In Tariq Karim’s new book The Tortuous Evolution of South Asian Regional Cooperation: Bangladesh’s Travails for Sub-Regional Cooperation, the quote that genuinely enticed me to read through the whole tome is on the second page of the first chapter: “For several millennia, the people of this ancient, civilizational, and great sub-continent had lived together like one large, very extended, irrepressibly rambunctious joint family. As in joint families, which many of us may still have some lingering memories of, we often tended to be a boisterous lot, made love to as well as quarrel with each other, sometimes walked away from each other in a huff, but then constantly could not stop thinking about each other before finally returning to hug each other.”
The quote embodies a complex mosaic of shared histories, deep-seated tensions, and enduring connections. This metaphor aptly conveys the region's intricate geo-politics, where seemingly discordant elements co-exist in a shared yet fractious reality. Historical milestones, such as the 1947 Partition, which severed old ties but could not wholly erase its members' cultural and economic interdependence, have shaped this metaphorical family's collective struggles and occasional harmony.
The subsequent quote of the author “I would argue, and one may or may not agree with me, that our history of those several millennia together as such a gigantic joint family is primarily marked by longer periods of peaceful co-existence than periods of internecine strife” evokes profound nostalgia (experienced or aspired) for the vibrant unity of pre-Partition South Asia while inspiring optimism through its vision of rekindling regional cooperation, reminding us of the untapped potential of collective progress and shared heritage.
The books I have read on South Asia, as well as my writings and research on it, have only made me realize that the sub-continent is a mosaic of shared heritage, a patchwork quilt of cultures, interwoven threads of history, a fractured mirror of unity, and a labyrinth of geo-political complexities. The book under review delves into these complexities, tracing South Asia's trajectory from integration to fragmentation and its efforts toward regional cooperation.
Each chapter explores a facet of the region's shared struggles: The aftermath of colonialism, the contentious legacy of Partition, and the persistent challenges of economic and political integration. Through vivid narratives, it highlights how Western models of governance, imposed during colonial rule, have facilitated and hindered post-independence progress. The nuanced interplay between traditional identities and modern statehood underscores the region's duality, as seen in the political dynamics of India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh.
Chapter 1 examines the Indian sub-continent's shift from unity to fragmentation following the 1947 Partition. Political decisions rooted in communal tensions disrupted longstanding connections among communities. The chapter delves into the Bengal Presidency, highlighting the economic and cultural consequences of the Partition, especially in the East. The imagery of severed communication routes symbolizes the loss of integration and the challenges of adapting to new realities. This thought-provoking chapter encourages readers to rethink narratives of division and acknowledge enduring ties, emphasizing the region's rich heritage and potential for reconciliation.
Chapter 2 examines the complexities of post-colonial states in South Asia. The author employs Robert Jackson's concept of "negative sovereignty" to highlight weaknesses in newly-formed states, which, while internationally recognized, often lack the necessary institutions and political will for true statehood. The chapter critiques the applicability of the Westphalian model, arguing that it is a European construct resulting in "quasi-states." It also analyzes tensions between Western and Islamic territorial notions and the paradox of Westernization in non-Western societies.
Chapter 3 discusses how Western education and institutions fostered a new elite class that alienated the broader populace. The chapter highlights leaders like Nehru and Jinnah, who faced contradictions in addressing colonial legacies within a diverse society while educated in the West. The discussion also includes India’s Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), which, despite initially rejecting Western nationalism, leveraged Western political structures to advance their nationalist goals. This duality emphasizes the broader theme of non-Western entities grappling with their identities within colonial frameworks, prompting reflection on the ongoing impacts of colonialism.
Chapter 4 examines the formation and challenges of the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC). It contextualizes SAARC's origins amidst historical tensions like the Partition and India-Pakistan relations, discussing initial hopes for collaboration alongside skepticism surrounding Bangladesh's proposal. The chapter highlights economic disparities and mutual distrust among member states, illustrating how the principle of unanimity in the SAARC Charter has hindered progress. While acknowledging the potential for economic ties and people-to-people connections, the author critiques how political realities, including religious extremism and domestic politics, obstruct cooperation.
Chapter 5 analyzes regional integration in Europe, Southeast Asia, and South Asia. It highlights that historical conflicts in Europe and ASEAN led to cooperation for peace, while South Asia faces challenges due to historical animosities, particularly from the India-Pakistan Partition. The chapter underscores the importance of political will, shared vision, and trust for successful integration and discusses SAARC's challenges, including India's economic dominance and the unanimity requirement in decision-making. The author argues against the necessity of conflict for integration, proposing a shift towards collaboration and economic integration. A building-block approach with smaller sub-regional initiatives is suggested, using Bangladesh's successes as a model to foster trust and interdependence in South Asia.
Chapter 6 explores the South Asian Growth Quadrangle (SAGQ) and its potential to enhance regional cooperation amidst SAARC's challenges. The author, reflecting on their time as Bangladesh's Additional Foreign Secretary in the 1990s, advocates for smaller groupings like BBIN, IMS, and IP to achieve better outcomes than broader initiatives. Despite skepticism from Pakistan and Sri Lanka, this sub-regional approach gained interest in the late 1990s, though India's influence raised concerns. The section "BISTEC to BIMSTEC - Still Too Faint a Light" outlines the evolution of BIMSTEC from its formation as BIST-EC in 1997 to its expansion in 2004.
