Coalitions are often good for politics. In the first place, they strip away at the hubris of political parties which have begun to feel they are invulnerable. In the second, they are a healthy sign of politics being re-energised through compelling political parties and politicians to come together in the broad national interest. And, of course, coalition governments are a clear desire on the part of the electorate for change, however minimal, in a nation’s body politic.
The African National Congress, having enjoyed unchallenged authority in South Africa for three decades, has now been forced into a coalition with the Democratic Alliance. In the years since apartheid was brought to an end in the country, the ANC and the DA have never felt comfortable in each other’s company. But with South Africans deciding that the ruling ANC did not qualify for more than 159 seats in a 400-seat parliament, it became obvious that change had become necessary.
Coalition governments are a reminder for politicians that it is the issues that matter. Unemployment, weak internal security and a worsening economy undercut the authority of political parties which happen to be in power for a long stretch of time. And that is precisely the rap the ANC has been given on the knuckles by voters. President Cyril Ramaphosa has been re-elected to office, but with the support of the DA and the Inkatha Freedom Party, which now prop up the ANC in power. For Nelson Mandela’s disciples, it is quite a climbdown.
But, yes, coalitions are tentative affairs too. They can unravel when the junior partners in them decide that circumstances do not allow them to continue being part of the re-arranged government generally set up after an indecisive election. Such possibilities give sleepless nights to the leaders of the major parties in coalitions, whose worry is that one fine morning, with the departure of a coalition partner, they might be compelled to go for fresh elections. Coalitions often survive on the sufferance of junior partners in the arrangement.
These political realities will not permit the ANC to sleep well. Much a similar situation now assails Narendra Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) in India. Like the ANC, the BJP has lost its clear majority in the Lok Sabha, going home after the election with no more than 240 seats in a 543-seat parliament. The BJP has not lost power, for its alliance partners in the National Democratic Alliance (NDA), the Telegu Desam Party and Nitish Kumar’s Janata Dal, have helped it form a government at the centre. The Modi-led coalition will hold as long as Chandrababu Naidu and Nitish Kumar feel there are the advantages they can derive from being part of the government.
One does not require much imagination to understand the precariousness underlying political coalitions. Even so, such coalitions are a necessary happening in modern democracies. That democracy is not a system of winner-take-all is a good lesson drawn from coalitions. A coalition government is a humbling affair, for it often checks the arrogance of politicians who have begun to feel complacent about their long hold on power. Since in a democracy political change can be brought about only through an exercise of the popular will, elections which throw up results that do not give majorities to particular parties are a refreshing way for politics to have balance restored in governance.
Certain coalitions work in beautiful ways. In West Germany in the mid-1960s, Kurt-George Kiesinger’s CDU and Willy Brandt’s SPD entered into what was described as a grand coalition after elections that did not give a clear majority to either party. The coalition worked for three years, until Brandt decided in 1969 to go for a coalition with the small Free Democrats. Brandt assumed the office of chancellor and subsequently promoted Ostpolitik, which in terms of history is generally considered to be the first step toward détente between the capitalist West and the communist East in the Cold War climate of the times.
Coalitions can be wobbly affairs too. Indira Gandhi lost to a coalition of the opposition arrayed against her in 1977 but returned to power three years later when the coalition came apart. The coalition against Mrs Gandhi fell largely because it was based more on the ego factor working in her enemies than any policy perspectives designed to reshape India’s future. Observe the chaotic state of affairs in Pakistan as they exist at present. The government headed by Shehbaz Sharif and his Muslim League survives with the support, provided from outside, by the Pakistan People’s Party.
Pakistan’s is not a formal coalition but a carefully contrived method, helped not a little by its military, of keeping the incarcerated Imran Khan’s Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf out of the power structure. The PTI won the election but through subterfuge by Khan’s political rivals and the machinations of its ubiquitous army was deprived of the opportunity of returning to power. Given Pakistan’s history of political intrigue, it is not likely that the PML-PPP combine will endure. The ambitious Zardaris will not wait too long to take charge of the country. Or the army, true to its game of manipulating politics, will bring the government down.
Coalitions in undemocratic circumstances worsen the state of politics in a country. In nations where democracy has been the underlying principle of governance, though, coalitions are a message to politicians, especially in ruling parties, to get their act together, indeed to do away with the regressive politics they may have pursued in the four or five years between the last election and the latest exercise of the vote.
That will be a big worry for the young Emmanuel Macron, who has called snap elections to the French parliament in light of the remarkable performance by the far-right National Rally at the European Union elections. If Marine Le Pen’s followers win the election on 30 June, President Macron, who will be in office till 2027, will be forced into cohabitation with a party whose policies run counter to the beliefs of liberal and centrist elements in France. Francois Mitterrand did not have a comfortable time when his socialists were forced into cohabitation with the political right.
But there is the other picture too. Every coalition is an opportunity for the junior partners in it to comprehend the meaning of authority and learn how to master the instruments of power.
Finally, coalitions point to the limits to unchecked authority by parties long used to absolute exercises of power. They are as well a shot in the arm for democracy, for democracy is a constant process of re-engineering. Coalitions prevent the powers that be from slipping into the grasp of elements out to promote their vested interests.
When democracy comes under threat from the arrogant and the unenlightened and the power hungry, political coalitions become a needed roadblock to the fulfillment of the dangerous ambitions of these elements.
Syed Badrul Ahsan is Consultant Editor, Dhaka Tribune.



