June 5, 2011: A 33-year-old lady is assaulted by her other half in Dhaka. The attack by her husband not only leaves the lady with a broken heart but also robs her of eyesight, one of the greatest gifts bestowed upon human beings. A month later, she flies to Canada for treatment – after Indian doctors gave up – only to learn that the damage will stay with her till she breathes her last.
October 9, 2012: A 15-year-old girl is shot in the head by members of a fearsome outfit in Swat, of Pakistan’s Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province. The assassination bid leaves the teenager in critical condition, and she is flown to England for better treatment. She survives but the assault confounds her. She never thought advocacy of girls’ education would lead to such a ghastly incident.
If you’ve identified the second individual but are confused about the first, you are probably not alone.
To understand how these two people relate to one another, let’s decode the identities.
The second person is Malala Yousafzai. The first one is Rumana Monzur.
Does the name ring a bell?
Some of you may have forgotten her partly or completely. Well, she is the woman who used to teach International Relations at the University of Dhaka and was blinded by her own husband in a barbaric attack.
Rumana was pursuing a higher degree at the University of British Columbia (UBC) and was on a visit to Bangladesh at the time of the attack.
What was meant to be a pleasant vacation for her eventually turned into a nightmare, as the man who fathered her only daughter bit off part of her nose and inflicted permanent damage on her eyes.
And all those acts were, according to Rumana, provoked by jealousy.
“Jealousy engulfed him the moment I decided to continue my studies in Canada,” Rumana said, though her husband accused her of unfaithfulness.
Police arrested Rumana’s husband Hasan Sayeed after the attack and he died in prison five months later. It was said that the man had taken his own life.
Where is Rumana now? How is she?
More than two years passed since the attack and Rumana says she is now in her “comfort zone.” With that, she actually points at the UBC campus, where she lives with her daughter and parents. They were also granted permanent resident status on humanitarian grounds last September.
Rumana is currently pursuing a degree in law at UBC after successfully completing postgraduate studies. The blind yet studious lady was accepted into three law schools, though she decided to continue at UBC.
Now I earlier hinted at similarity between Rumana and Malala. Is there really any?
Juxtaposition of Rumana and Malala:
One may argue that both of them are starkly dissimilar. On closer inspection, however, it is revealed that:
1. Both of them are exceedingly passionate about studies and education. After the horrifying experiences they were subjected to, they could have decided to abandon studies and simply get on with life. Instead, they refused to give in to the situation, though it was a bitter pill to swallow.
Malala resumed schooling in England and said: “I’m excited that I’ve achieved my dream of going back to school.”
On the other hand, Rumana victoriously returned to UBC to finish the unfinished war. She was in her thirties and said: “I can feel the positive energy of these young people at the university, and that makes me happy. Studies are my passion. I must pursue that.”
2. Both of them are shining examples of German philologist and philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche’s quotation: “What doesn’t kill me, makes me stronger.”
“Nothing changed in my life except this: weakness, fear and hopelessness died. Strength, power and courage was born.” This is what Malala said while speaking at the UN this year.
Rumana expressed a similar feeling as well when she said: “I’m stubborn and told myself that after what I’ve been through, nothing can be harder than that. My husband’s death wasn’t significant to me. My basic objective is to try to live a meaningful life. I can’t stop because I became blind.”
3. Both of them focus on solutions, not problems. Rumana opines that dwelling on what happened only leads to questions without answers.
“If I think about it, it just leads me nowhere. It was the incident. I don’t want people to see me as a victim. I want people to see me as a survivor.”
This closely resembles Malala’s view who, in her UN address, said: “I do not even hate the Talib who shot me. I’m here to speak up for the right of education for every child. Books and pens are our most powerful weapons. Education is the only solution. Education First.”
Why Rumana is a greater hero than Malala
Notwithstanding the similarities, Rumana, is in essence, a person of much greater stature. Why? Malala protested against restrictions on girls’ schools imposed by the Taliban and was consequently shot. She was already familiar with the oppressive acts of the Taliban when gunmen attempted to knock her off.
