In the heart of old Dhaka surrounded by pencil high-rise apartments is a house with crumbling yellow plaster that says a lot about its inhabitant whose age can be anybody’s guess. His mind is still sharp, reminiscing the days of the past and the country in its wholesome days.
In our time, he muses, we voted for political stars, not a bunch of silly nick names like Montu or Jhontu. Names mattered because they told us where they came from and where they could take us. Sadly, all that is in the past and today we only have brands like Awami League, BNP, Jamaat-e-Islami, etc.
People vote for symbols rather than character, symbols that have long lost the meanings of their origin. What have we become as a nation? Mere sleepwalkers in a world of vain promises and futile hopes? Why are we asked to vote for nationalism where none exists and for service to the people which comes as periodic killings and street terror?
What happened here can perhaps be understood by a recap of how we lost touch with the very democratic spirit we were trying to create at the birth of the country. In our euphoria of liberation from an oppressive partner we became so indebted to the liberators who had released us from bondage that we overlooked the fact that bondage could reappear in other forms too. The flames of devotion were so bright that we forgot altogether that descent needs to be sustained to preserve the essence of democracy. We let it die slowly.
The country’s infrastructure at that time was far from shambles, not the typical post-conflict situation. All that was needed was good governance to get the machineries running again. What did we do instead? We got lost in political adulation and looked away from many things that just didn’t look right.
In other words we did not help create the effective opposition that could keep the party in power to the straight and narrow. The outcome was not very pleasant. Every government that came to power subsequently had to wrestle it from the incumbent with threat or bloodshed or both. Every time there was a switch of government the oppressor became the oppressed, hell bent upon putting its nemesis out of business from day one.
The same spirit persists today. The political fall-out of this is that a substantial part of the energy of any government is now deployed to keep the opposition at bay instead of attending to the needs of the nation. Bi-partisanship has become a dirty word, the parliament does not function, and street thugs determine the economic future of the country. The play goes on and on with extraordinary predictability while the bewildered polity watches passively from the sidelines.
So where is the salvation? How long will this game between the two political adversaries go on? Can the presence of a strong third party break this vicious cycle? I mean a forceful third party with real teeth whose leader does not have to check into a hospital every time he sees a crisis coming.
There are many ways in which a sizable third party could provide a break in the oppressive atmosphere. It can help the opposition deny the governing party votes that they need in the parliament to pass ill-conceived legislations. It could force the opposition to compromise when it is needed. Of course it has its downsides too, but the overall positives it could deliver in the context of this politically volatile nation should lead us to judgment.
Third parties exist in many countries and their effectiveness has differed from country to country depending upon the system of government. If we look briefly at how they have fared in some of the more developed democracies and some less developed ones we could get a better understanding of its value for us.
First case in point is the United States with a presidential form of government. Even though the American constitution allows for third parties, the Electoral College system (i.e. winner takes all) makes it difficult for third parties to be consequential except maybe take some votes away from the majors.
This deficiency, however, is made up to a large extent by the constitutional division of power between the executive and the legislative branches and the electorates usually make sure that both don’t simultaneously reside with one party. Once in a while, however, when the Americans are caught in a political morass, they start having second thoughts about their duo-party system, as we saw in the 1992 election (the Ross Perot revolt) and the 2012 election (the dysfunctional government crusade).
High level of dissatisfaction with both parties rekindles debate for third party prominence. Some states have even tried to correct the representation imbalance by dividing the total Electoral College votes rather than giving it outright to the winner. Although these efforts have not amounted to much (except in two states) they have kept the debate alive. The states’ own independent policies that have more profound impact on people’s lives have kept the idea in the back burner.
The second case in point is the United Kingdom, a parliamentary democracy. It also has a two party system with the majoritarian principle (first-past-the-post principle) where a candidate from any party receiving the highest votes in a single seat constituency wins.
Some exceptions take place in multiple seat constituencies where other provisions of the system may kick in including alternate vote, bloc vote, etc. The country, however, has not always felt at ease with this arrangement and time and again voices of dissent have arisen for a more egalitarian proportional representation (PR) system.
The main reason for this is that FPTP often provides a win for a party in the parliamentary elections with less than 50% of the popular votes, thereby diminishing its moral position for majority rule. Even when sizeable national support is amassed by the smaller parties in an election it comes to nought and in effect is wasted as the recipients do not qualify for any seat in the parliament. Smaller parties do not fare well under the FPTP system.
The advantage of the PR system is that it allows ranked voting. One particular form of PR that has gained popularity is the single transferable vote (STV) system where a voter could indicate his ranked preference for all candidates in a ballot. A candidate requires only a set number of votes to win (pre-determined by a formula).
Votes cast in his favour in excess of this number are automatically transferred to the next candidate according to the voters’ choice list and so on. This not only gets rid of the “wasted vote” problem but also allows voters to pitch for candidates of their choice rather than a slate of party hacks.
Proportional representation encourages coalition or minority government which can be less confrontational and able to force all sides to make compromises towards a middle ground.
The idea, however, lost traction in the UK following the national referendum pushed by the Liberal Democrats after the 2010 election. The present two party system continues without much problem though perhaps because both the Labor and the Conservatives have refrained from extreme party politics.
