The potential adverse effects of global warming and climate change put Bangladesh in the most vulnerable position. This is the second and concluding part of the article which highlights Bangladesh’s options for mitigation and adaptation.
‘Cap-and-Trade’ principle and carbon markets
Carbon credits form the basic currency of “cap-and-trade” systems for reducing greenhouse gas emissions. Such systems include the Chicago Climate Exchange, EU-ETS and the Kyoto Protocol. These systems are also known as Emission Trading Schemes (ETS).
The Government initially allocates a number of allowances to each company. Any company that exceeds its emissions beyond its allocated allowances will either have to either buy allowances or pay penalties. A company that emits less than expected can sell its surplus allowances to those with shortfalls.
Companies or countries will buy these allowances as long as the price is lower than the cost of achieving emission reductions by themselves.
The carbon price is the price of an allowance to emit one metric ton of carbon dioxide. These allowances are traded for months on the forward market for delivery at a future date and are also reflected in the company’s account for “spot” trading.
Governments will also have to buy carbon credits because the cap-and-trade mechanisms had initially only applied to a fraction of each state’s economy and governments are responsible under the Kyoto Protocol for meeting their country targets. Governments of industrially developed countries and European companies subject to the EU Emission Trading Scheme are the main buyers of carbon credits.
Currently developing countries do not have to meet any target for GHG reductions. However they may develop projects with the potential of mitigating CO2, and the carbon certificates generated from these, known as CERs (Certified Emission Reductions) can be traded in EU-ETS or sold to countries that do have Kyoto targets.
The crisis in the EU-ETS was created by an over supply of carbon credits due to several reasons. The initial “caps” allocated based on a “grandfathering” scheme were deemed to be too generous by many. That led to a lower than anticipated emission of CO2 by companies, resulting in an oversupply of allowances in the market. The on-going recession in Europe and related underproduction across industries also accentuated the situation. Large corporations like Mittal Steel made windfall profits by selling the excess allowances granted to them. The price of carbon crashed to a record low of below Euro 3.00/mtons beginning of this year after European parliament voted against a proposal to support the struggling market.
Bangladesh’s carbon potential
Greenhouse gas (GHG) emission: It is ironic that the country often ranked at the topmost in terms of vulnerability to risks faced from climate change also happens to be the one of the bottommost in terms of CO2 emissions. At an annual emission of 41.61 million Mtons, Bangladesh’s contribution to global emission of 21.43 billion Mtons is barely 0.2%. Per capita emission is in fact the lowest in the world at 0.27 Mtons, against a global average of 4.6Mtons per person.
The above, however, will not remain unchanged with Bangladesh’s development priorities at the forefront and with the country on a high-growth trajectory. What Bangladesh needs to look at is the projection of its carbon potential instead of its present rate of emission. To get a better sense of what that might be, it is useful to look at the country’s dominant sectors in terms of CO2 emissions.
Energy: Electricity generation contributes up to one-third of the country’s total CO2 emissions, and manufacturing/construction contributes to another one-third. Together the two sectors constitute 65% of the country’s total CO2 emissions. The electricity generation is primarily from gas, of which the country is endowed with large natural reserves. Bangladesh currently produces approximately 5,000MW of electricity, but has an ongoing demand of almost double the amount.
If the future projected demand related to the government’s high growth target is taken into account, the country’s immediate electricity shortage could be as high as 5,000MW. Fulfilling this need entirely from gas based electricity generation could easily double the country’s total CO2 emissions. A dilemma that development experts will face is that when gas is one of the few natural resources that Bangladesh is endowed with in abundance, can it afford to forego gas-based electricity generation and instead choose a more clean energy path?
Manufacturing and construction: The other high CO2 emitting sector, manufacturing and construction, poses a different sort of problem. Bricks form the backbone of aggregate requirement of this sector in Bangladesh. Traditionally brick-making in Bangladesh is a small-scale business mostly located in peri-urban areas.
