Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Nouveaux érudits: The intellectual catastrophe

Update : 12 Aug 2014, 06:34 PM

Nouveau riche is a French expression used in sociological discourses to describe individuals who have moved up the economic strata from a lower socioeconomic status. The English translation of this Gallic phrase might be “new rich” but a rather meaningful translation would be “new money.”

People who have gathered enough wealth within his or her lifetime to climb up the class hierarchy, which the missionaries of the church of Marx and Lenin are futilely trying to eradicate to this day, and are classified as members of the richer class vis-à-vis their prior status, are at times pejoratively referred to as the nouveaux riches (plural of nouveau riche).

The term might have sprung up from the sociological shifts and drifts that were taking place in Europe in the postindustrial era and is still in use due to the many factual and fictional anecdotes of slumdog millionaires known in our societies. The usage and references of this expression are matters of economics – philosophers and theoreticians of socioeconomics may juice out any theory they want.

This article is not about the nouveaux riches nor is it a piece on scholarly literature. This is merely an expression of thoughts regarding the intellectual decadence that have rusted the intellect of our nation as a whole. Critics may castigate this in whatever manner they want.

The French, with their sublime language, have come up with expressions conveying delicate nuances of social stratifications, perfumes, musical terminologies, female undergarments and passionate kisses.

Despite that, even the French with their articulate language may not conceptualise the intellectual framework of the majority of the intelligentsia of Bangladesh. It takes a non-French, a Bangalee, the writer, to coin a word to express this phenomenon.

After all, the French can be referred to as the Bangalee of the West due to the prevalence of the vowel “o” in the phonologies, the repute of being the lingua franca of the cultural élite of the respective regions and the rich poetic heritage of the literatures of the two languages.

A large segment of the intellectuals of Bangladesh, both deceased and living, accorded with flattering titles like “anti-traditionalist,” “courageous” and “modern,” are projected to be representing the mainstream intelligentsia of the country.

There may not be any debate with the claim of “being mainstream” as it is a very relative and monopolised concept in this country like those of “spirit of 71,” “history of the liberation war,” “religion” and “democracy.”

Depending on which side one is on, and the degree of power that side holds in the parliament, these concepts act the chameleon. The intellectuals of our country have taken shelter under the tents of the influential political dogmas sustained in this country and have exercised their intellect likewise.

The misfortune would have been sufficient if it ended here but the situation is worse when these indemnified intellectuals spelled by the Western civilisation, who are technically above criticism and if subjected to thus the critic is labelled as “collaborator,” “fundamentalist” or “spy,” try to contextualise and impose the Western experience and occidental sociological theories upon the Bangladeshi society, which is very different from the West regardless of how good we speak English, how open we are to bacchanalian New Year’s eve and how hard we try to be less prudish to public display of affection and bosom exposure.

The fascination with the Western society and its practices and the dire urge to impose them on our society in the name of modernism and enlightenment reflects the inferiority complex the intellectuals suffer from as being citizens of Bangladesh, a country which is ethnically and culturally subservient to the Eastern ethos, and this fascination may bring hostile repercussions for us. These intellectuals are thus nouveaux érudits or newly intellectualised.

Just like their socioeconomic counterparts, the nouveaux riches, they constantly display their gathering and fail to use it in the proper way despite the superficial glamour and appreciation by the naïve lower strata of the economy and the commoners in case of the nouveaux riches and nouveaux érudits respectively.

To understand the nouveau érudit phenomenon, it is essential to glance at the rear view mirror of our history. The racist Pakistani occupiers massacred the intellectuals of our nation vindictively.

This left the nation without intellectual guidance. One has to risk being labelled a member of the anti-liberation force to comment that those who were not active participants in the armed struggle of liberation held the helm of governing the country.

Thus, to expect sincerity and honesty from them was beyond realism. It is no wonder that corruption ensued rendering the country to famine, totalitarianism and being nicknamed “the bottomless basket.” A bourgeoisie and affluent class emerged lacking education but made no concession in shoe licking the regime.

