Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

A real fashion revolution

Update : 13 May 2014, 06:14 PM

There are few industrial disasters in recent memory that has shaken up the public conscience the way that the Rana Plaza tragedy has. The death of 1,133 workers on April 23, 2013 focused attention on the high human cost of cheap fashion. Outrage has poured in from every corner of the globe on the appalling conditions that workers have to endure and the outrage has been accompanied by a call to action from all quarters. There was a consensus that all parties involved – international brands, governments, factory owners, trade unions and even consumers  –  need to take action to change the status quo.

This year April 24 was declared “Fashion Revolution” day, an international day of public action with simultaneous events taking place in 51 countries around the world. The main purpose of #fashionrevolution was to commemorate the Rana Plaza tragedy and to raise awareness of the conditions in the global garment supply chain.

The slogan for the event was “meet your maker,” a rather unfortunate choice of words, but the intent is clear enough – get to know the people who are making your clothes. Public education and awareness raising events included screening of documentaries, speaker events with experts, raising funds for the victims and in some places demonstrations and human chains.

However, the rhetoric of  the Fashion Revolution day was far more ambitious than just raising awareness.

To quote from the website: “Together we can use the power of fashion to catalyse change and reconnect the broken links in the supply chain. Wear your clothes inside-out to help start the beginning of an industry-wide transformation towards a more sustainable future.” This call to action to wear your clothes inside out resulted in an avalanche of #insideout hipster selfies on the website, Facebook and Twitter.

Download "Best of 2014"

While this demonstrates a certain level of interest among consumers and perhaps even solidarity with garment workers, it is doubtful that the campaign will generate any kind of real impact on the lives of garment workers in developing countries or the global garment supply chain. 

Squandering the consumer good will

If the revolution fails then certainly the blame can’t be attributed to the consumers. Boycotting is the single most powerful tool consumers have to let companies know that the way they run their business is unacceptable. However, ever since the Rana Plaza strategy, consumers have been consistently told to not boycott clothing from Bangladesh for fear of putting poor people out of their jobs. But what other options are available then?

One of the “action points” on the Fashion Revolution site is to “demand transparency.” That seems like a worthy goal and a reasonable place to start. However, it’s not clear how consumers are supposed to demand transparency and from whom. The global garment supply chain is complex and involves a multitude of players and issues that include production of the fibre, textile, manufacturing of the apparel and then the marketing and retailing of it. All along the supply chain there are considerations of environmental and labour rights. A brief survey of the Fashion Revolution events around the world shows that while most consumer focus right now is on working conditions in the manufacturing part, they are also concerned with other issues along the supply chain. Environmental concerns, in particular, loom large.

In the face of this level of complexity, what does the demand for transparency even mean and who will respond to this? The measures that are being taken so far are meagre at best and by themselves won’t generate meaningful information for action by consumers or civil society watchdogs. For example, the Bangladesh Accord on Fire and Building Safety, or “the Accord” in short, stipulates that a list of suppliers from Bangladesh and their inspection reports will be made public. However, the information will be aggregated for all buyers and it won’t be possible to trace which brand is manufacturing at which factories.

International brands themselves have done very little so far to make their operations more transparent. Sustainability sections of major retail brands such as H&M and Inditex (owner of Zara, among other labels) is full of inspirational rhetoric about what they’re doing to improve the conditions of workers and the environment. While glossy marketing copy describes their “generous” programmes in detail, they are completely mum on the actual results of how these programmes are working.

Some brands on the other hand are trying to capitalise on rising consumer interest in sustainability, to market new product lines. However, consumers need to take a leap of faith, and “trust” that this is not just a marketing ploy as opposed to a real change in manufacturing practices.

If the brands are not required to produce hard evidence that what they are doing is actually improving working conditions or reducing environmental impact, then it becomes all too easy to white-wash the problems that cost money or are difficult to deal with.

Customers have a right to know

It’s almost banal to say that we live in a data-driven age. There is more and more information available for every aspect of our lives and the goods we consume are no exception. There was a time when labelling of ingredients or nutritional information on food products was not the norm.

However, over time the food industry has evolved (often driven by governmental regulation) to provide more detailed information on ingredients and nutrition so that consumers can make more informed choices. In a similar vein, various forms of certification and labelling schemes (for example, Energy Star) are being used to signal to consumers whether appliances or other household items are environmentally and ecologically friendly.

In addition to certification schemes for quality, in recent years increasing attention has been placed on how products are made. Fair Trade works towards equity in global supply chains, by ensuring that producers in developing countries are paid fair prices.

Various types of eco-labelling schemes are taking into account issues such as sourcing of raw materials, amount of hazardous effluents in the production process and even packaging. Moreover, ever-broader categories of products are using sustainability labelling. For example, in Nordic countries the Nordic Swan eco-label now covers 63 different product groups, from appliances, computers, hand soaps to furniture and hotels.

All of this is to say that perhaps it’s time to think about a labelling scheme for the apparel industry that will allow customers to make a more informed choice about which brands and manufacturing practices they are willing to support. This will also enable customers to distinguish between “good” and “bad” brands and reward companies that are willing to go the extra mile to ensure sustainability in their supply chains.

As I mentioned before, the garment supply chain is long and complex, therefore it will take some effort to develop meaningful certification schemes that can distinguish between the good and the bad performers along metrics such as environmental impact, fair trade and working conditions in manufacturing plants.

Brands are of course likely to complain that transparency comes at a cost. However, because of advances in technology it is easier and cheaper now than ever before to generate the data necessary to be able to do these kinds of assessments. Moreover, given that the global ready-made apparel industry is estimated to generate up to $2tn of revenue a year, with a steadily increasing profit margin, the cost argument can only go so far.

To present this data usefully to consumers one can imagine something like the use of QR codes on products, which when scanned will take customers to a website, where they can find detailed information about the sustainability of the production process of the item of clothing they are about to purchase.

For forward-thinking brands that are actually making concrete positive changes along their supply chain, this will give them a competitive advantage, as they will be able to distinguish themselves from less caring competitors. On the other hand, this will also allow consumers and civil society to aim their advocacy efforts towards brands that refuse to provide these details.

Making the supply chain more transparent to consumers will also discourage opportunistic business practices, such as moving production from countries with rising levels of environmental and labour rights standards to less compliant producer countries in order to cut costs. This will complement the efforts that are underway at the moment, such as the Accord and the Alliance, to improve conditions in countries like Bangladesh.

Transparency can be the catalyst for a real fashion revolution

The feel-good rhetoric of creating jobs and improving lives in third world countries has served fast fashion brands well. The Rana plaza tragedy along with a string of similar incidents in recent years, has seriously called into question the truth of this claim. There is the beginning of an understanding that the complexity of the global garment supply chain can no longer be used as an excuse to hide abuse of workers and the environment, and that there needs to be a higher level of accountability for brands that are making billions by exploiting this complexity. 

Consumer action can significantly impact industry practices and they can hold brands accountable by voting with their wallets. However, this will not be possible if they are not given meaningful information that will help them choose. Consumers need better options than boycotting all clothing made in countries such as Bangladesh or continuing business as usual.

Rana plaza has started a global conversation on what consumers can do to ensure that the clothes on their back is not killing people on the other side of the planet. But we now need to take this interest and desire for change and translate it into results by enabling consumers to act. Otherwise, #fashionrevolution will mean little more than a feel good exercise for western consumers while workers in developing countries continue to suffer.

Top Brokers