Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Bring the murderers of Manzoor to trial

Update : 10 Jun 2014, 06:17 PM

A three year old girl, along with  her infant brother (only a few months old),  her mother, and a few friends of her father, embarked on a perilous, uncertain journey under the cover of the dark night of July 25, 1971.

For more about this girl we will have to go back a little into the past: 

The war for liberation has begun. It is the last week of July, year 1971. Village Kazla, deep set in the rural Bangladesh, known as an outpost of the liberation war, is our ancestral home. Like every other evening many have gathered to listen to the news broadcast by Shadheen Bangla Betar Kendra – Four Bengali officers of the Pakistani army have crossed the borders, and have joined the war for liberation. This news was aired that night.

The names of the officers were not revealed; we, however, were almost certain that our elder brother, Major Taher, was one of them. We had been anticipating such news. In a letter written to our mother by Taher, which reached her by mail read: “I will reach you at the first opportunity” (Ekattorer Chitthee, page 126).

Our forecast was not incorrect. A few days after we came to learn that with our brother Taher, Major Manzoor, Major Ziauddin, and Captain Patwary had defected from West Pakistan and joined the War for Liberation.

Towards the end of 1972, “From Abotabad to Devi Garh” by Colonel Taher was published in Bichitra, a weekly magazine of Dainik Bangla. I took the dictation of that thrilling and daring episode. Sialkot cantonment is not far from the Pakistan-India  border. Major Manzoor lives there with his family. Major Taher, Major Ziauddin, and Captain Patwary have come by a Volkswagon car from Abotabad to spend the day at Major Manzoors house. That night, they will cross the border. Taher writes:

“Discussed a lot with Manzoor. At last we revealed to Manzoor of our plans to defect and we asked him to be our companion. Manzoor’s wife, his three-year-old daughter and a few months old son were there with Manzoor. Manzoor contemplated that in his condition it was simply too risky and didn’t agree to go along with us. But Manzoor’s wife became adamant to come with us

“... Quarter to nine in the evening, some how we squeezed into the car and started. To keep the children calm Mrs Manzoor gave them sleeping pills

“... After two o’clock at night we reached the edge of a dried up ravine. In the depth of the ravine under torchlight we carefully studied the map again. This time we didn’t make any mistake, we are three miles inside the border. A few hundred yards is the Indian border outpost Devi Garh. Mrs Manzoor laid down her children under a tree. We breathlessly awaited the first rays of the dawn.”

The awaited dawn did arrive. The four soldiers fought with valour in the liberation war. Major Manzoor, commander of Sector 8, Major Taher, commander of Sector 11, Major Ziauddin, a battalion commander of the Z Force, and Captain Patwary, a company commander.

The three-year-old girl toddled through the War for Liberation. Some obscure memories may still be with her. The girl’s name is Rubana Manzoor. I had seen her once in June 1981, when she was 13. They were living with a relative in Bhooter Golee in Dhaka. Theirs were the days of utter misfortune.

On 25 July in 1971 Manzoor, Rubana and the entire family defected from the enemy country of Pakistan and took refuge in the friendly country of India. To liberate the country, Manzoor had pledged his life, fought, and won the war; his country, at that time, was back in the clutches of the war-criminal enemies.

They killed him. On the first day of June, 1981. For Manzoor, to protect his life and his family, a secure shelter couldn’t be found in his motherland.

After arresting Manzoor from the forests of Fatikchhori, the killers had snatched away and dragged Rubana’s father from her siblings and her mother. On that night, they had killed her ever smiling father, General Manzoor the GOC (General Officer Commanding) of the Chittagong Cantonment,   inside the cantonment itself.

It was not only the utter grief, but also an implausible scene of atrocity that they witnessed before their very eyes, that left them thunderstruck. Disbelief and fright was smeared on their faces. Mrs Manzoor told me that in fear, no one called on them.

I had met Mrs Manzoor quite a few times after that. The last time I had met her, was at the end of November, 1981. I received an invitation to visit London at that time. At the end of 1981, after 5-years of imprisonment, I was released, and had joined my teaching profession in the University of Dhaka.

