Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Brazil has already lost

Update : 20 May 2014, 05:50 PM

When German lawmaker Stephan Mayer visited Brazil earlier this month, few of his comments on the South-American nation were as surprising as his statement that the citizens of the self-proclaimed country of football aren’t at all excited about the upcoming event. How can the five-time world champion have little enthusiasm, four weeks before the tournament? The answer is more complex than most foreigners would expect. Although the seleção has seen better days, national frustration has little to do with the sport itself. Corruption, embezzlement and irresponsible government spending in such an unequal country compose just one of the issues involving an effervescent part of the world.

A bit of context

Truth is Brazil cannot be understood as a single country. As seen on news and travel brochures, it has easy-going metropolis, such as Rio, and also cosmopolitan business and industries, like São Paulo. But whatever criteria one decides to use, there is much more to it.

Famous for its rain forest, 10% of the country – 850,000 sq km – is covered by desertic, semi-arid scrubs, and six-month-long droughts are common. There are also another four major biomes which, directly or not, influence infrastructure and development.

Looking at culture, it is important to highlight a series of colonisations by Portuguese, Dutch, Italian, German, Polish and Japanese, and the mass import of Africans – the country was the last in the world to abolish slavery.

Currently, the inflow of illegal immigrants from Bolivia, Haiti and even distant countries pose a challenge to border regions. In 2013 alone, almost 2,000 Bangladeshis entered the country illegally with the help of coyotes, and requested refugee status.

With this melting pot, regional contrasts and differences of opinion are more than expected. However, it is only now that nationalism, preached during the more than 20 years of military dictatorship, begins to be put to rest. Since the 1990s, the country tries to reorganise and own up to its own institutions and objectives. However, the result so far has been a conflicting social reality, reinforced by income concentration and not-so-exempt media.

Let’s talk about money

A common misconception is that poverty is confined to urban slums, the (in)famous favelas. However, the needs of indigenous peoples, slave-descendant maroon villages, riverine communities and semi-arid Northeastern states are not satisfactorily met by the government, although there has indeed been considerable reduction of poverty in the country, compared with the hunger and mortality rates of the 1980s. As in other BRIC countries, the cake has grown, but was not distributed. Concentration of income has decreased slightly, but the 10% of employed workers with top salaries concentrate 41.2% of total labour income, while the bottom 10% share 1.4%. There are still 6.53 million people living below the poverty line, says the Institute of Applied Economic Research (IPEA).

Brazil has, on paper, a well-developed welfare state. Free education is a constitutional right from birth to higher studies, and health services include vaccines, complex surgeries, mental treatment and support by psychologists and social workers. Paid sick and maternity leave, retirement and other such measures benefit workers. However, as in the rest of the developing world, legalities are restricted by weakened infrastructure, bad administration and personal interests – meaning that the quality of these services are defined by birth certificate and personal address, rather than entitlement.

In the South, the city of Porto Alegre begins to grow in the sector known as “Treatment Tourism.” Private hospitals have stood to such an extent, especially in cardiology, that the city has become a centre for care among the most affluent from other countries, such as rival Argentina. In the Southeast, Sírio-Libanês and Albert Einstein are hospitals that could make their Western counterparts envious.

Unfortunately, this high-end reality is not the rule. Another interesting study, Radiography of health, states that “the portrait of health in Brazil is characterised by the existence of both ‘African’ and ‘European’ regions when it comes to the distribution of physicians.” In states like Maranhão and Pará, the total number of physicians per thousand inhabitants is less than one, similar to countries like South Africa (0.76, according to the World Health Organization). In cases of Rio de Janeiro and the District Capital, the ratio is of more than three doctors per thousand, higher than the US (2.42).

Basic education is in similar situation. In 2010, the Municipal Human Development Index (MHDI) in the country varied from 0.207 (Melgaço) to 0.825 (Águas de São Pedro). Understaffed and under equipped, Brazilian schools deal with an extra set of problems, security-related. Gun possession in class, vandalism and theft around the school are some factors that affect academic achievement.

All this makes classrooms extremely unattractive, for teachers and students alike. The Development Report 2012, UNDP, reports that one in four students who start primary education in Brazil leaves school before reaching last grade. Further ahead, the talent blackout slows the country’s economic momentum in all sectors. Only 12% make it past higher education. Brain drain is a challenge that starts to worry the private sector, which cannot fulfill its higher positions; at the same time, government agencies struggle to recover investments in scholarships of students that, after finishing studies abroad, postpone or cancel their return, due to the quality of life standards at home.

What does this have to do with football?

