Digital Bangladesh (DB) is being interpreted in many different ways: some view it as procuring computers and other related devices, some upgrade this to combine mobile phones and other modern information and communication technology (ICT) tools and policies, but very few conceive it as a demand driven, citizen-centric, social development agenda.
Many writers in both Bangla and English dailies are restlessly criticising DB from as many angles as possible. Most recently, one daily’s Editorial section opined how DB agenda is failing to live up to its expectation in terms of allowing more freedom of expression and speech. One cannot disagree with this argument when citizens are being persecuted for expressing their opinions through their own private pages in social medial platforms. However, such myopic interpretation of DB’s implementation is both alarming and disappointing.
This article argues that DB is a national programme encompassing all socio-economic sectors, transcending the boundary of party politics. To be concise, it is an umbrella which is helping to plant the seeds for cultivating a culture of innovation within the civil service bureaucracy.
Three initiatives are discussed in the hope of providing a more socially meaningful interpretation of DB (Box 1 presents some key achievements). First, it is known that in order to reduce the information gap excluding millions residing in rural and remote areas, community information centres (CICs) or one-stop information and service centres are in operation across many countries around the world. All 4,500+ Union Information and Service Centres (UISCs), established in 2010 and working at the lowest government tier, are hosted in local government institutions.
One per cent of the government’s total Annual Development Programme (ADP) is directed towards ensuring the sustainability of these micro-enterprises indicating their sharp contrast with conventional CICs.
Today, a citizen walks 3 km to a nearby UISC saving transaction, opportunity and contingent costs of going to the district headquarter 35 km away. Many ministries of the government have redesigned their services to make them “e-deliverable” through these centres.
As a result of their ubiquity, a farmer in a remote location can quickly learn about appropriate fertilizer and pesticide; a victim of domestic abuse can easily access information on legal recourse; a villager can apply for land records without having to deal with intermediaries; a patient can seek expert medical advice; child marriages and forms of home-based injustice can be redressed through the UISC Blog; a beggar can become an owner of a bank account thanks to branchless mobile banking; and, most strikingly, at a time when remittances are overtaking traditional flows of development finance comprising of foreign aid and foreign investment, a migrant worker can participate in government-to-government (Bangladesh-Malaysia) migration opportunities without having to travel to Dhaka.
A poor migration worker has to pay at least Tk200,000 to Tk300,000 through financial loans or selling land and other properties at the pre-migration stage. The latter has undergone significant transformation as a result of the UISCs position within the government machinery.
Box 2 presents some data portraying UISCs’ performance as a last mile service delivery agent.
One of the other significant changes has been the establishment of District e-Service Centres (DESC) across all 64 districts. Over the last two hundred years, Deputy Commissioner’s (DC) offices have been providing a wide range of public services (licenses, certificates, land documents, revenue, enquiries, education, relief, social welfare, etc), which were very unpredictable and consumed both time and money of the service seeker.
DESCs have simplified the back-end governance processes associated with the disclosure and delivery of public information and services, and thereby, transformed the way public service is being delivered today. Citizens, regardless of their social profile, can avoid face-to-face interactions with the government officials, a process traditionally considered as intimidating for the less literate, and opportune for rent-seeking. In addition, as a result of the mushrooming of UISCs across Bangladesh, citizens do not need to visit the district head-quarters for tracking their application.
Table 1 provides a snapshot of the service delivery transformation taking place through the DESC. In particular, decision-making time has been drastically reduced as a result of increased predictability in the delivery of public service.
Finally, DB’s novelty lies not in its grand visions but rather on how it is to be implemented. The latter process demands triggering change in the values, attitudes and skills of government officials.
Nevertheless, bureaucracy is rule-based and experimentation is discouraged. Even when a public service innovator takes the first step, convinces the higher ups and colleagues, and the initiative sees light, there is no way to reward the innovator; but, there can certainly be a slap on the wrist from his/her superiors.
By the virtue of an official Innovation Team gazette in 2013, the aforesaid situation has been tackled at least from the policy perspective. The ministry level e-Governance Focal Points, working since 2008, graduated to Chief Innovation Officers (CIOs) and all directorate, district and sub-district level focal points saw the appointment of Innovation Officers (IOs). Their mandate is to generate and implement innovations aimed at simplifying the service delivery process.
In addition, these teams can seek the support of the multi-donor Service Innovation Fund (SIF) in order to fill financial resource gaps for supporting their creative initiatives. An Innovation Forum is organised quarterly which provides a platform for CIOs and IOs to come together and share their field-level experience.
Perhaps it is the Awami League’s weakness that it has not been able to propagate its DB successes in a way that would make developmental sense to the non-technologically savvy mass. May be it is the opposite and that is why the Grand Alliance, excluding Jaitya Party, is adamant in the all-party caretaker government agenda. Or, failures have been so large that it overshadows Awami League’s successes to the extent that it is unwittingly adopting an “in the name of development, we can govern forever” approach.
Regardless of what the Awami League is thinking today, it has to come to terms with the fact that the credit of brining changes in the traditional service delivery process goes to the government machinery, not only party loyalists.
It is the dawn of a new beginning, an alternative path to making public service responsive through increased predictability in the decision-making process. DB is a product of the Awami League and if the latter is sincere in its vision, then it also must believe that DB agenda will need to be endorsed and implemented by successive governments for the betterment of citizens’ lives. DB will need to be firmed up through other visionary initiatives which may or may not look beyond 2021, but will try to compensate for some of its shortcomings.
Will any non-Grand Alliance government reverse the gear of development and discard all the strides made to date?
As a citizen of Bangladesh, I would like to believe not.



