It is rather baffling that even after more than six decades of independence or partition, many distinguished Indians dream about Akhand Bharat or undivided India and express great passion for the same, while completely forgetting the hard impact of about two hundred years’ of British colonial rule on the social, political and economic lives of the millions of people who are called Muslims.
They never even shrink from unconvincing criticism of such great leaders of the then India as Mohammed Ali Jinnah or Pandit Jawaherlal Nehru, both of whom ultimately spearheaded the independence of India from the British rule, and two independent states were born on August 14 and 15 – Pakistan and India, respectively.
The course of history is hardly soothing for those people who are averse to objective analysis – like celebrated Spanish poet and novelist Jorge Santayana is often quoted: “those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.”
Pertinently, eminent columnist Kuldip Nayar’s recently published article, styled as “The idea of partition recedes in shadow,” has brought forward a few questions about his observations. According to him: “Pakistan’s founder Mohammad Ali Jinnah went on plugging that Hindus and Muslims were two separate nations, and this made them increasingly distant from each other.”
Obviously, such a generalisation about the partition of India is far away from the historical facts. What is interesting is that, it was Jinnah who tried his best in brining Hindus and Muslims together, and was once declared by MK Gandhi as the “ambassador of Hindu-Muslim unity.” Needless to say, Mohammed Ali Jinnah has been painted as the villain of India’s partition in 1947 only as an attempt to pass the buck and without any cogent reason.
On the other hand, Jaswant Singh, a former Indian foreign minister, in his landmark publication, “Jinnah: India, Partition, Independence” compared the leadership of Nehru, Gandhi, and Jinnah. According to Jaswant Singh, there were several players more culpable – the British, Congress leaders like MK Gandhi, and Muslim leaders who carried the traits of today’s Islamic terrorists.
He further stressed that the demand for Pakistan was made by elements that Gandhi encouraged and Jinnah initially abhorred, and the responsibility for India’s vivisection lies with the Congress and British, not with Jinnah.
Sometimes it is also alleged that Nehru believed in a highly centralised policy and that’s what he wanted India to be. On the other hand Jinnah wanted a federal polity which even Gandhi accepted. Nehru didn’t. Consistently, Nehru stood in the way of a federal India until 1947 when it became a partitioned India.
However, may we not forget that in the long course of history, it’s not always the leaders who chalk out the politics of a nation. Sometimes, just the opposite happens when the circumstances become such that the sensible section of the people propel their leaders to adopt a strategy which stands the test of time.
The plain truth is that neither Nehru nor Jinnah could hardly reverse the course of history which the British laid during 200 years of colonial rule. One needs not go through civil servant-turned-historian William Wilson Hunter’s “Indian Musalmans” or Percival Spear’s series of books on Indian history to understand as to how the British from the very beginning of their colonisation, were highly dubious about the Muslims who were otherwise very well off before the British occupation of India.
According to WW Hunter: “The Musalmans of India are, and have been for many years, a source of chronic danger to the British power in India. For some reason or other, they hold aloof from our system, and the changes in which the more flexible Hindus have cheerfully acquiesced, are regarded by them as deep personal wrongs.”
No wonder, within a generation, well-to-do Muslims of India became poor peasants under the Hindu zaminders (landlords), and thus turned into a hapless uneducated mass to be dealt with cruelly both by the British and the high caste Hindus.
Thus the great divide between the Hindus and the Muslims started right there, not on the ground of religious believes but on the abysmal economic, social, and political disparities between the two peoples. It may be worth mentioning here that before the advent of the British in India, generally the Hindus, Muslims and people with various other faiths used to live in this Sub-Continent in peace and amity.
Therefore, in the garb of two-nation theory, what Jinnah wanted to achieve was emancipation of the down-trodden and forlorn Muslims of the Sub-Continent from the clutches of poverty and helplessness.
Kuldip Nayar maintained that in undivided India, the Muslims could comprise one-third of the total population (including those of Pakistan and Bangladesh) with as much voting power. His contention is again very much arguable as the learned columnist might appreciate that the main question at that time was not the voting power of the Muslims, but fashioning their lives without interference from the majority Hindus.
Even today, there are approximately as much Muslims in India as there are either in Bangladesh or Pakistan. But if one compares the standard of living of the Muslims in India with that of either Pakistan or Bangladesh, one may easily conclude why the partition of India was highly imperative in 1947.
According to the report produced by a committee led by a former chief justice of India, Rajender Sachar, Muslims are now worse off in India than the Dalits, or those once called untouchables. Some 52% of Muslim men are unemployed, compared with 47% of Dalit men. Among Muslim women, 91% are unemployed, compared with 77% of Dalit women. Almost half of Muslims over the age of 46 cannot read or write.
While making up nearly 14% of the total population of the country, Muslims account for 40% of India’s prison population. They hold only 4.9% of government jobs and only 3.2% of the jobs in the country’s security agencies, thus creating a new set of “untouchable Indians” in the modern democratic republic of India.
This official data is enough to figure out that in post-independence India, the Muslim community remained downtrodden economically in comparison with all other majority or minority communities.
It is expected that the government in India would come forward and take effective steps to improve the lots of the Muslims over there, for no country can prosper keeping the 14% of it’s population trapped in poverty. One may now conclude why the partition of India was inevitable.
There is no gainsaying the fact that the partition brought about tremendous misery to the Hindus, Muslims, and Sikhs. There were merciless killings on the both sides of the borders in the name of respective faiths which took more than a million lives and caused displacement of more than twenty million people. But the alternative or the undivided India could be even more menacing, and could have brought forth endless civil wars causing many times more casualties.
An undivided Indian government, no matter how it could have been formed, would be just unable to contain such a situation. It may be worth mentioning that both Jinnah and Nehru were hard core secularists and prognostic statesmen. Nehru wanted a peaceful India, free from any political or religious discord.
Jinnah too had envisioned a secular Pakistan, but later governments had subverted his ideals to let Islamisation into the polity. The popular idea is to quote Jinnah’s now oft-quoted speech on August 11, 1947, when he said: “ in course of time Hindus would cease to be Hindus and Muslims would cease to be Muslims; not in the religious sense, because that is the personal faith of each individual, but in the political sense as citizens of the state.”
Admittedly, the Pakistan which Jinnah envisaged is not the Pakistan of today. After the sad demise of Jinnah, the rulers were mostly dogmatic, dictatorial, and narrow-minded so much so that within a short time (in 1971), the people of East Pakistan (now Bangladesh) had to liberate themselves through a bloody war against Pakistani occupying forces.
Today’s Pakistan, although a nuclear power, is not developing as was expected and situation is aggravated by the Talibans and other religious bigots. On the other hand, despite many problems, Bangladesh, with more secular and matured outlook, is doing better socially, politically and economically. The country is the world’s second largest exporter of garments and textile products after China.
As of now, it’s economic and social development indicators are reported to be the best in South Asia.