At the time Lawrence Liftschultz, an American journalist, was studying at the University of Cambridge. I thought of collecting a first hand narration of the episode by Mrs Manzoor and handing it to Lawrence.

The Sepoy uprising of November 7, 1975, led by Colonel Taher; the camera trial inside Dhaka central jail; Zia’s conspiracy of killing Taher by hanging – these incidences were covered in detail by Lawrence Liftschultz in his book “Bangladesh: The Unfinished Revolution – Taher’s Last Testament,” published from Zed Press of London in July, 1979.

To unearth the truth behind the cruel killing of Manzoor, Taher’s comrade during the war for liberation, Lawrence Liftschultz seemed the most dependable and able person. I remember Mrs Manzoor, throughout the night, wrote, in detail, how her husband had nothing to do with Zia’s assassination. I reached London on November 27, 1981, carrying the detailed script written in English by Mrs Manzoor.

I met Lawrence Liftschultz, handed him the script and requested him to come forward and uncover the truth as he had done with regard to Taher’s killing.

By then, it was clear that the chief of the Army, General Ershad masterminded the conspiracy to kill Zia and Manzoor. Lt Colonel Matiur Rahman and Lt Colonel Mahbub, who allegedly took part in the killing of Zia, were mysteriously killed in a shoot-out. On the night of September 23, 1981, another 13 officers were killed by hanging after a hasty court martial.

Out of the thirteen, eleven were freedom fighters. Among them, five had received gallantry awards for their unsurpassed bravery. Matiur Rahman and Mahbub were also recipients of such gallantry awards. Two of the youngest officers killed in the gallows were commissioned in 1976 and 1978.

On June 1, 2014, Rubana, Manzoor’s daughter, gave a heart wrenching description of the events of the day 33 years before in an interview. That interview was taken by none other than Lawrence Liftschultz. The words of Rubana, spoken in English, have been published by two national dailies.

What did she say in that interview? She appealed for a fair legal action. She also added, those who have killed her father should be brought to trial, and justice be ensured for them.

Then only, after so many years, her mother, and her four siblings will get some solace. The blood of Rubana and her family has been painfully trickling down for the last 33 years. After all this, Rubana’s words didn’t have a complaining tone or malice.

She said, the judiciary of Bangladesh should attain that worthy stature where everyone will be served justice. She prayed for justice not only for freedom fighters like her father, but also hoped that it should extend to every citizen of the country, which was once liberated by individuals like her father.

Rubana mostly remembers her father’s smile. She has mentioned about the traits of her father innate in his children.

June 1, 1981 – a day of immense grief. Rubana has offered a heart wrenching description of this day in her interview. She tells us: “I had my arms wrapped around his waist. I wouldn’t let go of him. I was crying. We were all crying. And then, they forcibly took him away from us. We never saw him again. They murdered him within just a few hours. Now all this is known.  I cannot say anymore. It is too painful. Too difficult. He was our father. We loved him. We love him still.”

Rubana said: “When a father or husband is murdered, the people that are most devastated by the death is his family. Others may feel bad, even sympathetic, and they may cry out for the truth. But, it is the wife and children who are given the life sentence of pain and suffering.”

Rubana wants to know, in which hole her father was dumped. They yearn to visit his grave, and want to pray for her father. Why should a Bir Uttam be kept hidden in an unmarked trench?

She demands from the Army and the Government that they find that place where her father is resting. Is it too much to ask for a daughter of Bir Uttam freedom fighter, an eminent sector commander?

She ends her interview by expressing hope that “the call for justice from the people of this country will rise up once again and be heard.”

I could have ended my article at this point. Yet, a few important things about General Ershad deserve to be mentioned. From the meticulously researched chronology of Lawrence Liftschultz’s articles, it has become evident that, the mastermind of the Manzoor killing is General Ershad.

I will not elaborate on this perspective. Rather I wish to discuss Ershad’s role during the War for Liberation. I will take help from the book “Nine years of Dictatorship (1982-90)” authored by Major Rafiqul Islam, PSC, and published by the University Press Limited.