On the contrary, Rumana was assaulted by her husband. Attacks by members of a militant group and those of a husband are two utterly disparate experiences. For Rumana, it was unexpected to the highest extent.
Imagine Sayeed, the guy with whom Rumana dreamed of staying for the rest of her life. As it turned out, this was the guy who left her blind forever.
Jewish American stand-up comedian and TV writer Cathy Ladman said marriage is like a 5,000-piece jigsaw puzzle. Rumana presumably comprehended the absolute profundity of the statement.
But rather than saying that “I’m at the end of my rope,” a resilient Rumana decided to bite off more than she could chew, and that’s what helped her reach a far greater height than Malala.
The dogged lady fought back and flew to Canada to resume her studies. But the fight took on a new dimension as Rumana’s ability to see was completely gone. So how can one study if he can’t see?
It was a tip of the iceberg to which Rumana responded “the skills that come with adapting to blindness would take care of themselves over time.”
That conviction eventually proved to be a triumph over difficulties. She learned to read Braille as a last resort and got used to adaptive technology to read and write.
Apart from learning how to use a cane to navigate her way, she mastered the skill of learning and memorizing study materials by listening to recorded audio and at present, she is learning law by listening at UBC.
She has many friends who read out lessons to her. She also amazed her professors, who acknowledge they’ve never seen someone adapt to changing circumstances so fast.
But don’t be tempted into thinking that the entire journey was child’s play. It was all about leaving your motherland to settle in a foreign country after being ripped apart mentally. It was all about getting up and moving forward after being turned upside down by myriad tribulations. It was all about learning how to live everyday without the opportunity to see your own daughter and parents.
“Each moment, I miss seeing (my daughter) and not only her, I miss seeing people,” Rumana told The Toronto Star.
Last but the not the least, it was all about presenting a master’s thesis (The impact of climate change and rise in ocean levels in Bangladesh) and then attending the question and answer session as a blind student.
“I had to present the thesis before my teachers, fellow students and a bunch of other attendees. My whole concentration was on the presentation. Everything else just disappeared from my mind. I was handling the questions. After all that finished, I couldn’t believe that I’ve successfully done the whole thing,” Rumana told a Bangladeshi daily.
All in all, the extremity of Rumana’s misery beat that of Malala in numerous ways. Malala was shot, received intensive treatment and recovered. As for Rumana, she lost her vision and coped with a whole new ball game.
But how did Rumana escaped everyone’s notice?
Malala’s prominence needs no mentioning. In January this year, Deutsche Welle said Malala may have become “the most famous teenager in the world.” Yes, Malala somehow became a cult figure.
She was also blessed with supporters who literally went crazy to make sure that the yet-to-reach-adolescence girl was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize, though it finally went to the OPCW (Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons).
Both Rumana and Malala made international headlines following attacks on them. Nonetheless, it’s irksome that Malala continually managed to be in the limelight while Rumana’s story petered out. Surprising? Not at all. Rumana, compared to Malala, didn’t receive the least bit of activism or campaigns that might have made her a well-known figure. This is what went wrong with Rumana but right with Malala.
Rumana didn’t get UN Special Envoy for Global Education Gordon Brown to launch a petition under the slogan “I am Rumana” to demand that violence against women be stopped.
Time magazine didn’t feature Rumana as one of “The 100 Most Influential People in the World.” She didn’t win Simone de Beauvoir Prize, an international human rights accolade for women’s freedom. She wasn’t invited to the UN to call for worldwide eradication of violence against women. The list of what this Bangladeshi lady missed could be very, very long.
Well, one can argue that Malala had a message and hence rose to a high standing by spreading that. But hey, hang on a minute.
“I hope other women and girls, including my own daughter, can learn from the horrors I experienced at the hands of my spouse,” Rumana told The Toronto Star.
“When you belong to the privileged class, you never think domestic violence can happen to you. I wasn’t sharing my problems, my marriage issues or issues of domestic violence when I was experiencing it.
