Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

The audacity of hope

Update : 03 Aug 2014, 10:04 PM

Seeing the recent events across some of the Muslim countries during this holy month and imagining how these events might impact their future, one is tempted to use the phrase of Barack Obama – “the audacity of hope” (made famous during his Boston Convention speech in 2004).

It is said humans remember good things. But more humans remember the bad things, and recent events made this Ramadan memorable for the wrong reasons. It might be opportune to see if one can hope for their future to be better than their present and how so – ie hoping if the next Ramadan might be a better memory.

In the Israel-Palestine conflict, or rather the Israel-Hamas conflict, the common man in Gaza paid a price as Israel and Hamas tossed the ping-pong on who started it – Hamas for firing rockets, or Israel for its Gaza blockade and not releasing some prisoners.

Israel justified with its right to defend itself. Hamas alleged that Israel’s exit from Gaza in 2005 under Ariel Sharon was a practical sham, as Israel still maintained restrictions around Gaza’s borders.

To this Israel cited examples of weapon-smuggling tunnels, or IDF apprehending a Gaza-bound Iranian ship carrying missiles as evidence of Hamas’s murkier objective. All is not well within Palestine either.

Internal bickering, with a violent confrontation between Fatah and Hamas in 2007, left them “divided” by Palestinians themselves – Hamas in Gaza and Fatah (and Palestine Authority) in West Bank.

Where does this leave Gaza’s common man? The lives of Palestinians in West Bank might not be perfect (be it in Area A, B or C) due to limited jobs, education and movement difficulties. However, violence has been relatively lower in West Bank recently.

Salman Fayyad as prime minister (though his appointment by Mahmoud Abbas was debatable) won kudos due to his focus on economics, infrastructure and building institutions for governance.

While Israel is partly to blame for its offensive against Gaza’s innocents, somewhere Hamas’ way of working also seems a reason aggravating violence which made basic survival for Gaza’s residents difficult.

At least the Palestinians in West Bank do not live in constant fear for daily survival. The Muslim world may not agree and may defend Hamas, but the current conflict seems more to do with Hamas, rather than Palestine.

After Hamas fought Fatah and seized control of Gaza in 2007, it was not just Israel that upped its ante. Even Egypt closed its Rafah-border at various times since 2007 as secret tunnels smuggling weapons were discovered, except during when Hamas’ ally, the Muslim Brotherhood, ruled Egypt.

It is alleged that Hamas still does not see eye-to-eye on many aspects with Fatah (and Palestine Authority), and doubts persist on who is Palestine’s legitimate leader.

How does one make the next Ramadan a better memory for Palestinians? I have no right or authority to opine on the posturing of Hamas or IDF. Each side has its rationale for its actions. But it is high time the common-people of Gaza decide what is good for their future.

They need to resolve their own internal politics first. Either they see a progressive future under Hamas which won the 2007 elections (the years from 2007 to 2014 should give some idea, especially after Israel eased its blockade for non-military goods in 2010).

Otherwise, if they want to relocate to West Bank, then the authorities should facilitate it. However, allegations surfaced that Hamas forbid residents from fleeing Gaza, effectively putting them in the path of death.

While images of corpses would be excellent public-relations for Hamas to defend its ideology and elicit sympathy, it would be sheer injustice on the very people they are supposed to govern.

This does not paint a positive picture of Hamas – and Hamas might be as much to blame as Israel for the current suffering of Gaza’s innocents. Such a comment on Hamas sounds controversial and the Muslim world may not agree.

However, incidents since 2007 do put question marks on Hamas’ intentions. Allegations that Ismail Haniyeh, Hamas’ Palestinian Prime Minister, made a fortune taking 20% unofficial tax on goods coming through Rafah’s secret tunnels and built palatial homes for himself and his thirteen children around Rimal area, tarnishing Hamas’s intentions to govern in a proper, institutionalised manner.

Palestinians need to put their own house in order and stabilise Fatah-Hamas relations, or else its internal politics would be disastrous. As the whole world rightly sympathises with Gaza, sympathisers need to decide if their sympathy is for Hamas, or for Gaza’s common people or for Gaza’s identity within a united Palestine (which the Hamas-Fatah bickering is overshadowing).

Even amongst regional powers, Gaza seems just a pawn. As per media reports, Iran and Egypt’s Muslim Brotherhood are alleged to support Hamas, while Saudi Arabia seems opposed as it remains watchful of its rival – Iran.

Even oil-rich Qatar finds itself in this tussle for influence over Hamas, as it tries to garner a bigger role in regional politics as a key mediator. Hamas’ Khaled Mashaal is already in residence in Doha.

