Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

How the ‘Media Has Failed Women’ has failed

Update : 23 Jan 2014, 07:17 PM

Rise and shine. Feminism is the air. Body positivity, body image, female empowerment, sexism, objectification, and misogyny are some words that seem to be continually flung around on laminated gold papers, like fiery shurikens hurling through the air. All these terms and their meanings are nicely lumped into one video that has been stampeding the Internet since the beginning of December last year – How the Media Has Failed Women in 2013.

Here, we see glimpses of female figures ranging from Malala Yousafzai to Sandra Bullock to Hillary Clinton to Miley Cyrus to Rachel Maddow to Rihanna, some portraying positive representation and some negative, with the common themes of positivity being intelligence, talent, leadership and achievement, and the common themes of negativity being body exposure, sexualisation, rape culture perpetuation, and methodic snide mocking, which is in effect bullying, from male peers.

No one will argue the intentionality of the media in presenting information in such ways to create and inculcate in viewers certain social constructs and no one will argue the collective failure of eliminating rape culture and the societal disadvantages of women. However, what is questionable is the indication that the media directors are the sole perpetuators of these constructs in the media.

Such an indication, when extended to include women exposing their bodies or sexualising themselves, assumes a lack of agency on the woman’s part and adopts the view that she is an unknowing victim of exploitation, or assumes a lack of intelligence on her part and adopts the view that she is an unknowing victim of societal indoctrination, catering to hegemonic cis-male privilege.

How is this sheep-like view of women any better than however the media is portraying them? Women, like the pop artists referenced in the video, are highly successful in their careers and are talented musicians as well as creative performers, irrespective of whether or not their style can be reconciled with one’s artistic preferences. So are they really being exploited or are they turning it around and exploiting that very exploitation of women, to their own advantage?

A huge issue is the dated notion of correlating self-respect and dignity with attire (or lack thereof). If self-presentation is the issue and if pop artists like Rihanna and Miley Cyrus are coerced products of a culture that fetishizes hyper-sexualization, who will reasonably argue that those women who wear a hijab or burkha are any less coerced into their decision by the cultures relevant to them?

Women face presentational pressures from both sides of the spectrum. Today, if I go out wearing a niqab, I’m a product of religious oppression. The day after, if I go out wearing a short skirt, I’m a “slut.” There is no escape. On a clothing-style scale of 1 to 10, we have to shrink and squeeze ourselves somewhere in the range of 4 to 6; trespassing beyond that in either direction would put us women in dangerous territory.

Also, by definition a “slut” is a female who engages in sexual relations indiscriminately. Even if we were to naively assume that one’s wardrobe spells out one’s sexual lifestyle, so what if a woman did have multiple sexual relations? Since which stage of evolution has sexuality become an exclusively male domain?

Sociologically speaking, and in the words of Anthony Giddens, sexuality and relationships in the post-modern world are apparently governed by confluent love, a liberal and contingent romantic construct that had come to be under “pressures of female sexual emancipation and autonomy.”

Why is it then, that when a man has many sexual experiences, those are seen as conquests and he is perceived as a “player” while a woman with similar tendencies still gets the label of “slut” or some other derogatory term, not only by men but also by other women.

To give a little personal anecdote, I have been schooled in supposedly the best private school in Dhaka and the tasteless sexism I have witnessed, and also personally experienced from both the authorities and my peers, in the latter years of my time there, had generated in me a raging disgust that had entirely masked the earlier happy memories and left me with avoidant tendencies.

I was called in and shamed, my parents were called in and blatantly lied to. Two of the least caustic (and filtered) examples of two different authorities’ dialogues: “You’re the girl. You’re the one society will always point to. You’re a very intelligent lady and we have high expectations of you, and not just academically. I hope you will not disappoint us,” and “If there weren’t these distractions like yourself, he could have done something very big by now.”

