800 years ago. Here the Magna Carta was sealed (not signed) by King John. It was here a sovereign king first bowed to his people and granted them freedoms.

Freedoms which now seem, as the Americans so elegantly put it 561 years later, “self-evident” but at the time were revolutionary, this was to be the beginning of the monarchy’s slow retreat from power which laid the ground for a government of the people.

It wasn’t until the early 1700s that the system really started to come into its own, and with the Great Reform Act of 1832, parliament’s dominance over the control of the country was sealed. Many countries around the world owe their parliamentary systems to the United Kingdom. Our system is seen as the bedrock of democracy, the cornerstone and blueprint for almost all modern parliamentary systems. As a Briton, this makes me both immeasurably proud and at once deeply uneasy.

For all its grandeur and history, there is something deeply rotten at the heart of British politics, rooted in a system that, because of its antiquity and status, is impervious to change. This lack of adaptation by the British system to an ever-changing populace and its own falling standing in a global world, has led to the highest apathy and anger at our system since the Peasants’ Revolt in the 14th century.

Over the next few months in this series of opinion pieces, I hope to show you how this situation has come about, and what I believe the British people and government can do to rectify it. I also believe Bangladeshis can learn from our mistakes, see how we got here and hopefully avoid those same manoeuvres that led us here all within the context of the upcoming UK general election in May.

To understand how this has happened, it is first important to understand how our system currently works. On paper, Britain is a “constitutional monarchy.” We have a monarch, in this case, Queen Elizabeth II, who holds executive power over the government, which itself is referred to officially as “Her Majesty’s Government,” leaving no one in doubt as to who the government has to answer to. This power is somewhat restricted by certain laws (but more on that later).

We have two legislative houses: The House of Commons, made up of elected members of parliament (MPs) from specific areas in the country (constituencies), and The House of Lords, made up of a mixture of hereditary (inherited) positions, appointed lifetime positions, and bishops (no separation of church and state for us, thank you very much). We also have a seemingly separate judiciary ruling on the legality of bills passed in these two chambers.

The ruling party selects a prime minister who then selects cabinet ministers for each government department. This in and of itself is troubling as cabinet ministers can only be drafted from elected MPs, leaving most departments run by career politicians who haven’t the foggiest idea what they’re doing.

As in the case of Michael Gove, a man shunted around to so many different departments after running them into the ground that they have now had to appoint him as the common’s equivalent of a babysitter, it seems this is all he can be trusted with. At the opening of parliament, there is an address by the ruling monarch outlining the government’s coming agenda for their term of office. This is, however, written by the government.

On the surface, this system seems to have all the right checks and balances – a two-chamber legislative branch, a wholly separate judiciary and a benign executive overseer – but in reality it encourages an arrogant parliament with an attitude of superiority over the rest of the people.

The problem begins with how our democracy first came into being. Our initial parliaments needed protection from the crown, having just shed blood to win the right to self-governance. The monarchy was seen as a unifying force that was needed to keep the country together. The British Isles had spent the better part of the last thousand years or so being ruled as many separate kingdoms.

The answer was seemingly simple: Why not make parliament the supreme legal authority in the land? We could keep the monarchy as a figurehead, unifying the nation, whilst under no doubt as to who held all the power. Needless to say the royalists didn’t take too kindly to that.

This power struggle came to a head during the English Civil War (roundly won by the parliamentarians). A few years prior to the war the courts had ruled that parliament had the sole right to legislate but the crown could enforce the laws. After the war, the Bill of Rights finally removed all of the crown’s power to legislate or to ignore laws passed by parliament.

This is where we run into trouble. Whilst the crown could no longer ignore the laws passed by parliament or pass laws of its own, it still retained the royal prerogative. This is the final stage a bill must pass before it becomes law. Similar to the United States where a bill must receive the signature of the president, so too must a bill in the UK receive the John Hancock of the monarch before it passes into law.

The royal prerogative has remained, by convention, a mere formality that no monarch would use except in dire circumstances. Yet the power still remains. I do not worry about our current monarch, I worry about who is to come next, or in 50 years’ time.

Prince Charles (the heir to the throne) has already proved himself to be a meddling monarch-in-waiting, interfering in everything from planning permission to trying to influence key votes on GM crops, to even forcing members of his staff on to government departments. How this will develop when he finally (after 61 years of waiting) gets the crown, is anyone’s guess.

Another wholly troubling side effect of parliamentary sovereignty is its relationship with the judiciary. As the supreme legal authority, they have no reason to listen to a word the courts say.

Again, it has always been “convention” that parliament would take the advice of the courts if a law was deemed unconstitutional, but they are by no means bound to do so.

This was brought into sharp relief in 2013, when the Court of Appeal ruled that the government’s “workfare” scheme (where people on unemployment benefits were forced to work for free or lose their benefits) was unlawful as it fell foul of many existing laws, most notably the Minimum Wage Act and the Benefits Bill. This made the government liable for back-pay and compensation to around 231,000 people that had been forced into what was essentially slave labour.

So what did the government do? Why, it simply rushed through a bill retroactively changing the law. Yes, you read that correctly, the government retroactively changed a law that was ruled illegal by our court system to avoid having to pay compensation, money owed, and a PR disaster.

This retroactive change is completely lawful and above board, morally it is despicable and the worst type of egotism. It firmly placed the government above the courts and removed any fantasy of the government being answerable to the people.

It is, however, a perfect example of how our system creates an egotistical government above all the consequences of its actions. The abused has become the abuser. What once needed to be protected, now needs to be curtailed. 

Top Brokers