Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Winning the global Race-to-the-Bottom

Update : 04 Aug 2013, 05:17 AM

It took the tragedy of Savar collapse, and more importantly a blow to the RMG sector (projected significant reduction of foreign orders), to initiate a serious discussion about labour rights and labour voices in Bangladesh. The prayer remains that the discussion gains traction, and urgently resolves the pressing issue at stake. Indifference can be made an option but it ought to be a recipe for disaster.

The tragic event along with the accompanied issues have been discussed and debated by myriad experts, at various levels and from distinct perspectives. A lot of argument has been about economic growth versus value-oriented cost of labour exploitation. As expected, the economic argument sounds most intellectually appealing.

As for me, I can only imagine the pure economic value that those 1,100-plus individuals would have added to our economy during their lifetime. I bet it would be a lot more than the cost of maintaining good labour standards and required regulations. Anyhow, the discussion at large has remained inward-looking, and a broader discussion has to be undertaken from a zoomed-out view. Where is Bangladesh in the global economy? Is it winning the race to the bottom?

When Nobel Laureate economist Joseph Stiglitz talked about the notion “race to the bottom,” I could only imagine that he envisioned the state of affairs of Bangladesh jotted all over the crafted notion. Before dipping into a critical argument, I must give a disclaimer: this post is not an RMG sector bashing rhetoric.

The achievements and the advancements of the Bangladeshi garments sector are well-celebrated and well-understood in most circles. It is the cash cow of Bangladesh. It inculcates 80% of our exports, contributes significantly to our economy by $20bn, reduces trade deficit, creates 4 million jobs and in turn fosters social empowerment for young women. It’s past exponential growth and the prospected future growth is also commendable. However, big accomplishments should bring big responsibilities!

The plight of Bangladeshi societal economic conditions, many of which are born due to the prevalence of the cash cow, have to be analysed. There are problems which some would consider as unintended consequences of global capitalism; I would rather state them as structural economic problems which we shouldn’t settle for.

The prominent problem is the race to the bottom: essentially the argument that in an unregulated global capitalist order “competition” will dictate transnational corporations (TNC) to ravage the land and labour of (mostly) developing nations which are offering the lowest non-common denominator standards. Unfortunately for Bangladesh, it is winning this gross race where compromise hits rock-bottom in a case for competition of retaining business.

Why mostly developing countries? The honest reality is that western societies do not wish their land and labour to be grossly exploited, and that is the reason the garments industry is in places like Bangladesh. The western world have refused to live in hyper-polluted environments and compromised standards of living dictated by market forces. Early on, they have adhered to labour empowerment via trade unions that has served them well for a good amount of time, at least until the 21st century.

The argument against “race to the bottom” is the lower cost of labour (read lower labour standards in between lines) keeps Bangladesh on a competitive edge and helps our society prosper. The argument does have a lot of weight, but it should not be solely viewed from a market fundamentalist perspective.

The question is how low the labour standards need to be. Do we need to hyper-commodify labour? Does the cost of labour need to be five times less than that of China? Does the labour cost need to be the lowest in the world? Does it need to be “slave labour,” as proclaimed by the spiritual leader of 1.2 billion Catholics (read consumers)?

Does it need to be $0.25/hr –below the UN wage estimate of $2/hr – which is just enough to keep the individual and her/his family afloat on the poverty line? Do they deserve a minimum wage or a living wage? And all these wage and compensation compromise, when profits are (or were) surging in the sector and income inequality is alarmingly broadening in the society!

What are the real costs and negative externalities at stake? These are just a few from a laundry list of hard questions that we cannot shy away from. Neither should we hide behind the mask of realism, posing the argument of business loss to competition. Global competition is a reality, but so is the plight of our labour/society. And, these shouldn’t be false choices. After all, what is the point of growth without real development?

The race to the bottom doesn’t stop at low wage non-benefit oriented labour standards in Bangladesh. It is reflected in the complacent regulatory measures by authorities to conduct appropriate oversight. The infamous account of 18 regulators for over 100,000 facilities in Dhaka is shameful compared to global standards. The degraded environmental accounts of Bangladesh are also negative exemplars. Just to pick on one of the worst: the defamed ravaging of our land and air in the tanneries of Hazaribagh, a complementary export industry to garments, is another achievement of low standards.

The tanneries there discharge about 30,000 cubic metres of liquid chemical waste every day on our lands and waters. By that count it would fill the Empire State Building every week. The solid waste and chemical fumes also come with the package. Alarming indeed!

Another structural problem remains – that of crony capitalism. The fact that over 10% of our lawmakers are owners of our cash-cow RMG factories, and a significantly higher number is estimated to have business links, disrupts the fundamental nature of global competitive market mechanism.

If you believe that is a chance phenomenon, then there is little to have a progressive conversation. But the “business losing to competition” argument has no grounds when the nature of the business is crony, which inhibits innovation and production at the very early and local level of global supply chain.

Now, let’s come to the question: where is Bangladesh in the global economy? As an RMG export-oriented economy it is at the beginning of the supply chain. It is an important one because it is the second biggest exporter and, if similar growth remains (just may be!), it is expected to become the biggest in few years. Hence, the importance of Bangladesh is not negligible. However, it is surely vulnerable.

Overlooking the newly-earned uneasy reputation, the low labour cost and low standards cannot be seen as an incentive forever. Neither can we milk the cow dry. At a macro-level, if even the slightest bit of global market mechanism works, then the TNCs will move on to a different place. May be to neighbouring Myanmar or somewhere in Africa! They are not expected to have any loyalty.

Despite the huge labour pool, labour will not be cheap forever. Other than labour and special share of the supply market, unfortunately for Bangladesh, there is no other bargaining chip. In these aspects, China was in our seat some years ago but they diversified simultaneously, faced the reality and moved on.

We have not made our labour force even pseudo-skilled. We have to build human capital – there is no alternative. We have kept our economy vulnerable to one sector. Neither are we talking about serious diversification of the economy. We keep justifying the status-quo because “we can’t find another labour intensive sector, as every other sector is capital intensive.”

The western model of post-industrial-revolution development, where the “economy matures” from one sector to another, may not work for Bangladesh because we are at a new era of modernisation. Bangladesh has to realise so. Today, everyone in the global supply chain is supposed to be winners of globalisation. But the unfortunate truth is: winners are only the middle people.

In case of garment sector it’s the garment agencies and international buyers/retailers whose profit-share is significantly high. Losers are the consumers and the labours. Consumers (mostly in the West) because they are under-empowered and contribute to externalities, and in real terms don’t benefit from the low cost of production. And labour because of obvious reasons, some of which are underlined above. 

Top Brokers