Having read the five reasons why it probably won’t happen described in Part Three, you may have written me off as a somewhat jaded and cynical development hack who should be put out to grass. I don’t blame you. Nevertheless I assure you that this analysis is based on long experience. To balance the case let me present five reasons why I believe the fantastic objective of eradicating extreme poverty could actually happen. They are not in order of priority.
People
I have met a huge number of dedicated, talented and committed people willing to work tirelessly and often for very little reward to achieve positive development outcomes. I have been privileged to lead a couple of fantastic teams of Bangladeshis during two long stints as a team leader. Most recently the partnership between the shiree team and implementing NGOs that was built made me believe that almost anything we set out to do could be achieved.
There are armies of front line field workers in both NGOs, including thousands of very low paid “volunteers,” as well as government employees who do a great job. As an example of the latter, I was team leader of an Agricultural Support Services Project (ASSP) during the late 1990s and I am sure the strong cohort of DAE block supervisors (now entitled Assistant Agricultural Extension Officers) dedicated to providing advice and support to farmers remains a potent force. There are thousands of no less dedicated public servants in other sectors who could do so much more, even with current resources, if empowered through effective management.
The experience in shiree is that the poorest of the poor when first enrolled in the programme often exhibit a reticence or sense of resignation to their fate. However when revisiting groups after a relatively short period one can nearly always feel a palpable increase in confidence, hope and happiness as people start to experience an improvement in their conditions and can see the prospect of a brighter future for their families.
This turnaround in fortunes, however fragile and vulnerable to future setbacks, is associated with direct transfers but is also, I am sure, strongly contributed to by the counselling, contact and attention provided by field workers, the feeling of solidarity from being involved in group activities and the increase in self worth from becoming a producer – whether micro entrepreneur or employee.
Even enrolment into a social protection scheme such as a widows allowance or old age allowance, while providing what may be regarded as a pittance in terms of cash transfers (typically Tk300 per month), requires an element of recognition of current and future need by people in authority. A recognition that this person is a legitimate and valued member of the community with rights, aspirations and links to important people and the institutions of state.
New technologies
By this I mean both information and communications technology, the digital revolution, but also new approaches to undertaking poverty reduction embodied in the manner in which projects and programmes are undertaken and the results that can be expected. These two elements are interlinked.
One of the learnings of the shiree programme is that the circumstances of individual households facing extreme poverty are complex and may not be amenable to a simple or standardised solution. Hence a given asset transfer, for example in the rural areas the provision of a cow with associated support such as training and fodder, will often be very effective but quite frequently will not be the very best option for a given household. This may be because the mix of labour available in that household is better suited to some other IGA or perhaps because the recipients are just not interested in raising cattle, but would perhaps be very keen on and well suited to some alternative.
One “technological” solution to this issue is simply to give cash and to leave the choice of IGA to the recipients. However for the extreme poor, many of whom have never before been in receipt of an amount perhaps equivalent to a whole year of income, making the best rational choice between many alternatives may be difficult. An alternative approach is to only select households deemed suitable for the particular asset that is on offer but this implies leaving some of the extreme poor out.
The basic problem is one of managing massive diversity at large scale and the solution is to equip beneficiaries, project managers and field staff with adequate choices and adequate information resources. This is where digital technology, while not a panacea, can make a huge contribution. Hence in shiree a real time information system has been developed that is operated through an application downloaded onto Smart phones provided to field staff.
Through a snapshot (10 minutes) questionnaire undertaken regularly with beneficiaries with results automatically uploaded to the central server the progress of all individual households can be continuously monitored. The tool does not substitute for the dedicated work of field staff but provides the information needed for adaptive programming - managing diversity at scale.
Furthermore new applications can be developed that allow the identification of issues associated with a myriad of different IGAs. In shiree there is already one such “app” in pilot that monitors the health of livestock and allows back-office veterinary support to be remotely accessed. The scope for other “poverty impact apps” is limitless.
The opportunity for application of such technology in the realm of public service provision is no less exciting and potentially impactful. Hence, for example, access to government safety nets amongst 100,000 shiree extreme poor beneficiaries is monitored regularly and can be seen by all via the project website. This is a powerful tool for assessing the outreach of public services to the poorest that could easily be extended to other poverty critical sectors such as education or health, ensuring that the drive to create a “Digital Bangladesh” has an extreme poverty reduction pay off.
NGOs
Bangladesh has probably the largest number and most diverse range of development sector NGOs for any country of similar size, including of course the world’s largest NGO and a number of organisations that have transitioned from NGO status into quasi commercial organisations. In addition the major international development NGOs are all active in the country with many having been contributors to national development since soon after liberation.
It is not fashionable to praise NGOs, they are not the primary drivers of macro economic growth, they are not the guardians of national policy and there have been notable instances of corruption within the NGO sector. There are however many great NGOs in Bangladesh and more than anything, collectively they have the experience, field presence, expertise, mandate and commitment to reach the poorest of the poor. They can reach into areas and work with communities that government services cannot or do not reach. Hence if the objective is to eradicate extreme poverty it is critically important that NGOs are heavily engaged in the venture, that the lessons from NGO implemented programmes are drawn into public service provision for the poor. The community mobilisation, advocacy and “holding to account” function of campaigning NGOs must also be respected and supported.
Proven approaches
As stated elsewhere in this article achieving the objective of the rapid eradication of extreme poverty from Bangladesh does not require the invention of radical new approaches but it does require a dynamic, committed and results oriented national leadership, the expansion and effective targeting of social protection benefits by the government, the scaling up and further enhancement of successful project approaches such as those pioneered by the BRAC- Challenging the Frontiers of Poverty reduction (CFPR) programme and further developed in projects such as shiree, the Chars Livelihood Programme (CLP) and Food Security for the Ultra Poor (FSUP), measures to ensure that the extreme poor are not excluded from core public services, the full coordinated participation of the donor community, the full utilisation of available NGO capacity to access even the hardest to reach groups, a dynamic real time information system that provides rapid and honest feedback to programme implementers, the full support and participation of local administration and local elites as well as a dynamic role for the private sector especially in supporting access to formal employment opportunities. With strong political will and a broad national, non politicised, coalition of support all of the above are eminently achievable.
It’s a great objective
A final reason why the objective of the rapid eradication of extreme poverty may be achieved is because it has all the characteristics of being a great, smart, objective. Amongst these characteristics are that it is challenging but, as shown above, achievable, it is a truly national objective – as all regions experience extreme poverty, it is consistent with the global development agenda and will allow Bangladesh to continue to be at the cutting edge of poverty reduction efforts worldwide.
It is affordable and will help to sustain economic growth by building productive potential. Most of all this is an inspiring objective that all sections of society can support and participate in achieving in some way.
As a next step readers may wish to consider endorsing the Manifesto for the Extreme Poor via the website.
I conclude by thanking all of my Bangladeshi colleagues for an inspiring period in my working life and to wish you all success in the continued fight for freedom from all forms of poverty and deprivation.