I learnt from Major Shamsul Arefin, a freedom fighter and researcher of the war for liberation, that Rafiqul Islam is no longer alive. Major Islam was an officer of the first batch during the liberation war. In the pages 31-36 of his book, Rafiqul Islam writes:

“When the people of Bangladesh were engaged in the battle for freedom; Ershad was the commander of the 7th East Bengal Regiment. It can be mentioned in context that when 7th East Bengal was fighting a war for Pakistan under Ershad’s command, the Freedom Fighters were engaged in a bloody battle to liberate Bangladesh under the Bangladesh-India joint command.

“At midnight of 25-26 March when the Pakistan Army went berserk in genocide and the liberation war of Bangladesh started, Ershad was on leave in Rangpur. He went back to Pakistan during the first days of April without considering taking part in the War of Liberation and joined back as commander of the 7th East Bengal. During the War of Liberation he had visited Rangpur in September to see his ailing father. This time too he didn’t join the War for Liberation and went back to Pakistan. In 1972 Lt. Col. Ershad was appointed as the Chairman of the Tribunal to try the stranded Bengali officers and soldiers charged with treason. So for these reason, in liberated Bangladesh, he shouldn’t have been in armed service. Nevertheless, he was inducted into the armed forces and the outcome of having a dangerous person in the armed forces is evident to all.

“On 24 August 1975 the Army Chief Major Gen Shafiullah and the Air Force Chief Air Vice Marshal AK Khandakar were deputed to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Major Gen Ziaur Rahman and Air Vice Marshal Tawab were appointed as Army and Air Force Chiefs, respectively. To influence a balance between freedom fighters and non freedom fighters within the Army; on counsel of the then Defence Advisor General Osmani, Ershad at the time been in a training course in India, was called back and was promoted to the rank of Major General and appointed as the Deputy Chief of Staff.

President Ziaur Rahman didn’t stop after rehabilitating the people against liberation in all levels. He appointed Major Gen. Ershad as the Chief of Staff and promoted him to the rank of Lt. General.

“General Manzoor was most vocal in opposing the appointments and rehabilitation of anti liberation forces in the administration. Manzoor’s candidness was used as a pawn’s move in a game of chess by Ershad.

“It is a matter of immense misfortune that Ershad being a repatriated person, by his cunning, could make his way up to occupy the top position of the armed forces which was built during the War for Liberation.”

On the basis of the information provided by Major Rafiqul Islam, Ershad can be termed as a traitor and a collaborator. Not only as the mastermind of Manzoor’s killing, Ershad should before his death also be charged and brought under trial as a despised collaborator.

I will end with a plea to the daughter of Bangabandhu, the prime minister, Sheikh Hasina: You have raged war against the culture of impunity. It is for this reason that justice has been established in the killing of the father of the nation. We have achieved the judgement on killing of Taher by Zia after a long wait of 35 years. General Manzoor’s killing through a conspiracy 33 years ago has been stalled since many years.

 His daughter, Rubana Manzoor, had pleaded for a fair trial of her father’s killing in her heart-wrenching interview. She has thanked you in her interview, and said that you would definitely understand their agony as your father, mother, and members of your family were also killed by the anti liberation brutes.

She has also mentioned that her mother met you after the fall of Ershad. They exchanged sympathy because they had both lost those dearest to them. Rubana has mentioned with deep anticipation that Sheikh Hasina will realise their severe anguish and will come forth to ensure justice.

Prime minister, I would like to place one more appeal before you. The role of Ershad during the War for Liberation and the nine years of dictatorship is known to you and all people who aspire for the triumph of democracy.

To save the nation from the wrath of Jamat-BNP you may have had to forge the grand electorate alliance with a dictator like General Ershad. You have also included their leaders in your ministries. The people will surely judge your stance without prejudice. But many have been deeply hurt by the appointing of Ershad as your special envoy.

Remove Ershad from this position without any further delay. Please issue firm orders to conclude the findings of General Ershad’s involvement in Manzoor’s killing and bring him under trial. The trial of Manzoor’s killing will further ensure the rights of justice for every citizen of the nation and uphold the cause of the war you have waged against injustice and impunity.

Top Brokers