“I felt it was a shame for me, but I didn’t realize at that time that it is not a shame for me, it is a shame for the people who are doing it. That is the most important message I want to tell women who are experiencing it and keeping silent.”
Either it wasn’t a message worth spreading or it was missed. To me, the second one is true.
From unnoticed to ‘Daughter of the Year’
Nearly 15 months after the attack, a rare honour was finally conferred upon Rumana and it came following her master’s-level educational achievement. Canada’s Citizens For A Civil Society and Indo-Canadian Women’s Association jointly organized the first ever Daughter’s Day in Edmonton on September 1, 2012. And guess what? It was Rumana who won the Daughter of the Year award.
The day is observed to honour achievements of women in various fields and to take initiatives to stop all sorts of violence against women. For Rumana, blindness was surely full of pent-up distress.
But on September 1, 2012, she might have told herself: Every cloud has a silver lining.
A number of Canadian newspapers published Rumana’s interview where she, with her eyes closed, was seen holding a cane. Yet, the lady, an unsung hero in Bangladesh, looked confident and determined.
“I don’t want to stand in front of my daughter as a woman who is a victim of assault. My battle is still on. And my only wish is to make Anusheh say that her mother can do everything,” she said in the interview.
The victor inspires thousands
Women who have never experienced violence will easily ignore Rumana’s story the way girls who can go to school every day without any fear or resistance will find no reason to pay heed to Malala.
But for 87% of married women in Bangladesh who are subjected to violence by their husbands (according to a recent survey of Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics), Rumana will always be an inspirational figure who knows how to win against all odds by keeping your morale at the peak after you’ve lost your vision for life.
And she could do more
Gordon Brown’s “I Am Malala” petition facilitated ratification of the Right to Free and Compulsory Education Bill in Pakistan. But Malala as a person exerts a far stronger force on people’s minds than the bill and that’s the beauty of embodiment.
In Bangladesh, we have the Prevention of Repression against Women and Children (Amendment) Act 2003 and the Domestic Violence (Prevention & Protection) Act 2010. However, what is missing here is embodiment. And all I’m suggesting is that instead of publishing a handful of pieces of news concerning a Bangladeshi woman who was blinded in her homeland but was later honoured abroad for her accomplishments, Bangladeshi media can embody her in a way that will raise awareness of violence against women.
Such a step will do another magical thing. Many argue that Malala is just propaganda as there are thousands of others who found themselves in the same situation like this Pakistani girl but still remain unheard. But if the so-called propaganda can ensure fearless schooling for more girls, then it certainly has done more good than harm. So, by the same token, why not go for the Rumana propaganda, provided it can convey the message that “where there’s life, there’s hope” to those 87 Bangladeshi women out of every 100 and eventually help bring down the rate of violence against women in the country?
And how do we do that? To my mind, the “I Am Rumana” book could be the first step.
Want a copy of ‘I Am Rumana?’
British journalist Christina Lamb co-authored “I Am Malala: The Girl Who Stood Up For Education and Was Shot By The Taliban” which is the autobiography of Malala. It was published in early October 2013 and became talk of the town.
But let’s forget awhile whether this book is really worth reading. All I’m saying is the book served its purpose as an essential tool to promote the Pakistani teenager. It embodied her and spread her story across the world. People who aren’t into news or world events can get the whole picture of Malala’s journey once they read the book. Even prominent Pakistani journalist Hamid Mir observes the book contains many good topics.
This is exactly that can happen to Rumana, though it will be very cumbersome for a blind person to write down her story. But anyone can resort to dictation to get it done, no matter how long it takes.
So here comes the crucial question: Who is going to be the Christina Lamb for Rumana to write “I Am Rumana: The Bangladeshi Lady Who Wished To Pursue Higher Studies in Canada and Was Blinded by Her Husband Because of Jealousy?”
Lamb says she has always wanted to be a writer and has been interested in writing about other people. Hello, is there any ardent individual out there interested in Rumana? Rest assured that it has many elements to become a bestseller. However, even if it fails to reach that level, it will still speak volumes about Bangladesh.