According to Brazilian youth, everything. When Federal government decided to invest $11.62bn in what it considered less pressing matters, millions took to the streets for understanding that, yet again, their interests were being compromised. One year later, it can be evaluated that these concerns were not completely off. Jorge Abrahão, president of Ethos Institute of Social Responsibility, evaluates that “Public investments have replaced private investment in the World Cup 2014, especially in relation to stadiums.” When the country was chosen as host, it was established that 60-70% of investments should come from private sources. He estimates that, today, “more than 90% of spending on stadiums in Brazil will be public (government).”

Federal Government has defended itself from such allegations by affirming that investments have come from National Development Bank BNDES, and that the loan will not take away from other sectors. “We can not accept that, due to investments relating to the World Cup, education and health are in dire straits, as some of the most exalted critics say,” argues Minister Gilberto Carvalho, General Secretariat of the Presidency. He also reminds that the $11.5bn spent on the event since 2010 is by no means close to the $371.8bn that government directed to education and health care during the same period.

Pressured by 2013’s protests, federal government has rushed a temporary solution for the issue. Since July last year, the “More Doctors” programme has made it easier for foreign physicians to migrate to the country and practise their art in public health clinics across the less glamorous regions. Cuban, Portuguese and Spanish, among others, are some of the 9.5k professionals taking part in the programme that will benefit over 3,000 districts and indigenous villages. However impressive, the number is still 30% below current demands.

Either way, irresponsible spending is still an issue. Nineties’ superstar player Romario, now member of Congress, is adamant: “Outside the pitch, Brazil has already lost.” In interview to Folha de São Paulo, he refers to the works of Mané Garrincha, located in the capital Brasilia. Costing $630.7mn, it is the most expensive arena to date. According to investigations by the Court of Auditors, overpricing reached $194mn, done in an almost effortless way. The transportation of precast materials, for example, was calculated as comprising a distance of 240km. In fact, the factory is only 1.5km away.

Other famous footballers have also given their opinion. Member of the Board of Directors of the Local Organising Committee (LOC), former striker Ronaldinho has lost some popularity in December 2011. When questioned about possible government spending, he answered, “Cups are made with stadiums, not hospitals.” The legend Pelé has also stirred controversy last year, when he urged protesters to calm down during the trial-run Confederation’s Cup. Just before the match against Mexico – and after episodes of police brutality – he urged supporters to “forget all this confusion that is happening in Brazil and think about the Brazilian team.” He reinforced this position to ESPN in January, suggesting that protesters should leave the streets until after the World Cup, so to not affect national image abroad. In the country which paraphrases Marx, it was considered a less-than-fortunate comment. “Football is the people’s opium” is a popular idiom.

Self-interest as norm

Coincidently enough, contractors that made large campaign donations during 2010’s municipal elections are, now, overseeing stadium construction and renovation. Andrade Gutierrez and Odebrecht, for example, multiplied donations over 100% just before the host cities were elected. When asked by Business Insider why the sudden increase in contributions, the magazine was left unanswered.

The promotion of personal interests is a constant in the country where 40% of lawmakers are currently being tried criminally. Political and economic elites clash for power, at the same time as new religiously-entangled political parties and politicians are gaining space in both Congress and Senate. As a result, the country’s public services are broken down to affiliated allotments – and citizens pay the bill. First, through taxes, and then through private companies they are induced to hire to make up for non-rendered services. In 2012, a study by the Department of Competitiveness and Technology (Decomtec) of Sao Paulo’s Federation of Industries revealed that the economic and social damage caused by corruption hits $31.2bn per year.

Although the Confederations Cup, World Cup and Olympics have reignited discussions towards partisan expenditures, other multinational events had already raised eyebrows. In July 2013, Rio held Catholic Church’s World Youth Day, a five-day-long celebration which included the visit of the newly ordained Pope Francis. Although with no accusations of embezzlement, the cost of $53.2mn was paid with public money.

Muffled media

In spite of popular distrust towards such affairs, media is not always incisive of violations. A more naive look might say that, drunk on advertising opportunities, media at first shared the sense of national pride. However, when the opinions turned among society, media coverage did not follow the tide. In 2008, 79% of Brazilians supported hosting the Cup according to Datafolha Institute; in 2014, the percentage dropped to 52%. Those who were against it rose from 10% to 38%. Contrasting numbers can be related not only to the growing feeling of shame of being fooled by government excesses, but also through innovative online groups that take on the watchdog role.

Many are the reasons that lead to the omission or connivance. Brazilian mainstream media belongs to only nine families: Abravanel, Bloch, Civita, Frias, Levy, Marinho, Mesquita, Nascimento Brito and Saad, some of which also own large construction and development companies. Record, the second largest network in the country with 60 affiliates and broadcasters, is owned by Edir Macedo, banker, bishop, and founder of one of the country’s most prominent evangelical churches. Not many professionals are willing to investigate or openly criticise their bosses. As a consequence, there are repeated cases of reporters associated with such companies being intimidated and excluded from the field when covering manifestations and other non-official events.