Next, an equally critical aspect is enhancing economic opportunities for Palestinian people so that their quality of life improves. Most Palestinians are uneducated and unskilled, and capable only for blue-collar jobs.

Many are shop assistants in handicraft/garment/trinket/food stalls, as per Christian pilgrim tourists who visit the historical towns of Bethlehem, Hebron and Jericho in southern West Bank.

The world should understand that, despite all their sympathies, till the time all Palestinians are able to access secondary, university or vocational education, they will never progress. They will remain economically backward and may be susceptible to radical groups due to the lack of adequate education and income opportunities.

The only way out is if they get access to education and better jobs. One solution is night schools for working adults, as it can make them capable for higher paying work by developing skills related to communication, arithmetic and vocations.

College enrolment for the students through scholarships to universities abroad is another alternative. This would make them capable for a higher level of work than their parents – albeit in other countries for now, until opportunities pick up in Palestine’s economy.

Even then, remittance from foreign workers can be a key source of revenue – case in point being Bangladesh, India, Philippines and Pakistan. Its neighbours can offer practical support. India itself has been a destination for university students from many conflict-ridden Asian and African countries, including Palestinian students.

A criticism to these suggestions is that even if Palestinians become capable for better jobs or set up own businesses, Israeli control over West Bank’s Area A, B and C means opportunities for Palestinian commerce to flow freely would be severely restricted.

However, a practical guess is that any effort towards economic development might be welcomed by all concerned, as this would mean gainful employment for Palestinians and steady income for its government. This would make its establishment more stable and less susceptible to internal disturbances and regional influences.

Such a situation might be encouraged by the world, including Israel, as it would make the region more peaceful. Economics and commerce is often the best solution, and can achieve what politics and military cannot!

Moving to economic opportunities for the government itself, income opportunities for Palestine are few. Tax receipts from Israel have been a key source – ie custom duties on Palestine-bound imports into Israel and taxes from Palestinians who work in Israel.

But this is susceptible to sanctions, which depends on incidents of violence. Ismail Haniyeh had in the past ignored such sanctions, which raises questions if Hamas had illegitimate income due to which the loss of tax income did not matter to him.

This again raises doubts on Hamas’ intentions to govern properly. Another vital source of income for Palestine is foreign aid. According to Global Humanitarian Assistance, Palestine was amongst the top five recipients of global aid in 2011, along with Pakistan, Afghanistan, Somalia and Ethiopia.

In fact, the Muslim world is partly to blame for Palestine’s plight here. Despite their sympathy due to the religion factor, actual aid from Muslim countries has been far less than Western nations.

For instance, during the 2007 Donor Conference in Paris, Europe led with over 50% of the pledges, and USA-Canada about 11%. The Arab countries together made 20% of the pledges. Even if the West acted due to its own selfish interests, it is also true that many Arab nations in the GCC are enormously prosperous on a “per capita basis” due to their oil spoils.

Higher commitments from them would show their solidarity for Palestine in more practical terms. Higher assistance to development projects can win goodwill, in the same way US assistance to Egypt is believed to have helped normalise Israel-Egypt relations in 1979.

Lastly, Israel needs to concentrate more on the Palestinians in Israel-Proper. The Palestinian cause has often centred around those in the Occupied Territories and abroad, and the Palestinians in Israel remained neglected.

They make up 20% of Israel’s population, but still remain marginalised. It might be in Israel’s interests to assimilate them even more inclusively within their society – be it in schools, colleges, markets, offices, etc.

This might help improve their standard of living and well-being, and “content people make peaceful nations!” Jews have a paranoia that their community is reducing, while Palestinians have a higher reproduction rate (common in poverty-stricken communities globally where families earn lower income with inadequate healthcare, hence an ill-placed perception that larger families mean more working hands).

However, as families grow prosperous and expenses increase to maintain higher standard of living, education tuition, medical care, etc, the family size reduces due to affordability concerns.

One hopes the experience of Palestinians in Israel might be the same if they do become prosperous, and this might help quell the fear of population numbers that Jews have. It would also create an incentive for Palestinians and Jews to regard each other with lesser hostility. In conclusion, one cannot say if the One-State or Two-State dilemma for Israel-Palestine will ever be resolved. Tenders for Jewish housing development in West Bank settlements have increased in Benjamin Netanyahu’s current term, as compared to his earlier term or those of Sharon and Olmert earlier.

But seeing the Israel-Hamas events, it must be understood that improvement in education and income opportunities as well as resolution of internal politics is absolutely imperative for Palestine to avoid unrest and make their future brighter.

Just sympathies will not do. Otherwise, they continue to stare at a bleak future, and some might become easy poaching for radical groups in case such groups are the only avenue offering them a source of income.

Click here to read the concluding part.

Top Brokers