Despite problems of poor infrastructure, political instability, corruption, and natural disasters, Bangladesh’s economy has continued to grow at a remarkable rate, and there are reasons to be optimistic about the future. For example, Bangladesh should reap the benefits of a “demographic dividend,” as the relative share of the working-age population increases. Whether Bangladesh can benefit from this dividend, however, will depend on the quality of its human capital. Without a skilled labour force, Bangladesh’s demographics could turn into a liability rather than an asset. This analysis examines whether our educational system is preparing Bangladesh’s youth to contribute to the country’s continued economic growth.
Reasons to be optimistic about the future
Past success is a good predictor of future success: Since Bangladesh transitioned to democracy in 1991, the country has averaged GDP growth rates of 4.9% in the 1990s, 6.0% in the 2000s, and 6.3% for the first three years of the 2010s. It is now among the 60 largest economies of the world. Goldman Sachs has included the country in their list of “Next Eleven” while JP Morgan added Bangladesh to its “Frontier Five.”
The demographic dividend: For the latter half of the 20th century, most working age Bangladeshis had to invest their time and income in taking care of a large number of children. These children have since grown up and are contributing to the economy, but they have had far fewer of their own children than their parents’ generation. As shown in Table 1, the result is more working age Bangladeshis with fewer dependent to care for. In 1961, approximately 48.8% of the population had to care for 51.2% of the population. By 2012, however, an estimated 61.6% percent of the population had to care for only 38.4%, freeing up both time and income.Human capital: The missing link
While the country’s growth has been impressive, it has been overwhelmingly driven by remittances and the ready made garments (RMG) export. Remittances totalled Tk1,156bn (US$14.5 billion) in FY 2012-13, accounting for 11.1% of GDP. For the previous fiscal year, it is estimated that the RMG sector employed 4 million workers, accounted for 78.6% of total export earnings, and made up 16.2% of GDP. While these two sources of wealth have been a boon for the country, they are unsustainable. If Bangladesh is to become a middle income country, then wages will necessarily rise and Bangladesh will cease to be an attractive destination for the low-cost garments sector. As such, today’s income from remittances and the RMG sector have to be used to diversify, add value, and grow tomorrow’s economy in new ways. For this to happen, a larger percentage of the Bangladeshi working age population must acquire the skills and abilities to turn disposable time and income into new businesses and innovation.
The education scenario: How are we doing?
In our interviews with entrepreneurs, we consistently hear complaints about the quality of workers, and many business leaders place the blame on the educational system. A glance at the educational sector shows substantial progress but also a very long way to go if Bangladesh is to capitalise on its current growth rates and its demographic dividend.
Literacy rates: While Bangladesh has managed to dramatically raise its literacy levels over the last two decades from 35.3% in 1990 to 56.8% in 2010, as shown in Table 2, the country still lags far below most other emerging economies included in Goldman Sach’s “Next 11.” For example, Asian competitors Vietnam and Indonesia both have literacy rates over 90%.
Enrolment rates: Enrolment rates also reflect good and bad news. As shown in Table 3, enrolment rates have improved considerably over the last 35 years for primary, secondary, and tertiary education. By 2011 the government claimed that primary school enrolment had reached 98.7%. Unfortunately, however, only 66% of these students are likely to complete primary education and only 5% of secondary school entrants are likely to get a higher secondary certificate.Secondary and Higher Secondary Examinations (SSC and HSC)
At first blush, increasing pass rates on SSC and HSC examinations appear to demonstrate progress in student learning. Over the last eight years, the percentage of students passing the SSC exam has increased from 62.2% to 89.7%; the percentage passing the HSC exam has grown from 65.7% to 74.3%; and the percentage of students earning the highest score of GPA 5.0 has almost doubled from 3.2% to 6.3% (See Figure 1). Education board officials have attributed this growth to new teaching methods, expanded teacher training and greater use of textbooks by students.
On further examination, however, there are reasons to believe that these gains are overstated. Several teachers interviewed for this study felt that the government had decreased the exams’ standards rather than improved student learning. For example, in the past year many HSC students who scored the highest score of GPA 5 failed to even pass the Dhaka University admission tests.
University level education: At the university level, it is very encouraging to see that enrolment has doubled in the last decade; however, our own research and non-random survey of 1,100 private university students in Dhaka shows there are still very clear challenges limiting the realisation of students’ potential.
Insufficient critical thinking and problem solving skills: This is the complaint that we hear most often from business leaders and university faculty. As the Bangladeshi education system continues to favour memorisation over understanding and critical thinking, graduates are not prepared to innovate or problem-solve.
Poor English language skills: While English is generally the medium of education at the university level, graduates of Bangla medium higher secondary programs are only rarely able to perform at a university level. In our survey, we found that on average students rated their peers’ English writing, reading, comprehension, and speaking abilities as “advanced intermediate” or below, and faculty offered even lower evaluations.
Acceptance of cheating and plagiarism: Cheating has long been a problem in the Bangladeshi educational system. In 2001, the government launched a massive drive to combat cheating on SSC and HSC exams, resulting in the expulsion of 33,542 students. By 2013 this number had dropped to 690, but it is clear that we are still far from a culture of academic integrity.
Our survey of private university students found considerable evidence and acceptance of cheating and plagiarism. As shown in Table 4, 64.4% of students surveyed admitted to having copied from their peers on a test and 76.8% admitted to having copied and pasted from the internet in writing assignments. Furthermore, 33.9% of surveyed students agreed that “given the way things are in Bangladesh, it is sometimes okay to cheat on a test” and 42.0% agreed that it was sometimes okay to plagiarise (See Table 5). Given that many students would be unwilling to admit to such actions or beliefs on a survey, it is likely that these percentages are actually much higher.
The wrong attitude? Many university faculty members consistently complain that students are unwilling to work hard, but we were surprised to see that many students share this view. As shown in Table 6, when asked for the primary reason why other students’ do not read their assignments or why they cheat on tests and copy and paste from the internet into their assignments, respondents tended to report that an unwillingness to work hard was the primary reason (followed by poor English skills). Perhaps of greater concern: Three-quarters of students (74.2%) agreed with the statement “Success in life is determined by forces outside our control.”Conclusion
Continued deficiencies: While we can see clear and commendable increases in literacy and enrolment rates, both still remain comparatively low. These rates will need to be increased further; however, the risk of inflated SSC and HSC exam scores suggests that we also need to be focused on the quality of education. A look at problems at the university level suggests that we are still falling short of providing our youth with the knowledge, attitudes, and skills that will allow them to continue and expand Bangladesh’s economic development. More attention needs to be paid at all levels of education to improving critical thinking and problem solving skills and to raising English abilities to university standards. In this process, however, our research suggests that we also need to promote a culture of academic integrity and even build the self-esteem and sense of efficacy of our students.