There are over 4,000 brick-making enterprises in the country producing over 12 billion bricks annually. Annual growth rate of the construction sector in Bangladesh has ranged from 8.1% to 8.9% in the last decade and this is expected to continue into the foreseeable future. Traditional brick production, however, is one of the largest sources of GHG emissions in Bangladesh, estimated to be in the order of 6 million tons of CO2 per annum. Outmoded, inefficient, and poorly-constructed kilns and the use of substandard fuels in the kilns have all contributed to such high levels of GHG emissions.
Unless interventions that will induce change in the mode of manufacturing are implemented, GHG emissions will continue to grow unabated. Combine this factor with massive deforestation and land degradation caused by the random sourcing of wood for these outmoded kilns, and we find Bangladesh attaining a carbon emission figure at par with most of its developing neighbours.
Mitigation strategy
The country is set on a course to rapidly develop its economy. Growth is bringing about pressures on its infrastructure which is still at a very low level of development compared to other neighbouring countries (see Table II). There is a chronic shortage of electricity, with demand far exceeding the supply for the last two decades. Power shortage is estimated at 2,500MW to 3,000MW with the current power generation of 5,000MW against the total demand of 7,000 to 7,500 MW. 85% of the country’s electricity is produced using gas, 2% was produced at hydro-electric power plants, 3% by coal, and the rest approximately 10% by using liquid fuel.
Infrastructure in Bangladesh ranks among the worst in the world, securing only the 126th position in 133 nations, according to the Global Competitiveness Report 2009-10 released by the World Economic Forum in 2009. Poor infrastructure, including yawning power and gas shortages, is hurting Bangladesh’s hopes of achieving double-digit economic growth and becoming a middle-income country by 2020. Bangladesh’s economy has grown by 5% to more than 6% each year over the past decade, but the country wants to raise GDP growth to 10% or more in the next 10 years to alleviate poverty.
Although there is pressing demand to improve its index on several social-economic fronts, Bangladesh cannot be oblivious to the ramifications of global climate change playing out on its shores. This means climate change as an issue must come out of being an environmental problem to take centre stage as a major development problem. As the country grows over the coming decades, policy-makers must develop low carbon development options and incorporate not only strategies to build climate resilience into the economy but also evolve mitigation measures for a low carbon development pathway.
The way forward
Develop a strategic energy plan to ensure national energy security along with lower GHG emissions: Being a low energy-consuming but energy-starved country, Bangladesh is unable to meet its present demand for energy despite the low level of energy use. This demand is likely to rise at least 50% faster than GDP per capita in coming years.
Energy security being a fundamental issue of development in Bangladesh, the country has to develop a low GHG emission or carbon neutral energy path, by emphasising energy efficiency as well as renewable energy development. Although there is abundant natural gas, the growing energy gap in Bangladesh is too large to be covered by gas-based power generation within a short period of time.
Economies of scale of a single nuclear power station can outweigh the cost-benefit ratio of several gas-based plants and thereby close the energy gap quickly and efficiently by fewer one-time capital investments.
Renewables face a supply chain and distribution problem in a country where access to the national grid is the major limiting factor. The country needs to look more at distributed energy solutions and build on a value chain based on energy storage options in the case of renewables.
Develop synergy between adaptation and mitigation: The inherent inter-relationship between the two apparently disparate areas of Adaptation and Mitigation had urged IPCC to add an additional chapter in the 4th Assessment Report to explore the trade-off and synergies, the optimal balance and combination, the criteria to gauge outcomes, and to understand when these two areas become substitutes or complements.
But the choices are not always easy. IPCC itself notes: “[A]t a national level, mitigation and adaptation are often cast as competing priorities for policy makers. In other words, interest groups will fight about the limited funds available in a country for addressing climate change, providing analyses of how countries might then make optimal decisions about the appropriate adaptation-mitigation mix.”
The alternative would be to find synergies between the two areas of activities. Bangladesh produced its Climate Change Strategy and Action Plan in 2009, treating strategies for mitigation and adaptation separately with understandable emphasis on the later. Bangladesh may gain from a more holistic approach by mainstreaming mitigation into its development agenda along with adaptation. This may involve a greater involvement of the private sector and a deeper understanding of financing instruments and markets than there has been until now.