It is not exclusively journalists who are to blame for the lack of coverage of certain beats. A survey conducted by the Brazilian Association of Investigative Journalism (ABRAJI) last june evidenced both public and official hostility. During the first month of significant protests, eight journalists were arrested and 52 were beaten by both police (38 reported cases) and protesters (14). The violent approaches affect traditional and alternative media alike. Another example are the numbers presented by Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ)’s Impunity Index. Although Brazil has one of the most vibrant investigative press corps in the Americas, CPJ’s 2013 report ranked Brazil as the eleventh in the world for impunity for crimes against journalists, who were specifically targeted for their work - putting it in situation similar to Pakistan, Russia and Nigeria.

Protests, claims and threats to personal freedom

When coverage does occur, results can be rather disturbing. For instance, a video published by O Globo shows police planting evidence of use of mortars to incriminate demonstrating teachers, in a protest for salary increase for public school workers. All in all, it is important to understand that misconduct is not exclusive to this specific government, but rather institutionalised and sanctioned by 500-year-old self-serving elites. With all the protesting, measures to prevent corruption or that are punitive to unethical leaders are, in best case scenario, “under discussion.”

The most obvious example comes from Maranhão, one of Brazil’s poorest states. Known for using bribery and violent intimidation for keeping itself in power, the Sarney family is openly known for corruption and self-serving. Examples go from land-grabs and censorship to institutionalised boycotts, such as the recent episode when the governor banned a group formed by members of the Human Rights Commission of the Legislative Assembly of Maranhão and members of the Bar Association of Brazil (OAB) from investigating infringements within Pedrinhas Prison Complex. A more comical take of the situation is that of a publicly-funded cultural centre. In it, a room of oil-painted portraits of the family and its political allies are portrayed as Catholic saints, totaling more than 30 frames.

In the wealthy Southeast, police has a more autonomous role towards civilian-oriented violence. As portrayed by blockbusters Elite Squad and City of God, there is a blurry line that separates good and bad guys in the favelas. Whilst drug dealers historically gain respect by part of the population by compensating the absence of public services and providing basic confort such as gas canisters and medication, it is estimated that militias control 45% of Rio de Janeiro’s slums.

Formed by corrupted policemen and former officers, the groups compete for control of poor neighbourhoods with drug dealers. Between 2005 and 2010, the area controlled by these groups has tripled, says a report by the Institute of Social and Political Studies (IESP).

For all this, skepticism surrounds all aspects of security. The law that defines “terrorism” is under discussion in Congress, partly to curb protests. Over 20 paramilitary agents received training from former Blackwater (now Academi), and over $16.5mn has already been spent on paint and water cannons, armored cars, etc in São Paulo alone.

Add to this the gestapo-style displacement of families, increase in poverty-driven sexual exploitation and major setbacks in discussions involving sexual and reproductive rights and press regulations, popular unconformity is sure to follow. In recent months and years, several reports have been published and presented to local and international authorities with allegations of human rights violations such as forced evictions and displacement, forced labour, discrimination, lack of consultation of affected communities, child labour, as well as violent crackdown on demonstrators.

On top of it, the Supreme Court validated benefits to Fifa, foreseen in the “World Cup General Law.” Unanimously (11 votes to none), ministers considered it legal for Brazil to take full liability for damages related to the World Cup. Regarding FIFA exemption from lawsuits, similar positions were maintained.

What comes next

Misinformed, frightened and frustrated, even the most avid supporters aren’t pleased with the recent turn of events. As the foreign community begins to catch on to such instances, it is not surprising that the Olympic Committee is already considering canceling the 2016 Rio games, bringing the event back to the British capital city.

However, such decision ignores fundamental aspects of keeping Brazil under the limelight. According to the Foundation for Studies and Economic Research (University of Sao Paulo), the Confederations Cup alone generated 303,000 jobs. Ernst & Young, in partnership with Getúlio Vargas Foundation (FGV), estimates that 3.63 million jobs will be generated and that $64bn will be injected in the national economy. More importantly, the country is buzzing with journalists that are now seeing issues that, although as old as Brazil itself, have been ignored by foreign media for too long. This might be the much-needed break it needs to get its act together.

So tourists should come to the party. Feel the hospitality, it is amazing. Be dazzled by postcard-sights and understand why, no matter how far from home Brazilians get, even the most prodigal son returns home. But also understand that they refuse to allow national pride to overshadow skeletons in the closet.

Top Brokers