Chapter 7 examines Bangladesh's water-sharing disputes following the 1947 Partition, focusing on the Ganges and Brahmaputra basins shared with India, Nepal, Bhutan, and China. It discusses how the Partition led to conflicts over essential water resources for agriculture and ecosystems. Bangladesh's dependency on its rivers has resulted in significant challenges, especially with dam constructions reducing water flow. The chapter outlines the shift from conflict to collaboration in the 1990s, culminating in a historic Ganges water-sharing treaty with India. It stresses the need for regional cooperation among all riparian countries for sustainable management of shared water resources.
Chapter 8 reflects South Asian diplomacy, focusing on Bangladesh-India relations. As an Additional Foreign Secretary for South Asia, the author discusses the historical mutual suspicion that has hindered cooperation, particularly in the Ganges water-sharing dispute. He highlights how Bangladesh's political leadership initially rejected India's overtures and examines key events like the 1975 assassination of Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, which strained relations and reshaped regional geopolitics. Ultimately, it emphasizes the resilience of regional cooperation, notably through the Gujral Doctrine and renewed subregional initiatives.
Chapter 9 examines historical and contemporary issues between Bangladesh and India, rooted in the 1947 Partition and Bangladesh's 1971 independence. It discusses concerns such as security, borders, and water sharing, noting an improvement in relations after the 1996 election, which led to the 2011 Land Boundary Agreement. The chapter also highlights advancements in trade and connectivity following India's removal of trade barriers in 2011, emphasizing key agreements that foster deeper regional cooperation.
Chapter 10 discusses the stalled progress of SAARC and the emergence of the BBIN (Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Nepal) initiative. It outlines the diplomatic challenges posed by Pakistan's opposition to agreements, particularly the SAARC Motor Vehicles Agreement (MVA). Despite these hurdles, India and Bangladesh collaborated effectively within the BBIN framework, highlighting the importance of regional integration for South Asia's economic future. The chapter details the journey to the MVA's signing in June 2015, emphasizing India's pivotal role. It also covers milestones like the 2015 BBIN Friendship Motor Rally and early 2016 Joint Working Group meetings focused on connectivity and resource management.
Chapter 11 discusses the author's efforts to promote South Asian regional integration after his term as India's High Commissioner ended in 2014. As a World Bank advisor, he concentrated on enhancing sub-regional cooperation within the BBIN framework. The chapter highlights strategic meetings with stakeholders in India, Bhutan, and Bangladesh, focusing on water management, energy cooperation, and multimodal connectivity. Key topics included Bhutan's prime minister backing a Brahmaputra River conference and exploring joint hydropower projects despite political and bureaucratic challenges. The potential for reviving river transport for improved regional connectivity, alongside its economic and environmental benefits, is also discussed.
Chapter 12 examines how South Asian elections hinder regional cooperation, particularly in India and Bangladesh. The author notes that political issues like immigration and communal tensions often dominate election discourse, with Indian leaders employing anti-Bangladeshi rhetoric during the 2013 and 2019 elections, which strained bilateral relations. The chapter highlights how election rhetoric can undermine diplomatic efforts and create uncertainty for future collaboration.
Chapter 13 highlights the advancements in rail connectivity between India and Bangladesh. The chapter addresses challenges such as customs procedures. It showcases developments essential for subregional cooperation and connecting landlocked areas like Tripura to larger markets, with potential future integration into regional networks like ASEAN, contributing to stability and growth in South Asia.
Chapter 14 reflects South Asia's complex post-Partition history and its struggle for regional unity. The author suggests that a catastrophic event might be necessary to ignite a commitment to peace and reunification, highlighting the urgency of resolving entrenched conflicts. Drawing parallels to Europe's long path to cooperation post-Westphalia, the author argues that South Asia must expedite its integration. The chapter concludes by advocating for a more inclusive governance structure to foster cooperation and reduce polarization, offering a critical yet hopeful vision for South Asia's future.
The book illustrates vividly that South Asia remains ensnared in a cycle of mistrust, poor governance, and religious complexities, perpetuating regional conflicts. This persistent strife overshadows the immense potential for interconnectivity and collaborative progress through regional coalitions, which, if realized, could transform shared resources, trade, and cultural ties into a foundation for mutual prosperity. While the book offers a compelling exploration of South Asia's geo-politics, it would have done greater justice to the topic and the stakeholders’ roles had it included a chapter or discussion on the grassroots perspectives.
The book under-explored the role of youth and civil society and lacks concrete, actionable solutions to break the enduring cycles of mistrust and fragmentation. This book is invaluable for scholars, policy-makers, and students of geo-politics, providing profound insights into South Asia's complexities.
The book's narrative unfolds like a story, blending history, politics, and personal reflections into a vivid tapestry of South Asia's trials and triumphs. Its rich metaphors, evocative anecdotes, and nuanced portrayals offer fertile inspiration for crafting a fictional tale rooted in similar settings. The tale captures the region's fragmented unity, cultural complexities, and geopolitical tensions while addressing mistrust, resilience, and the enduring hope for regional harmony.
South Asia’s geopolitical landscape resembles a kaleidoscope -- its vibrant patterns emerge from fragmented pieces, shifting perspectives with every turn. Like the parable of the six blind men and the elephant, each observer grapples with only a part of the picture -- religious discord, economic inequality, or environmental crises -- never fully grasping the whole. This paradox of simplicity and complexity defines South Asia, where unity and division co-exist, creating a narrative as intricate as a tapestry of ancient threads stretched taut by modern challenges. The book reflects this duality, with the author’s account serving as both a compass and a lens, guiding readers through these layered realities.
Syed Shahnawaz Mohsin is a political and international affairs analyst.



