Historical records and evidences serve a necessary purpose of reinforcing the moral foundation of a nation. Our beliefs, our secular traditions and the different identities that we embody as a Bangali nation were the inspirations behind our struggle to separate our nation from the ideology of Pakistan.
Unfortunately, over the years the events that led to our emancipation, were gradually undermined by vulgar intrusions, facilitated largely by regimes and individuals who had strongly held on to their orientation under the ideological schools of Pakistan.
Secular traditions of the Bangali people never encouraged the belief that religion will disappear from their lives. In a country with more than 130 million Muslims, do we really need a custodian of Islam, that too in a political party?
Unfortunately, post 1975, religious sectarianism has been consciously sponsored by state apparatus. This fusion of religion and politics has had disastrous consequences in Pakistan, and in Bangladesh we have consciously allowed religion to infiltrate all areas of the public domain including education institutions.
There appear to be similarities between Bangladesh and Pakistan in the structure and nature of the self-defeating intervention by political parties, the military regimes and bureaucracy in the education institutions. They are failing to commit to a sustainable standard, a uniform and egalitarian stream of education accessible to children irrespective of their social and economic background.
Insights on the school text books of Pakistan led me to believe that although we are doing far better than Pakistan, the dark clouds of distress are gradually forming in our skies as well.
The case of Pakistan
It is important and of relevance to discuss the prejudices that are nurtured and the diet of lies that are fed to the children in schools in Pakistan and how it has impacted the nation.
The factual inaccuracies and conspiracy theories in Pakistani school text books has worked very well as an ideological instrument for successive military regimes to consolidate their power breeding hatred and intolerance towards non-Muslims with the rhetoric of violence and an abject glorification of the military.
Subversion of historical facts started during the regime of Bhutto after the humiliating defeat of the army in 1971 and, “Fundamentals of War and Defense of Pakistan,” was introduced as a full two–year–long course for Class XI and Class Xll, discussing modern warfare and weapons, defense problems, causes of war, etc.
During Ziaul Haq’s regime, the process intensified and religion (Islam) was used to invoke fear of the “enemy” and foster a sense of pan-Islamic identity, emphasising that it was the responsibility of every Muslim to prepare for the defense of Islam through jihad. Children were motivated through social studies text books with statements like “Hindus burn the wife after the husband dies but Muslims don’t,” to explain the difference between Hindus and Muslims, “make speeches on jihad,” etc.
In Grade V text books, more glaring onslaughts are perpetrated with narratives like, “Pakistan is for Muslims alone,” and “Muslims are urged to fight jihad against the infidels.” “The anti-Islamic forces are always trying to finish the Islamic domination of the world,” reads a passage from Social Studies text book of Grade IV in the Punjab province.
The narratives on the events of 1971 are replete with severe shortcomings. The “Role of Hindu Teachers,” in corrupting the mind of the Bangalis against the people of West Pakistan and “International Conspiracies,” appear as dominating factors behind the separation of East Pakistan with no mention at all of the atrocities committed by the Pakistani military.
The role of Hindus finds precedence in all narratives in text books on the history of the period which Abbas Hossain, director of the Teachers Development Centre, has termed as a total farce.
Instilling preconditions
Pervez Hoodbhoy, a noted academic and Professor of Physics at the Quaid-e-Azam University in Islamabad, says, “If Pakistan taught honest history to our children they would be explaining why East Pakistan felt exploited and fought for independence.
Instead, our children are taught cock-and–bull conspiracy nonsense.” Children are taught the “importance of Jihad in everyday life,” and trained to make “speeches on jihad.” A content analysis of text books by the Commission of Justice and Peace in Pakistan reveals that in addition to encouraging Indophobia the hateful content in text books in Punjab has increased from 45 lines in 2009 to 122 lines in 2012.
The following extracts from Class V text book exposes further the ludicrous nature of assault on the history of Pakistan; “Previously, India was a part of Pakistan,” “In the 1971 India–Pakistan war, the Pakistan armed forces created new record of bravery and the Indian forces were defeated everywhere,” with no mention of the 90,000 PoWs that India returned and the atrocities carried out by the army in Bangladesh.
The appropriation of the responsibility for rewriting and reinventing history by successive military regimes and political party ideologues, the innumerable unregulated religious schools and political instability have contributed much in producing a very large population of religious extremists who are easy recruits and hopelessly out of control in and beyond the country.
Today, Al-Qaeda and its partners reject democracy as un-Islamic, and easily finds support among the vast majority of individuals who has digested sham narratives of myths from text books and the clerics.
The case of Bangladesh
For Bangladesh, it may not have been possible at the initial stage of the nation building process to assign equal priority to education, infrastructure development and health.
However, and sadly, over the last 43 years we have not committed any meaningful effort to standardise and bring about any consequential improvement in the primary and secondary curriculum, an essential component to ensure access to non-discriminating education and train the minds of the future nation builders.
The education statistics may appear very impressive with high enrollment and literacy rate and student graduating rates in primary and secondary exams (92% in 2014) and the number of children receiving GPA awards. These statistics may support the political agenda of the regime in power but is no indicator of a qualitative improvement in the education our children are receiving.
We have been chasing vulgar means to attain a higher literacy and graduating rate in the SSC exams, perhaps to meet the target set by donors in the education sector, compromising the quality of education. There is no pride in merely attaining a high literacy rate, pride is realised in the minds we can cultivate and produce.
The standard of primary and secondary education reflects not only on the crop of students we receive at the colleges and the universities, a crude reflection is also noticeable across all areas of the employment market, in governance, politics and all national institutions.
The damage continues
The fallout has already started showing signs of irreparable damage to our national well-being. The dismally poor state of our education system can be attributed to the frequent changes made in the primary and secondary curriculum under successive regimes, questionable quality of reading materials, questionable qualification and commitment of teachers and massive corruption.
A report published recently in a national daily states that out of 323 government-run secondary schools, 213 are without headmasters and the position has remained vacant over the last two years.
Several streams of education co-existing in Bangladesh, including Madrasas (Alia & Qawmi), which focus largely on religious education, remains unregulated and incubates different shades of religious fundamentalists threatening the secular tradition of the nation. Unfortunately, in our case we failed to determine what the mandatory curriculum for all streams of our national education system should be, more specifically that of primary and secondary education where the character of a nation is reinforced and nurtured.
Added to all this chaos is the unregulated industry of private sector universities and medical colleges. Trained under a substandard primary and secondary education system, graduates of these universities have already entered the professional world to shape the nation’s future as politicians, doctors, engineers and bureaucrats.
Today, the inefficiency of every national institution and the mindset of our national leaders is a glaring example of how naively we have ignored and weakened our education system over the years.
Added to the inconsistencies in the structure of our education system is the needless interference with the contents of text books more specifically relating to the history of Bangladesh. Unfortunately, the History of Bangladesh has been the subject where unabated interference has taken place.
Changes were made every time the power bloc shifted, more specifically, regarding the “Declaration of Independence.” Feeding falsities, omission of the word Bangabondhu and discrimination in the biography of national leaders were the assaults made most frequently in text books and an entire nation of citizens are growing up confused and lost regarding history.
The volume of man hours spent debating who declared independence and frequently tampering with historical facts could have well been spent to streamline the education system.
The overwhelming divide that we observe across streams of school systems if not firmly confronted today and the quality of education improved, ensuring access of children to a non-discriminating stream of education, as well as insulate religion from being misused, we will subject ourselves to the mercy of a fascist state in the very near future and the dam of extremism in different forms will burst open and engulf the whole nation.