Developments in China present new opportunities: New financing instruments may evolve with the emergence of a new nexus of emission trading schemes, previously located in the West and now moving more to the East, and in China more precisely.
China launched its first emission trading programme last June. This development is potentially a milestone in the country’s efforts to reduce GHG emissions and coincides with the dramatic decline of the EU-ETS market. Policy-makers in government as well as entrepreneurs in the private sector may do well to watch this space carefully.
For the scheme to have global relevance, China too will look towards the developing world to find possible synergies with adaptation programmes in those countries, which may provide the underpinnings of a new alternative to CDM financing of projects.
At present China is the world’s largest carbon polluter and burns the equivalent amount of coal as the rest of the world’s countries combined. However, it is currently undertaking significant steps to reduce its contribution to global warming.
The Shenzhen Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) programme launched in June of this year will cover some 635 industrial companies from 26 industries. This is the first of seven proposed pilot GHG cap-and-trade schemes in China, which the country has been developing since 2011.
Besides Shenzhen, four of the other pilots are expected to start trading this year. The potential of Bangladesh linking on to such a scheme is enormous, whereas in the past most of its climate finance activities had its nexus in the West.
Expand the greenbelt coastal afforestation programme: The south-western part of the country is covered by the Sundarbans, the largest mangrove forest of the world. The mangrove forests act as deterrents to the furiousness of tropical cyclones and storm surges. Together with the afforestation programme of mangrove planting along the shoreline, the social forestry programme on government and community lands can be expanded throughout the country, thus improving the net carbon uptake.
At the same time, serious measures must be taken against random deforestation which is often the result of ad hoc construction activities fueled by outmoded and old-fashioned wood-fired brick making furnaces/kilns. The annual deforestation rate in Bangladesh is 3.3% compared to 0.6% in South Asia. Massive afforestation schemes must be undertaken to compensate for this massive loss of forestland.
Explore voluntary markets and develop CDM projects to finance sectoral development: Currently Bangladesh has only a handful of approved CDM projects concerned with solar energy, waste management, improved brick manufacturing, and energy efficient bulbs, whereas India has 1,413 approved projects and Sri Lanka 300. New carbon mitigating technologies can be implemented in different carbon emitting industries such as afforestation and conservation of forests, methane tapping and better use of methane waste, use of electrical vehicles, CFL lamps, etc through emission reduction purchase agreements (ERPA) financed by the global Community Development Carbon Fund (CDCF).
The CDCF supports projects that combine community development attributes with emission reductions to create “development plus carbon” credits, which will significantly improve the lives of the poor and their local environment. With the recent skepticism with the CDM scheme, Bangladesh could look towards new emission trading schemes developing in China and the voluntary markets, both of which have remained largely untapped.
Strengthen human resource capacity: Due to a lack of expertise Bangladesh has been unable to grasp opportunities to effectively use new global financial instruments to finance its mitigation efforts. Also, international climate change negotiations have now entered a phase where Bangladesh as the country most at risk must play a pivotal role in negotiating caps on major carbon emitters. Recent COPs, both in Copenhagen and in Doha, have failed to reach a consensus on a coherent and realistic global policy on climate change.The level of reduction of global emission will influence the magnitude of climate change impacts for countries most at risk, like Bangladesh.
Bangladesh should become a more active participant in the international efforts addressing the underlying causes of climate change and encourage countries to agree to binding targets for reduction of GHG emissions. For this to happen effectively, the country not only needs to have its own robust carbon mitigation strategy, but also enhance its human resource capacity within and outside the government by training at home and abroad.
Bangladesh could also rely more on a non-conventional carbon-free route to economic development by enhancing its human resource potential in the service industry. This can be done by investing significantly more on education and developing IT and other service industries to take up a larger share in its GDP.
By leveraging knowledge capital in combating climate change, Bangladesh will be able to develop its own edge in effectively utilising the cap-and-trade markets, tariffs, regulatory framework, low-carbon technology innovations, and energy conservation schemes to its maximum advantage.