Such classes, however, have emerged throughout the regimes in our country’s history – state sponsored marriage ceremonies with gold adorned crown during a period when poverty stripped women to wearing fishing nets and eat banana trunks cooked in poison to spare the misery of life and sons with a father possessing a mere broken suitcase turned lords of acres of land are such instances rarely discussed.

It may be rightly said that the post independence education system hardly had intellectual merit to it, but political favours determined the educationists. The poverty that ensued and the development that was taking place in the West and Westernised countries may have imbued this obsession with everything foreign in our national psyche.

The poor made fortunes as unskilled labourers in foreign lands and brought back stories of wealth and glamour, while those from the privileged class, disgusted by the poverty of the country, went to foreign universities and brought back ideas, styles and philosophy they were exposed to abroad.

The nouveaux érudits are essentially these intellectuals who have been exposed to the result, which is the development of the West and elsewhere, and not the experiences and realities that led to it. Hence, the textbook theories that they have absorbed have restricted them and provokes them to impose those on our society.

In Europe, for example, the oppression of the Church, Renaissance and the World Wars have created different contexts and spawned new political beliefs, which however are being questioned ever since.

Moreover, it is a fact that winners write history. Had the Nazis won the war, the world would have known about many of the atrocities the Allies had committed and perhaps everyone would not have believed that the fate of Nagasaki and Hiroshima was the only way to end the war. Had the victors been different the history of holocaust would have been different to a much less exaggerated degree.

Humayun Azad, the controversial writer of Bangladesh, once said in an interview in New York that people should be “modern” and at one point he insinuated “modernism” as an antithesis of girls wearing “hijab.”

The writer in an exhibitionist manner puffed a cigarette to display his anti-traditionalist demeanour during the televised interview. Azad advocated the adoption of attitudes the West incurred after the sex revolution in one of his books.

Although Azad expresses his adoration for the Bangla language through his diction, choice of words, works and writings, he is quite obsessed with Western practices. The Iranian scholar of the twentieth century, Jalal Al-e-Ahmad, once referred to the obsession of the then Iranian society with the West as a form of sickness where national cultural heritage and orientations were ignored only because they were not Western. Jalal termed it as “Occidentosis.” It may be fairly stated that Humayun Azad was afflicted with Occidentosis.

Various secular European politicians advocate anti-immigration policies and espouse Europe’s attachment to Judaeo-Christian values. Many secular Western countries incorporated the Protestant work ethic in driving their economies.

Although many European intellectuals were fascinated with Eastern and oriental philosophies, for instance the case of Nietzsche with Zarathustra, Europe as a whole never preached to get rid of its European identity.

Azad, coming off the rusticity of his village of Rarhikhal may have become a nouveau érudit once he was exposed to Western scholarship and European academia. Many intellectuals of Bangladesh like him who are proclaimed as the voice of the intelligentsia of the country are no exceptions.

As a nation we have our own values and ethos. Any attempt to substitute those with imported ideologies will only fracture our already divided society. The instance of Afghanistan where the Afghan communists and royalists attempted to impose their nouvau éruditic principles of Marxism and European modernism respectively have pushed the country to civil turmoil.

The result was Russian invasion which gave rise to a reactionary regime. Bangladesh has its own social, religious and moral identities. Its culture is different. Nouveau érudits, who are politically sheltered, are polished wannabes who hardly understand the masses but attempt to elucidate Western philosophy and experience.

Their hypocrisy and political redemption are exposed when they do not write a pencil on the Zionist genocides and expulsion endeavours of the Modi administration of Taslima Nasreen but go on fictionalising and citing fundamentalism in novels and poetry. The nouveaux érudits are indeed a catastrophe who hardly try to unite the nation and subliminally serve the interests of the foreign powers through their intellectual exercise which is indoctrinated with a largely non-Bangladeshi experience. 

Top Brokers