The third case in point, Australia, presents an interesting blend of the FPTP and the PR models. It uses instant run-off voting (IRV) to elect members to its lower House of Representatives and single transferable vote (STV) for the upper Senate. They bear many similarities and in fact STV applied to a single electorate system resembles the IRV.
Voters rank order their choice of candidates and the one with over 50% of the votes cast wins. However, if no one gets over 50% then the candidate getting the lowest number of votes is eliminated and his second preference votes are distributed to others in the list.
The process is repeated until someone emerges with the required 50% of the votes. The biggest advantage of IRV is that it prevents split votes and it does provide more opportunities for third parties to win seats in the parliament.
This in fact has enabled medium-sized parties like the National Party to build coalition with others like the Liberal Party without fear of losing due to vote splitting. Third parties also do better in the Australian Senate which follows the STV model.
The fourth case in point, India, has a multi-party system with a number of national and regional parties. Many believe that this system suits developing countries better because it allows shifting coalitions to develop and no single party can get the upper hand.
Others believe that this could be a bane to the political process because continuously shifting alliances can create frequent upheavals and disruptions. Some of India’s past history bears this out. The life span of the Janata Dal-led National Front and the Left Front coalition in 1989 was only two years. Between 1996 and 1998 several short run alliances came and went. But then again coalitions with the right partnership could be more lasting.
The 1998 National Democratic Alliance (NDA) coalition led by BJP did last for 5 years. Also, the Congress-led United Progressive Alliance (UPA) lasted the full 5 years from 2004 to 2009 and again from 2009 to 2014. In fact the two major party alliances, the UPA and the NDA have almost changed the character of the Indian political system to a two-party system.
The durability of the Indian alliances is partly explained by the compatibility of the alliance partners as well as the relative strengths of member parties. India is a Federation where the States play powerful roles in shaping the character of political parties.
Strong state parties (or even regional parties) are sometimes the result of build-up around particular ideology of interest groups or charismatic individuals. They have extreme capacities to influence the national politics. Alliance partnerships are thus better positioned for co-existence.
Yet, even within the perceived safe armours of the two major coalitions led by Congress and the BJP, serious chinks now seem to be appearing. The stormy win of the Aam Aadmi Party (Arvind Kejriwal) in the 2013 Delhi election has sparked hopes in many that new parties can also win if they present a solid platform and run with the sentiments of the people. If nothing else, it seems to be making the majors rethink the way they have done business in the past.
The fifth and last case in point is Pakistan. It is a federal republic with four provinces and two federally administered territories. It has a multi-party electoral system with two houses in the centre, the Senate and the National Assembly and four independent provincial assemblies.
With intermittent break from army rule, civilian administration in Pakistan generally has been on the basis of quite fragile coalitions. No party can really claim to be a national party and each of them derive their strength from regional power bases.
Three major parties that had previously dominated the political space were the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP), Pakistan Muslim League (N), and Pakistan Muslim League (Q). But in the May 2013 election the PTI party (a previous lightweight led by Imran Khan) rose quite unexpectedly through an anticorruption crusade and became the third major party very close behind the PPP winning 23 out of 264 seats in the Parliament and 57 seats in the provincial assemblies.
It also became the second highest vote getter in the home constituency of PPP, the city of Karachi. PTI’s strategy in Karachi was primarily taken out of Obama’s playbook – tapping into the youth votes through internet and social media. Additionally, Karachi, which is the business hub of Pakistan, responded to the continued violence and corruption that hurt its industries and businesses badly.
On top of these was the charisma of Imran Khan, somewhat of a national cricket hero there. It is quite likely that this newcomer’s inroad, just like the AAP in India may start a trend towards major changes in the defunct politics of Pakistan.
So what can we learn from all this? For one, we see that representative democracy works best when people actually see the fruits of their votes. Votes wasted, or not counted lead to indifference towards voting and even produce resentment that could translate to unpleasant actions.
Secondly, majoritarian systems work only when other avenues are available to check the excesses of majority rule. Thirdly, long periods of bad governance make the voters look for alternatives and create opportunities for third parties. Finally, charismatic leadership attracts followers even to minor parties (Kejriwal, Imran Khan).
When we examine Bangladesh through these lenses the following picture emerges. Theoretically, Bangladesh is a multi-party democracy but it has devolved into a two-party hegemony. Sure there are political alliances but they are weak and ineffective for the following reasons.
Individual alliance partners do not command significant public support, they don’t have significant presence in regional politics, they don’t have a cause célèbre or a unifying ideology, and they are simply happy to follow their dominant partners.
The country has also lacked good governance for very long. Institutions that could demand accountability (public accounts committee, anticorruption bureau, ombudsman) have practically disappeared. Finally, sycophancy has stunted the growth of alternate charismatic leadership.
The country really has two choices then, to break the two-party domination or to reform the electoral system in a manner that makes it difficult for any party, major or minor, to exploit public sentiments for long. The first is perhaps easier to achieve.
The recent Indian and Pakistani phenomenon can provide the incentive. That means mass support of a third party which can force the present majors towards more rational behaviour.
What is needed to achieve this? A cause that fires voters’ enthusiasm and some charismatic leadership. We have plenty of the former and maybe a little of the later. The result of the recent municipal elections in the country could be an indicator. Can we pick up the gauntlet?