The former person’s approach focuses on me and eloquently informs me that if I don’t conform to their idea of standard female behaviour, there can be repercussions. The latter person’s approach, skilfully and wonderfully articulates her view that I am holding back “Da Man.” Technically, we were both students of the school, but I had been dehumanised and reduced to a mere object, an object of distraction for the male student.

There is good reason I limited the second quotation to just one sentence and don’t feel comfortable sharing the rest of what was said. Needless to say, these were references to a relationship I was in at the time. Needless to say, I was the villain. Needless to say, the boy was never called in. No, I did not sexually assault him whenever I saw him. I did not otherwise “distract” him with my rampant sexuality whenever I saw him either.

All I did was talk to him – conversations I don’t recall ever initiating myself, considering I was very aware that every little nuance in my movements and sneezes were being observed.

In other words, all I did was exist and that was criminal enough to warrant systematic humiliation. It wasn’t just me, although with lesser frequency and vigor, there were also other girls who were monitored and - when perceived necessary - spoken to. Such is the hypocrisy of elitist private schools that claim themselves to be liberal and progressive.

I have grown up in a culture that religiously and systematically teaches women to keep themselves in check; a fitted top, gym shorts, or even the slightest slip of my dupatta would attract the gaze of five hundred rickshawalas and condemnation by five hundred relatives.

While one half of the feminist world is screaming about body positivity and denouncing obligatory covering up, the other half is equating being classy to not exposing our bodies. The irony lies in that both have male objectification in mind; the only difference is that one is fighting against it and rejecting it (but is denounced as encouraging it), and the other is hiding from it as protection (and is denounced as accommodating to it).

Like many others, I had the constant awareness of this condition at the back of my head all my life, this condition of being female, and once and for all I would like to start dressing and behaving according to my own set of ideals and my own aesthetic sense without thinking of how male-dominated the world is and how my choice of dressing will be perceived to relate to that.

What is it about the sight of the female body that sets off so many cues of threat? Why is it that one form of exposure is acceptable but another isn’t? It is clearly not that the very idea of exposure is unacceptable. Here is where the wild hypocrisy lies, the hypocrisy of art, the hypocrisy of being.

Nudity and sexuality are acceptable only when presented within a certain framework, authenticated by a certain context, therefore only when it appeals to a certain kind of aesthetic. Brooke Candy’s partial nudity is inacceptable, but Kate Winslet’s nudity in Titanic is beautiful. Silk Smitha’s semi-nudity is profane, but Vidya Balan’s semi-nudity while depicting that same Silk Smitha merits her multiple international awards. Anne Hathway’s nudity in Havoc is acting, but Rihanna’s raunchiness is classless. Natalie Portman’s nudity in Hotel Chevalier is art, but Miley Cyrus’ bawdiness means she is letting the music industry pimp her into the world of stylised pornography and glamorous prostitution.

Then there are classic nude portraits that have been hailed throughout history – Albert Moore’s A Summer Night, Albrecht Drurer’s Adam and Eve, and of course Michael Angelo’s David. By virtue of the fact that nudity and sexuality are represented in art form, they must have some sort of perceived beauty. But that beauty is criminalised when it is those very things of which those art forms are a representation, us, our bodies, that are presented similarly.

What is it about dynamic visual representation that threatens people’s sense of social structure? It is socially acceptable to talk about nudity and sex (but then again only in conditioned settings), to write about nudity and sex (but then again only in moderated language), to privately engage in sexual activities (but then again only in traditionally accepted styles and circumstances), but it is not at all acceptable to be publicly sexual or claim sexuality.

My disapproval of this schism between action and representation, and the double standard of propriety is valid only in so far as the action isn’t inherently nasty or ugly. I am not saying, for example, that just because we defecate, we should also celebrate feces and glorify them in visual representations. However, there is nothing inherently nasty about the human body and sexuality.

So yes, we have talked about the double standard of the media, we have talked about how it has failed women. Now let’s talk about the double standard of feminist groups and the double standard of every woman, every man and everyone else of all other gender identities that perpetuate body-shaming and sexuality-shaming culture.

Top Brokers