Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Young Pakistanis need to know about 1970-1971

It was not Indian conspiracy or Bengali secessionism which led to their army’s defeat in Bangladesh

 

Update : 15 Feb 2024, 05:08 PM

The recent election in Pakistan has raised some interesting points in the country on the fallout of the general election of December 1970. With the Islamabad authorities going out of the way in denying the clear ballot box triumph of the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf, a good number of Pakistanis aware of the history shaping up in in their country have expressed the fear that the mistake made in depriving Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman and his Awami League of the right to ascend to power in Islamabad more than five decades ago might be repeated all these decades later.

It is a new generation of Pakistanis that has in recent years been revisiting history and has been boldly drawing attention to what the military junta and its collaborators did wrong in the period between December 1970 and December 1971. In these 53 years since Yahya Khan and his military junta subverted the results of the 1970 election and plunged Pakistan into a deep crisis through unleashing a genocide of Bengalis in occupied Bangladesh, new generations of Pakistanis have been born and have discreetly begun to inquire into the reality of how 1971 came to be.

In the recent past, Imran Khan himself reminded Pakistanis of the atrocities committed by the Pakistan army in Bangladesh. There have been intellectuals like Pervez Hoodbhoy who have courageously informed crowds at literary festivals and on other occasions of the terrible wrong that was done to Bengalis through not only a repudiation of the results of the election but also an organised massacre of the very people who had voted en masse for the Awami League, enabling it to govern the entirety of Pakistan.

On Pakistani television talk shows and in Pakistani newspapers on such occasions as 16 December every year, participants and columnists are patently upset by the fact that the army committed such misdeeds in 1971. Even the centenarian Roedad Khan, who once lauded the army when it went into action in Bangladesh, has in recent years been contrite about the atrocities committed by the Yahya Khan junta.

And yet there is a whole lot that Pakistanis yet need to be enlightened on about 1971. When men like the former army chief, General Qamar Bajwa, proclaim that Pakistan’s predicament was a political and not a military defeat, it is but another attempt to mislead Pakistanis with a false narrative. Politicians like Javed Jabbar, despite being fully aware of the ground realities of 1971, during television conversations with young Pakistanis, have offered the false explanation that in that year it was foreign, meaning Indian, conspiracy which dismembered Pakistan.

No mention is made of the fact that the crisis was precipitated by the refusal of the Pakistani civil-military bureaucracy, in alignment with its political collaborators, to permit the majority party to form the government in Islamabad.

The discussions which have been going on in Pakistan since the February 8 election should be the beginning of a process by which the historical misinformation that has persisted in the country could be discarded in favour of an acknowledgement, at the official level, of what transpired in 1971.

Not much light has been shed on the role played by Zulfikar Ali Bhutto and his Pakistan People’s Party in undermining the mandate given by the people of Bangladesh to Sheikh Mujibur Rahman to reconfigure the state of Pakistan through the Six Points of the Awami League. That the PPP, with its supporters in the military officer class, helped in a subverting of the political process, has not been much discussed in Pakistan. That lapse needs correction.

Pakistan’s official history speaks of the country’s first elected government assuming office in December 1971 through Bhutto taking over as president from a disgraced Yahya Khan. That version is misleading for Pakistanis, for they have been kept away from the truth of the PPP assuming power by default. By that time, of course, Bangladesh had emerged as a sovereign state after a strenuous guerrilla war against the Pakistan army.

Such a reality does not appear in Pakistan’s official history of the war. It should be for Pakistan’s politicians, scholars, journalists and academics to undertake a campaign of presenting history in its true colours. That the election of December 1970 produced a winner in the Awami League, that the People’s Party came a distant second, that the military had no intention of transferring power to Sheikh Mujibur Rahman should be part of textbooks and discussions in Pakistan.

The generations of Pakistanis born after the war need to be informed about the role of the generals -- Tikka Khan, AAK Niazi, Rao Farman Ali, Khadim Hussain Raja and others -- in the massacre of Bengalis during the nine months of the crisis. The millions of Bengalis, ordinary citizens as also leading intellectuals killed, the women raped, the villages and towns destroyed, are information which should go out to Pakistanis who have all along been given a wrong or sanitised version of history.

Additionally, the role played by Maulana Maududi and his Jamaat-e-Islami as well as the Muslim League and other right-wing political parties in collaborating with the army on its murder missions will need to be focused on if Pakistan seriously means to have productive diplomatic relations with Bangladesh in future.

Pakistanis have never been informed that in March 1971 it was only the Awami League which had worked out detailed plans regarding the future constitutional set-up in the country. It remains a sad commentary on history that prior to his departure for Dhaka on March 15, General Yahya Khan had no idea of what the Six Points were and indeed asked his advisors for a copy that he could go through.

Besides, when Bhutto first travelled to Dhaka in late January 1971 after the election, he did not focus on constitution-making with Bangabandhu but was more interested in a power-sharing arrangement with the Awami League that would have him play a role in it. Similarly, when on March 21, he returned to Dhaka on Yahya Khan’s instructions, his party had no position paper prepared on a resolution of the crisis. These are historical details that need to be discussed in Pakistan today.

That Bangladesh was a part of Pakistan put to the torch by the Pakistan army is a truth Pakistanis need to discuss in public. That the Yahya Khan team left Dhaka stealthily on the evening of March 25, 1971 without bringing a formal end to the negotiations with the Awami League or without informing the leader of the majority party remains an abomination Pakistanis need to know about.

That the elected leader of the majority party, who should have been prime minister of Pakistan, was arrested and flown to (West) Pakistan to face trial on charges of sedition, that he was kept in solitary confinement and sentenced to death by a military tribunal -- these are important segments of history Pakistanis should be discussing as they ponder the future of their country in light of the February 8 election.

Pakistan’s young people need to go back to history -- to understand that it was not Indian conspiracy or Bengali secessionism which led to their army’s defeat in Bangladesh. They ought to be educated on the denial of democratic and constitutional rights, coupled with the killings by the army, which led to the decision by Bangladesh’s people to wage war against Pakistan and have their sovereign state emerge in mid-December 1971.

 

Syed Badrul Ahsan is Consultant Editor, Dhaka Tribune.

Top Brokers